Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Florida >
Feb 4, 2008 06:48 AM

Bay House Restaurant North Naples

The Bay House restaurant, in North Naples, has a new chef and wonderful food. The setting has always been beautiful-a warm, old Florida atmosphere overlooking the Cocohatchee River. However, the menu had been old fashioned and uninviting. With the arrival of a new chef and more interesting menu, MsRev and I decided to give it a go with some friends.

The menu has some Southern, mostly seafood, and tilted towards the low country cuisine of Charleston and Savannah.

Crispy fried oysters with Cajun remoulade were ethereal. They serve some of the best mussels I’ve had down here. They don’t use the ubiquitious New Zealand green-lipped and taste more like mussels we ate in Italy last fall. Crushed olive Caesar was quite tasty, an interesting twist on the usual Caesar. The beet carpaccio was a bit bland. If soft shelled crab is offered as a special appetizer, order it. Even the hot out of the oven buns were delicious.

The shrimp and grits entree is to do die for. It’s better than any we’ve had in the low country itself. Other entrees we thoroughly enjoyed were the oven roasted black grouper, seared jumbo sea scallops, and roasted sea bass with artichoke and shrimp fritters.

They serve a respectable key lime pie and crème brulee. Chocolate cake was a bit heavy and doughy.

Prices are moderate, with all seafood entrees under $30 (unfortunately, that’s moderate for Naples nowadays).

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. how did I miss this rec? You access this on the southwest side of the bridge? LilMsFoodie

    2 Replies
    1. re: LilMsFoodie

      The entrance is actually about 100 yards south of the bridge, on the west side. There's 1 street, who's name I don't recall, which you turn into, and after about 25 yards you'll see a sign for the Bay House-turning right.

      1. re: RevrendAndy

        Glad to hear about this new chef. Sounds interesting. Maybe this place deserves another try. Bay House is on Walkerbilt Road, west side of 41, 1/2 mile north of Immokalee Rd. It's easy to miss.

    2. I've always loved this restaurant for the setting, and when I went back recently with my dad as we've done in the past, I really loved the food. I actually quite liked the beet carpaccio, and the sea scallops were cooked perfectly. They weren't dishes I would normally order, but I did and I loved them. They were actually on the summer tasting menu! Great deal. It pays to hang out in Naples in the summer, I tell you. Now I wish I could go back and try the shrimp and grits (hopefully it'll be there the next time I'm home!).

      1. I second Rev's recommendation on the oysters. Next visit I'll the shrimp and grits, I can only order so much!

        I wrote up my two-top's meal at:


        The special pricing may go up, for all places, when season hits Naples.

        1. Fort Myers News-Mess reviews Bay House today with the highest rating I've seen him give for a long time.

          2 Replies
          1. re: LilMsFoodie


            The NewsMess is just that on food writing lately. A mess of sloppiness and incompetence. I think their reviewer reads other's reviews to know what to rave about. Sad.

            To destroy any further credibility, read their Wednesday's "The year's 10 best restaurants make dining great" .


            If you can't get it on line, their "Year's 10 Best" list includes Angelinas and Bonefish Grill, (I like both, that's fine) Then Eastside Firepit City Grill" at Gulf Coast Town Center, overpriced Trilogy in Naples, Artistic Deli, Holiday Inn's Cafe 2431, Cirella's Italian Bistro, Crave, Crust, Il Pomodoro, and Rain Sushi Bar. Huh?

            No mention of Sea Salt, IM Tapas, M Waterfront, Escargot 41, Eurasia, H2's, A Table Apart, Thistle Lodge, fun Yabo's, deparated Cru, or a dozen others ANYONE would rank ahead of some of their "top ten" for the year 2008. "Sloppy Ten" I call it, -for sloppy journalism in claiming, in a headline no less, that these are the Top in Collier and Lee Counties,- and laziness in not trying to pick out the "(somewhat) generally accepted" outstanding, or creative places, for inclusion in such a "Top Ten" list.

            We, collectively, could have come up with far, far better list. "Jean LePouf" used to be a very sharp critc a few years ago, now the current one is an inexperienced seemingly 20-something who needs 10 years of diing out before she has a palate to discuss dining with any credibility. Is she the editor's daughter? There is a blogger with the same newspaper about 10 years old, who has a more discerning palate, and even knows the best kept restrooms in town! Two good reasons why one should just ignore the current Jean Le Boeuf, and let her first get good at reviewing restrooms before letting her even think of handling restaurants.

            I learned to trust Karen Feldman's reviews in the upstart newspaper, the I ignored the Naples Daily News' gaggle of food writers for the most part, since competent critic Linda Gordon passed away over a year ago. Chiara is the only one I'll read. Maybe Fort Myers' current Jean Le Pouf came from the NDN flock of failed food writers?

            That's why I started my food blog for my friends, and learned about Chowhound. When you can no longer trust the newspaper food writers, someone with taste and ability to write hopefully will fill the void. Let me know when such a person comes to those other two 'mainstream" newspapers.

            1. re: An Insatiable Appetite

              I read that list and laughed. That Holiday Inn 2431 is ghastly and in the space of the unlamented Char. Cirellas? Crave...Why, Nice food, spartan interior, really not much going on there at all. Crust is nice, but not great for a top 10 list.


          2. While I enjoy Crust, Wyld's Cafe, it's sister restaurant, has better food and more sophisticated cooking. Bonefish is good but I don't believe a chain restaurant should be on that list. At least they picked Angelina's for best Italian. The readers of the Reno Gazette have chose Olive Garden as best Italian in Reno the last few years.