January 2008 Best and Worst for DC Restaurant Week
Starting with the excellent list (http://www.chowhound.com/topics/311574) that Lowbar posted in 2006, I have added some relevant information: the lists are now alphabetical, and I've added notes for the restaurants that are extending their Restaurant Week prices past the official end of the week.
1. Very Good
2. Good but Limited Menu or Limited Value:
Georgia Brown's (1/25/08)
Smith & Wollensky
Teatro Goldoni (1/27/08)
Butterfield 9 (service)
Mie N Yu (1/27/08)
Taberna del Alabardero
Having done that, I'd like to post a question for the board. Here are some more restaurants that are extending their Restaurant Week prices. Which of the three above categories should they be placed in? Let me know, and I'll edit this post appropriately.
Jaleo - Jan. 27
Urbana - Jan. 27
Oyamel - Jan. 28
Dino - Jan. 31
Farrah Olivia - Jan. 31
Il Mulino - Jan. 31
Mio - Jan. 31
Oya - Jan. 31
Tabaq Bistro - Jan. 31
Posh - Feb. 2
Clearly people are going to disagree but I would never put Butterfield 9 on the avoid list. I've had multiple RW experiences there and it's always been great....service and otherwise. The only complaints I've seen this year is a slightly limited menu but they still offer up 4 entrees which is more then places like Taberna offer. Just my 2 cents.
I took the list from an old, quite good discussion on DC Restaurant week:
My additions at the end of the list were from a DC Foodies discussion, in which someone had come up with a list of various restaurants extending their Restaurant week price specials:
I'd be glad to adjust the above list in any way that the consensus develops, including adding restaurants or changing their rankings. Personally, I can't claim to have eaten at all of these restaurants; in fact, I was looking at these forums to get ideas about which restaurant to try. Mostly, I'd like to know peoples' opinions on the rest of the restaurants that have extended their specials, because many of the top restaurants are already booked solid for this week.
The link above didn't work for me--probably because it has now been a few months. We just went to Indebleu two weeks ago with some friends and were very disappointed. Wish I had written in sooner when I remembered more of what we ordered but I still wanted to steer people away from this place who are looking for either good Indian (lots of better options as well detailed on this board) or fusion. We heard the new chef had been sous chef at another, more heralded DC eatery (forgetting which one) and, by all accounts, he/they are still trying to figure out what they want to be. No naan. Very uninspired appetizers and generally overpriced, very mediocre food. Disappointing. We should have known since it was our 6th choice for dinner after our first five couldn't accomodate a same day request on a Saturday. And, it was mostly empty at 8pm when we were there.
We went to Oceanaire last night after all the great RW reviews. It wasn't a great experience. First they seated us in what must be their small events room that they must not always use at this tiny table in the corner, which later they couldn't even fit all of our food on. The menu was so boring and small we ended up eating off the regular menu. For starters the choice was regular salad, ceaser salad or clam chowder (which is good, but I have had it at so many events). I can't remember exactly what the entree choices were, but there were only three I know one was mahi-mahi (so boring available anywhere with no unique preperation and one was small scallops forget where they were from with red wine reduction (with no side) and I forget the third, but it wasn't crabcakes. With all their fresh fish and huge portions you would think they could have offered some of their fresh offerings for the day, or some appetizers or sides as first courses. So anyway we ordered off the regular menu since we would have to order sides anyway so it would have been about the same price. The potatoes au gratin were just some quartered potatoes toped with tons of cheese, not potatoes au gratin, the steamed broccoli was good, huge portion, but it was just steamed broccoli.
I hope other people had a better experience. I would add this to the avoid list unless they change the menu next year. The fish I offered off the regular fresh menu was good, BF thought his wasn't great, so we probably won't be going back unless with his parents who seem to love the place, but they aren't hounds...
I went to Bistro Bis earlier this week. You expect them to rush to turn over the table during Restaurant Week, but the service was actually very slooooow. And, even though you can't get a reservation, they were a lot of open tables (maybe they budget a lot of time for each sitting?).
Anyway, I had the mussels appetizer ($4 up charge). There were a ton of mussels and they were very good. They didn't bring us bread (accidentally forgotten), but when I saw another table get some, I asked. The sauce was yummy and I wanted to dip. My friend had the french onion soup which looked good (I didn't taste it).
I had the trout for my entree. It came with some crunchy croutons on top, along with green beans and a rich sauce. It was good, but I would have liked some sort of potato or something, and it was a little rich.
I had the chocolate toffee bread pudding for dessert. Yummy!! My friend got the Roulade de Chocolat, which was not very good. He tried mine and liked it much more.
Someone needs to update this list, or even make a new thread, regarding any changes that occurred in '08 RW's to prep for the upcoming 09 one.
- Butterfield 9 and Corduroy are no longer participating.
- Would move Oceanaire to either #2 or #3 lists. The food was excellent and the service was good, but the RW menu was positively TINY and very lame. Only three entre choices and appetizer was limited to an extremely tiny cup of soup or tiny and boring salad.