Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Jan 11, 2008 01:10 PM

Why aren't my waffles crispy? Help!

We make waffles frequently on the weekends and I just can't seem to get them to come out crispy from the waffle iron. I use a Vitantonio Premier waffle maker with the small holes (not a Belgian waffle maker). I spray the iron each time with cooking spray and I've tried lots of waffles made from scratch and the Bisquick ones. I cook them to a medium brown, but they just don't seem to crisp up like I'd like (and I don't want dry, just crispy on the outside).

I've even gone so far as to take them out of the waffle iron and then sort of "pan fry" them in a little butter in my cast iron skillet. Works better but seems awfully labor intensive!

Don't know if I need to change the iron temp (I cook on "medium") or if I need a new waffle iron (it's 10 years old) or what. It seems to work fine otherwise.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. It sounds as if the iron isn't cooking at a high enough temperature. I'd try turning the iron to the highest setting, first (the thermostat may not be giving a correct reading, keeping the temp too low), before considering getting a new iron. The good news, though, is that a new waffle iron will only set you back about $20.

    My Blog:

    6 Replies
    1. re: sirregular

      Not $20. He has a Vintantonio model 1800 - the finest waffler known to man. Lack of Butter or
      too low a heat is his problem. At 1100 watts, this waffler does a good job. Is it broken?
      Set the temp high and it should work.
      on eBay, they run about $40. +
      Jack C.

      1. re: Jack Chambles

        No, it wasn't broken. The operator was broken. LOL I didn't have it on high because I thought they would burn. I crank it full bore now and it works perfectly!

        And you're right, they aren't $20!! LOL

        and I'm a she.... :) (always hard to tell on these boards!)

        1. re: Scirocco

          Yum, just purchased the Vintantonio 1800 from eBay and got delicious crisp waffles my first try baking on high temp as you've suggested! Thanks.

        2. re: Jack Chambles

          It may make great waffles, but some models of the Vitantonio, including some Model 1800s, had wiring defects that would present a shock hazard after repeated use due to abraded insulation. Anyone owning or buying one of these on eBay or wherever, please check the wiring often, and always plug it into a properly grounded outlet.

          1. re: HappyBunnyLove

            I still use this same one (I am the OP), but I always turn the temp knob all the way down (not sure it really has an "off") and unplug it each time we remove the last waffle.

            I used to have a different one that didn't have any temp knob at all (not sure the brand) and to turn it "off" you had to unplug it from the wall. It started throwing a few sparks when we'd unplug it. It went straight into the trash!!

            1. re: Scirocco

              Usually when things throw sparks when they are unplugged it's because power is still flowing in the unit. Very odd that there wasn't a way to turn the heat level down. Design flaw!

      2. Two things, in my experience, make for a crispy waffle: high waffle iron temp AND butter-laden recipe. You just need a LOT of butter in the batter for waffles to brown. More than in pancake batter

        6 Replies
        1. re: doc_k55

          Thanks! Ya, I was wondering if I should crank the temp up some more to get that high heat "sear" in a sense.

          And I agree - more butter is always good! And would definitely help the crisp factor. I didn't think of that.

          Will experiment and let you know! :-)

          1. re: Scirocco

            yeah, "crispy" made me think of upping the fat factor -- and since it really can't be on the waffle iron (compared with a skillet with oil, e.g.) -- then it has to be in the batter. or can you generously brush the iron with veg oil?


            1. re: alkapal

              My mother, who set the waffle standard for me, used 1 cube of butter, melted, in her 2 c flour, 2 c buttermilk, 2 egg batter recipe.

              1. re: Sharuf

                Im gonna try ur moms recipe.i never tried butter in the recipe or buttermilk.i always use pancake mix..hungry jacks.but always getting soggy waffles.thanx for sharing

            2. re: Scirocco

              Yes, crank up the temp. I have the Cuisinart waffle iron and use Bittman's overnight waffles (which is full of butter). I have the iron to the hottest setting to produce medium-crispy waffles.

            3. re: doc_k55

              I agree with the temp on the waffle iron, but disagree totally about the butter. I use somewhere between zero and 2 Tbs. butter in my waffles, and they are always crispy.

              In case you're interested, I think the secret to waffles that are light and fluffy on the inside and crispy outside is to separate the eggs and whip the whites separately, then fold in.

            4. I just tried out a Belgian waffle maker for the first time last night. (With mixed results. Not sure how I feel about it compared to my regular waffle maker which I love.)

              Anyway, the directions for the iron do say to turn to a higher heat setting for crispier waffles. So that seems to corroborate what everyone is saying.

              1. While high heat is important, the best way to get crispy waffles is to use a yeasted batter.
                See this thread:

                My earliest exposure to these was in the 60's, with Sourdough Jack's Yeasted Waffles, but here's a version with regular yeast. I actually don't think the SD adds much:

                2 1/2 C flour, 2 C warm water, 1/2 packet of yeast (regular or rapid). Mix together and let stand. When it's frothy, about 2 hours, beat an egg with 2 T oil and 1/4 C instant dry milk, and fold into the batter. Then combine 1 t salt, 1 t baking soda, and 2T sugar, sprinkle evenly on the top of the batter and fold in. The soda will cause the batter to foam. Let it stand for a few minutes. Cook in a waffle iron at the highest heat, and let it re-heat between waffles. Don't overfill the iron. These freeze well, and then toast up nice and crisp.

                17 Replies
                1. re: Leucadian

                  thanks so much for the link - I should've done a search first!

                  This weekend (tomorrow in fact) we plan to first play with the waffle iron temp. After that, will play with the recipes. I have a GREAT book for waffles, pancakes, muffins, yeast breads, quick breads, pizza dough, scones, etc. "Breads of New England" by Judy Gorman I doubt it's in print any more, but could probably find it second hand if anyone's interested. Will check for some yeast waffle recipes. I know there is at least one yeast recipe in there. Also, I get Cook's Illustrated, so am a big fan and will try their recipe as well. I love sourdough, so am intrigued by that recipe as well!

                  thanks everyone!

                  1. re: Scirocco

                    When you're looking for yeasted batter recipes, look for one by Mollie Katzen called something like Amazing Overnight Waffles. They are amazing.

                    The overnight rest helps the flavor develop. And makes it easier to pull together in the morning.

                    1. re: karykat

                      And on that topic - Cook's Illustrated has a decent yeasted waffle recipe as well.

                        1. re: alkapal

                          Thanks! I finally got around to trying Mollie's recipe today. It is so simple to put together the night before! We liked them and they were crispy (I think upping the waffle iron temp was the key there). I think next time I would try it with buttermilk instead of regular milk for added flavor and tang. I also may play around with some other yeasted recipes and find the combination I like best. Thanks for the tip - they were yummy!! :-)

                          1. re: Scirocco

                            While I love the flavor of buttermilk in baked goods, it makes waffles tough. Save it for pancakes, IMO.

                            1. re: danna

                              good to know! thanks for the tip. It would be a crime to waste an otherwise good batch of waffles!

                              1. re: danna

                                how does buttermilk make the waffles tough? I thought that would purely be a mechanism of overmixing and developing the glutin in the batter. i use buttermilk in my (silverton's) waffles and they're awesome....

                                1. re: eLizard

                                  are the silverton's waffles yeasted? that might make the difference. mine is a simple baking powder waffle. I've tried it a couple of times...buttermilk = tough for me.

                                  1. re: danna

                                    They're sourdough. But I've used buttermilk in chemically leavened waffles, and I've not encountered your problem.... Sourdough are sublime, though.

                                2. re: danna

                                  The no buttermilk rule isn't true - toughness would come from too much flour, or overmixing. Whipping egg whites is one way to make fluffy waffles, but they can be prone to collapsing once they're out of the iron, and it's kind of labor intensive. Butter does help crisp and brown the waffles, and it makes them more tender - plus it has better flavor than oil.

                                  1. re: Alice Q

                                    Ok, well, in the interest of research (eh hem) I'll just have to try them to be sure. ;-) will report back after this weekend.......

                                    1. re: Alice Q

                                      the souffle'ed waffles i've made from cook's illustrated weren't fabulous. They weren't terrible, but not any great shakes.... i may be persuaded by another recipe if anyone has any.....

                                      1. re: eLizard

                                        Try yeasted waffles, above. They don't have to be sourdough, but they are better if the batter rests overnight (before adding the baking soda, of course).

                          2. re: Leucadian

                            I just made Nancy Silverton's sourdough waffles from her La Brea cookbook. They were amazing. crisp on the outside, and light on the inside. plus i only use high heat on the iron.

                            1. re: eLizard

                              Just looked them up online and they sound really good! sounds like they'd have a good tang. I just ordered a sourdough starter from King Arthur, so I could use some of that. Mmmm! And yes, the high heat on the iron made all the difference!

                              1. re: Scirocco

                                these waffles are amazing. i have a square iron (the one cooks illustrated recommends) that makes 4 "eggo" sized at a whack. this makes four of those. next time, i'd make a double batch and freeze the rest for homemade toaster waffles. i use my own starter. incredibly easy to make. mine is 2 years old with a lot of neglect!

                          3. I would cook them as high as possible w/o burning them, but I prefer a yeast raised batter for maximum flavor and crispness.

                            I started with this recipe and made a few changes, but it is very good as it. They are best when allowed to ferment overnight, but 4-6 hours is enough time for flavor to develop.


                            2 Replies
                            1. re: Kelli2006

                              Success! I cranked up the iron and watched them and they came out nice and crispy (but still soft inside)! I'm embarrassed it was so simple! I guess I was worried that the high heat would burn them with raw insides.

                              Next - will experiment with the yeast recipes. Those sound great.! I wasn't organized enough to try them for today. :-)

                              Thanks everyone!!

                              1. re: Scirocco

                                You might want to ditch the no stick spray and use real butter on your waffle iron too. I can't use the sprays due to food allergies, so I use a small silicone brush & just a little soft butter to grease my waffle iron every few waffles and it works great. No more sticky residue from the no stick spray and the added taste of a little more butter- a win-win situation. I make sourdough waffles, using an ancient regular waffle iron I've had for almost 20 years <gulp>...broken handle & all. My sourdough starter is strong & happy, I end up with Belgian-type waffles because they push the top up as they raise while cooking. I don't follow a recipe per se, but rather go by feel, through a mix of different flours together, including oat & garbanzo bean, as well as adding ripe bananas and whatever spices I feel like, along with a good amount of fresh ground, whole wheat. I don't add a lot of fat to my waffles, again I'm eyeballing it, but I add a small amount of oil. I ran low on eggs recently, so I used ground flax seeds as an egg substitute, which also worked well.

                                I need to find a larger waffle iron, as mine only makes one 8" diameter circle waffle. I mistakenly bought a Belgian waffle iron several years ago that didn't have a heat adjustment, which was useless. Anyone have any good suggestions for waffle irons that turn out a larger quantity at a time?