HOME > Chowhound > General Tristate Archive >

Hudson Valley Restaurant Weeks - March 9-21 (Sunday-Friday)

MisterBill2 Jan 10, 2008 08:02 PM

Hudson Valley Restaurant Week will be held for two weeks -- March 9-21. Lunches are $16.09, dinners $26.09. Unlike last year, it will be Sunday-Friday -- last year it did not apply on Sunday. According to their website http://www.hudsonvalleyrestaurantweek... until February 21st, "From January 2nd through February 17th, 2008 American Express Cardmembers can make reservations at participating restaurants before the general public", but I just called X2O before noticing this and was able to get a reservation and they did not ask for my card.

The big news here is that X2O is participating so I HIGHLY suggest calling now for reservations (I had called last week but they were not taking reservations yet). I am not sure where else to try. Equus is on it this year so maybe I will try that. I had considered going back to Monteverde since it has gotten such good press of late, but it's not on the list. I am looking for a couple of places to dine at on the Sundays that are further away from Westchester than I'd normally drive on a weeknight. I had hoped that Beso in New Paltz would be on the list, but they aren't either. I recall reading good things about Iron Forge Inn during last year's RW so I may put that on the list.

Here is a list I cut and pasted from the website. Obviously there may be changes.

121 Restaurant & Bar (American, Westchester County
)North Salem
(914) 669-0121

2 Spear Street (New American, Rockland County
(845) 353-7733

Aroma Osteria (Italian, Dutchess County
)Wappingers Falls
(845) 298-6790

Beebs (American, Orange County
(845) 568-6102

Big Easy Bistro (Cajun, Orange County)

Blue Plate Restaurant (New American, Columbia County
(518) 392-7711

Bywater Bistro (New American, Ulster County
(845) 658-3210

Cathryn's Tuscan Grill (Italian, Putnam County
)Cold Spring
(845) 265-5582

Charlotte's (European, Dutchess County
(845) 677-5888

Cosimo's (Italian, Orange County
(845) 692-3242

Cosimo's (Italian, Orange County
)Central Valley
(845) 928-5222

Cosimo's (Italian, Dutchess County
(845) 485-7172

Cosimo's (Italian, Orange County
(845) 567-1556

Crabtree's Kittle House (New American, Westchester County
(845) 666-8044

Equus Restaurant (American, Westchester County

Gigi Trattoria (Italian, Dutchess County

Global Gatherings (Eclectic, Westchester County
(914) 683-1833

Goldfish Restaurant (Mediterranean, Westchester County)
(914) 762-0051

Harvest Cafe Restaurant & Wine Bar (New American, Ulster County
)New Paltz
(845) 255-4205

Il Barilotto (Italian, Dutchess County
(845) 897-4300

Il Tesoro (Italian, Orange County
(845) 294-8373

Iron Forge Inn (New American, Orange County)
(845) 986-3411

John Michael's at Purdy's Homestead (European, Westchester County
)North Salem
(914) 277-2301

La Puerta Azul (Mexican, Dutchess County
)Salt Point
(845) 677-2985

Le Chambord (French, Dutchess County
)Hopewell Jct.

Le Fontane Restaurant (Italian, Westchester County
(914) 232-9619

Locust Tree (European, Ulster County
)New Paltz

Main Course (American, Ulster County
)New Paltz
(845) 255-2600

Main Course at Alumnae House (American, Dutchess County
(845) 437-7159

Med 15 35 (Mediterranean, Westchester County
)Rye Brook
(914) 934-2550

Mexican Radio (Mexican, Columbia County

Mohonk Mountain House (American, Ulster County
)New Paltz
(845) 256-2056

Nina (America, Orange County
(845) 344-6800

Off Broadway (Italian, Westchester County)
Dobbs Ferry
(914) 693-6170

Oriole 9 (Mediterranean, Ulster County

Pamela's on the Hudson (New American, Orange County
(845) 562-4505

Raccoon Saloon (American, Ulster County
(845) 236-7872

Reka's Thai Restaurant (Thai, Westchester County
)White Plains
(914) 949-1440

Restaurant X and the Bully Boy Bar (American, Rockland County
(845) 268-6555

Sentrista Grille (Italian, Putnam County
(845) 279-2777

Shadows on the Hudson (American, Dutchess County
(845) 486-9500

Ship Lantern Inn (Continental, Ulster County

Ship to Shore (American, Ulster County
(845) 334-8887

Sonora (New Latin, Westchester County
)Port Chester
(914) 933-0200

Starr Place (American, Dutchess County
(845) 876-2924

Steakhouse "22" (American, Putnam County
(845) 878-9877

Sukhothai (Thai, Dutchess County

Tavern Restaurant (American, Putnam County
(845) 424-3254

Terrapin (New American, Dutchess County
(845) 876-3330

The Red Onion (New American, Ulster County
(845) 679-1223

The River Bank (American, Orange County
)Cornwall on Hudson
(845) 534-3046

The Tavern at The Marriott Westchester (American, Westchester County
(914) 333-1241

The Thayer Hotel (American, Orange County)
West Point
(845) 446-4731

The Village Tea Room Restaurant & Bake Shop (Eclectic, Ulster County
)New Paltz
(845) 255-3434

Torches (Eclectic, Orange County
(845) 568-0100

Valley Restaurant (American, Putnam County
(845) 424-3604

Vertigo Bar & Restaurant (New American, Rockland County

X2O Xaviars on the Hudson (New American, Westchester County

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream RE: MisterBill2 Jan 11, 2008 12:18 PM

    Thanks for the tip about X2O-- I called for my reservation too! Can't wait!!! I'm going to try the Castle and John Michael's too.

    1. m
      mom2 RE: MisterBill2 Jan 14, 2008 01:05 PM

      what would be the top 3 to pick from?

      1 Reply
      1. re: mom2
        dolores RE: mom2 Jan 14, 2008 01:11 PM

        IMO: X20, Il Barilotto and Crabtree's, in that order.

        Equus's wine pour is too stingy to my taste.

        And, of course, avoid Reka.

      2. g
        GCGuy RE: MisterBill2 Jan 14, 2008 01:21 PM

        What's with the $X6.09?

        1. GIOny RE: MisterBill2 Jan 22, 2008 07:13 AM

          Thanks for the list Mister Bill. I'd like to try X20, Equus, and Valley Restaurant (I went to a wedding there once and the food was pretty good so I'd like to try it in a non-wedding atmosphere). The Ship Lantern Inn has been suggested to me but I've never seen much about it. Is it worth the drive?? Almost forgot, I've never been to Bully Boy, would also like to try that. Agree with dolores about avoiding Reka and also Shadows.

          1. applesauce23 RE: MisterBill2 Feb 21, 2008 03:16 PM

            There are a few new additions to the list. The two that I noticed are Ario Thai in Rhinebeck and Twist in Hyde Park. My wish list includes: La Puerta Azul, Ship to Shore, Starr Place, Raccoon Saloon and Aroi. I will be going to X20 (definitely looking forward to that!) and Twist...I'll try to fit in some more restaurants if I have time.

            13 Replies
            1. re: applesauce23
              MisterBill2 RE: applesauce23 Mar 1, 2008 05:40 PM

              Several of the restaurants have posted their menus. I am very impressed with the menu at John Michaels, and made my reservation there after seeing it. I am less impressed with the surcharges at Equus ($5 for valet parking and $20 for the beef dish) but I will probably go anyway.

              I have reservations at Iron Forge Inn, John Michaels, Equus, X2O and Valley. Still trying to decide where to go that 2nd Sunday. Locust Tree in New Paltz has an interesting menu and I would not mind driving there on a Sunday (I am trying to stay local on weekdays, I am in Northern Westchester). The Sunday Times has an interesting piece on RW and they quote the chef from Tavern, so maybe I will try that even though it's not that far away from me.

              Sonora in Port Chester has a very nice menu, I may try that for lunch. Stoneleigh Creek in Armonk also has a nice lunch menu.

              1. re: MisterBill2
                i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream RE: MisterBill2 Mar 1, 2008 06:24 PM

                I thought John Michael's menu looked good too... was it difficult to get a reservation forthe day and time you wanted Misterbill? I'll try calling tomorrow.

                1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                  MisterBill2 RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 1, 2008 08:36 PM

                  I got one for Wednesday at 7pm, no problem. I expect it will get tougher once people read the article in the Times today.

                2. re: MisterBill2
                  MisterBill2 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 3, 2008 05:34 AM

                  Ugh, I just read on Liz Johnson's blog that Jeff Raider has left Valley (he is going to One in Irvington). I am much less excited about my RW visit to Valley now (although the menu did look good). :-(.

                  Also got the menu from Tavern emailed to me, it was ok but not spectacular.

                  1. re: MisterBill2
                    menton1 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 3, 2008 07:14 AM

                    The problem with all these types of "restaurant week" events is that, although the price seems reasonable, this is a SPECIAL MENU! You are not getting the same dishes they normally serve, this menu is specially designed for restaurant week; and sadly, with the majority of these restaurants, the menu is VERY inferior to their regular fare.

                    Better to save up and do a splurge on a normal evening...

                    1. re: menton1
                      MisterBill2 RE: menton1 Mar 3, 2008 04:06 PM

                      It all depends on where you go. Valley served really excellent dishes last time. Monteverde definitely was cheap in what they served. Kittle House also did a decent job. John Michaels has a standard $11 salad on their RW menu.

                      I think you are doing everyone a disservice by generalizing your own experiences and claiming that ALL restaurants act that way. You would think that an intelligent restaurant owner would realize that they are exposing themselves to hundreds of prospective customers and doing inferior stuff is a surefire way to ensure that they will not return.

                      1. re: MisterBill2
                        menton1 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 6, 2008 10:28 AM

                        You would think that an intelligent restaurant owner would not allow bad service or poor cooking, or dirty restrooms, either, but it happens alot.

                        As far as reporting on my own experiences, that's what these boards are for-- a subjective report on how one feels. Holding back is not the way to go here, IMHO.

                        1. re: menton1
                          MisterBill2 RE: menton1 Mar 8, 2008 05:27 PM

                          Except you stated you claim that the dishes are not from the normal menu as fact. And it's not.

                          I've read interviews with multiple restaurant owners/chefs who have said that they see this as a great thing because it lets potential customers who might not normally eat there check them out

                      2. re: menton1
                        pishpesh RE: menton1 Mar 12, 2008 12:23 PM

                        it is a set menu, but most of the dishes are from the normal menu - so you can get a good view of what the restaurant has to offer normally. Also, it's all about execution and service isn't it? you can certainly tell whether a restaurant has decent food and service - even if the menu is a set menu. They either execute and serve the dishes well, or they don't. it's a great way to try places you are not familiar with. We ate at the Kittle House on Monday and at Harvest on Hudson last night (John Michael was full *lol*). The food at both was very good, the service was excellent. I had not been to Harvest before and will definately go back - so I guess they achieved what their goal with RW participation. Tonight is Il Soriso. i'll report back afterwards.

                        1. re: pishpesh
                          roze RE: pishpesh Mar 12, 2008 08:08 PM

                          I'm going to the Kittle House on Sunday. Glad to hear you enjoyed the meal! Could you give me a little info on the food choces? Thanks

                          1. re: pishpesh
                            MisterBill2 RE: pishpesh Mar 13, 2008 05:40 AM

                            I ate at John Michael on Wednesday night and the place was definitely jammed. It was also one of the best meals I've had in a while. I strongly recommend checking it out if you can get in during RW.

                            Let us know about Il Soriso. Last year, Liz Johnson from the Journal News reported that they did not serve their HVRW menu until 8pm. It will be interesting to hear if they changed this year. Someone already posted on her blog that they were not offering it for lunch (and she got really awful service when she ate there at regular price and ordered inexpensive stuff).

                            1. re: MisterBill2
                              mom2 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 13, 2008 07:13 AM

                              I'm glad to hear about your positive experience at John Michael's, we have reservations for tomorrow night! What did you have?

                              1. re: mom2
                                MisterBill2 RE: mom2 Mar 13, 2008 10:05 PM

                                I had the tuna appetizer and salmon entree and then the basil panna cotta (it was green and jiggled). My wife had the parsnip soup, chicken and white chocolate mousse. All were excellent.

                  2. y
                    yumyum14 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 8, 2008 02:07 PM

                    Try Zuppa-Dave Dibari - is an incredible master chef and worth the try despite the location.
                    Harvest On Hudson - the menu for restaurant week has items from their regular menu - no skimping there, can't beat the view and parking is not an issue
                    Equus definately worth the savings despite the valet that has nothing to do with the meal.

                    1. f
                      foodamour RE: MisterBill2 Mar 11, 2008 01:03 PM

                      Thank you Mister Bill for this incredible list.

                      Moving up here recently from the city, I was worried that the food loving side of me would suffer, but you have given me new hope and fun on the weekends for places to go and tastes to savor.

                      I have been searching around for your posts, cause I feel we have a similar quality of food and taste loves, I really appreciate all of your honest posts. god bless you!!! ( my wallet and taste buds smile on you)

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: foodamour
                        MisterBill2 RE: foodamour Mar 11, 2008 08:38 PM

                        Thanks for your comments :-). Be sure to check the HVRW website at www.hudsonvalleyrestaurantweek.com because they've got additional restaurants listed, and several have their menus linked.

                      2. b
                        bob gaj RE: MisterBill2 Mar 11, 2008 05:58 PM

                        was at la puerta azul today...here's what they're doing for the hudson valley week. all from the traditional menu.

                        appy: Homemade soup made with fresh sweet corn, leeks, roasted poblanos & cream. Garnished with truffle oil and mushrooms.
                        (and 2 other appetizers).

                        mains: Fresh Tilapia seared in a chipotle butter. Served with corn rice & tomato sauce with sweet peppers & olives.
                        Grilled organic chicken breast with mole coloradito. Served with sweet plantains and sweet corn rice.
                        Beef short ribs braised in Mexican red wine. Served with zucchini and a bleu cheese salad with guajillo-red wine reduction.

                        churros with chocolate , and 2 other dishes.

                        if anyone's counting on prices, the appys were 8 each normally, mains 18 (ribs 22), so if you were planning on a dessert, you'd come out ahead. not much savings, but since it's close by and convenient, i figured i'd stop by....

                        1 Reply
                        1. re: bob gaj
                          moosesocks RE: bob gaj Mar 13, 2008 07:40 PM

                          I went there today. The food was good, but I don't think it's a huge saving, especially when you have a drink or two. But then again, I don't think it's all about that. It really gives me and my friends some "excuse" to go out and dine during the week....

                          I had the cherry tomato salad, which was really refreshing, though I'd prefer it in summer. For entree, I had the chicken breast with mole coloradito. I'm more impressed with the sweet corn rice that came with the chicken than the chicken itself - I'm sure there's plenty of butter in the rice!!!

                          I had churros - well...to me, anything that's fried is good~

                          I believe the other two desserts are: flan with pineapple & almond cake with coconut sauce.

                          Overall, la puerta azul is really a fun place to go to in this area with friends. I'm going again next Fri with other friends...

                        2. georgeb RE: MisterBill2 Mar 12, 2008 05:04 AM

                          Went to the Red Onion in Woodstock/Saugerties last night for the prix fixe dinner. Food was great, but think of it as a tasting menu, not a lot of quantity.

                          They were slammed for a Tuesday night, the bar was hoppin'. Unfortunately, the downside of the place was the acoustics. My ears hurt from the loudness of the place. You couldn't have any conversation without shouting, and, as a result, everyone was shouting. Next time I go (if ever), I will bring along a decibel meter. My guess was 120 dB.

                          To add more injury, the bartender decided to crank up the sound system, so it could be heard, adding to the din.

                          Due to the noise, I would have to give it a thumbs down, unless I wore earplugs (which is not beyond the realm of possibility).

                          1. i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream RE: MisterBill2 Mar 12, 2008 07:45 PM

                            Anyone make it to X2O? I'm having second thoughts about my reservation... just not sure I'm in the mood. Anyone have an info to sway me either way? TIA.

                            7 Replies
                            1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                              MisterBill2 RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 13, 2008 05:42 AM

                              I've not been to X2O this week but I did have a reservation for next week which I cancelled after hearing a few negative stories from people who went on Sunday.It turns out it is the same menu they had at X during the first HVRW a couple of years ago and I didn't like it then. It is not representative of X2O's normal menu.

                              1. re: MisterBill2
                                i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream RE: MisterBill2 Mar 13, 2008 12:32 PM

                                Do you happen to know what's on the menu, MisterBill? I think we're going to go anyway-- my bf really wants to go again since we enjoyed it so much when we went last year. Hopefully it will make me want to go back again, and not the opposite!

                                1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                                  MisterBill2 RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 13, 2008 10:07 PM

                                  They have some cornmeal crusted trout, and chicken and pork dishes. None of them are their normal dishes, which is the problem.

                                  1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                                    i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 14, 2008 07:03 PM

                                    I just wanted to follow up by describing our meal tonight. I am really happy we decided to go, because we had a really lovely time. We went once before (regular menu) and loved it-- we were reasonably pleased with service and food this time in the context of the bargain price. While I agree with MisterBill about it not being a normal representation of the menu, what we had was good for the price. And you can't beat the service and the romantic atmosphere and the view. That said, I would be annoyed if I went back next year and they had the same exact menu.

                                    We had...
                                    appetizers: mushroom soup, butternut squash "pudding" mold (they also have a salad with goat cheese)
                                    entrees: cornmeal crusted trout with swiss chard, pork with star anise. The pork was eh. I was happy I got the trout, although a bit perturbed they left the skin on. We also feasted on their regular bread platters-- baguettes and biscuits. YUM. I did not see anyone near us get the chicken.
                                    dessert: big on the molds i guess (ie, the butternut squash pudding), pumpkin panna cotta and chocolate timbale. The panna cotta was ok, I think pumpkin's a little out of season, and the chocolate timbale was verrrry rich and good but a little pedestrian. The coconut pudding looked good too.

                                    My boyfriend had a really nice white wine, supposedly from the Hudson Valley, also on the special menu. The place is beautiful, the service was great, and I have no regrets about going.

                                    Two quibbles: Our server neglected to tell us about 2 appetizer specials for RW not on the RW menu, a sushi roll and a goat cheese tart. We overheard them being recited to another table. In addition, dolores will want to note that parking, which I guess used to be free with validation, is now $3 for patrons of x2o. :)

                                    1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                                      dolores RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 15, 2008 03:34 AM

                                      Thanks, i eat! The meal sounds delicious, and I've yet to be there at night. The views must be lovely.

                                      1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                                        MisterBill2 RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 16, 2008 08:49 AM

                                        Interesting that theyre charging for parking. I wonder if that is this week only (like Equus is doing, $5).

                                        1. re: MisterBill2
                                          dolores RE: MisterBill2 Mar 16, 2008 09:03 AM

                                          (like Equus is doing, $5).

                                          I just called Equus, and the charge is only during restaurant week.

                                          How nice.

                                2. s
                                  Solstice444 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 13, 2008 03:47 AM

                                  Went to The Bird & Bottle Inn for dinner last night. I had the potato and cheddar soup (also had bacon in it), chicken fricasse (with mushrooms and root vegetables), and apple crisp. My mom had the salad (which came with goat cheese, apple vinagrette, and cranberries), the English short ribs (with a coffee-brown sugar rub), came with chipotle mashed potatoes and asparagus, and the chocolate lava cake. We both enjoyed our meals. The ribs were good except I thought the coffee rub made them a bit bitter, probably b/c I don't drink coffee. The other entree offered was a scallop dish, the other appetizer was some sort of tomato salad, and the other dessert was something with bananas...I can't remember quite what. The chipotle mashed potatoes were very good. The bread they served was also enjoyable...a sort of tomato foccacia, and cornbread with pieces of vegetables in it. I had never eaten there or been there before and it was a very nice cozy atmosphere, fireplaces going. They had the guest rooms open for you to look in as well. Overall a good experience!

                                  2 Replies
                                  1. re: Solstice444
                                    menton1 RE: Solstice444 Mar 16, 2008 10:39 AM

                                    Mr Bill2: "They have some cornmeal crusted trout, and chicken and pork dishes. None of them are their normal dishes, which is the problem"

                                    YOu challenged me on my comments earlier, where I expressed the exact same complaints about these restaurant week type-events, Mr. Bill2. Seems that you are coming around to agreeing with me!

                                    Yes, I would daresay that the majority of the menus served are NOT typical of the regular menu that these places serve. Why, Equus has the temerity to charge for parking ONLY during this promotion! I guess these restaurant owners think the public is stupid!

                                    1. re: menton1
                                      MisterBill2 RE: menton1 Mar 18, 2008 09:42 AM

                                      The problem is that you made it as a blanket statement. The fact is that not all restaurants serve dumbed down food. I had an amazing meal at John Michael's which was almost entirely from their regular menu (and the only one I could not find, my salmon entree, was good enough to be on it). I ate at Relish in Sparkill on Sunday night and it was right off their normal menu. Old Forge Inn in Warwick serves samples of two soups and two desserts and they are from the regular menu.

                                      The trick is to check the menu in advance and only go to places with interesting menus. You want to leave the restaurant being thrilled with what you ate -- not just thrilled at what you paid.

                                  2. marmite RE: MisterBill2 Mar 18, 2008 12:57 PM

                                    My mother and I went to Equus last night. I had the endive/ beet/ walnut salad to start, which was delicious- I could have eaten another for my main and been completely happy. The chef made me a vegetarian main course, consisting of mushroom risotto with egg-sized scoops of sauteed spinach (perfect) and carrot frisee over corn and green beans. My mother had the sweet potato and pear bisque to start, followed by hazelnut crusted tilapia, and declared everything delicious. For dessert I had the orange-basil Bavarian with orange foam, and she had the chocolate panna cotta. Service was outstanding throughout, and I would love to return- even if the menu was special for restaurant week, I'd like to see what they can do under normal circumstances.

                                    1. markp RE: MisterBill2 Mar 18, 2008 08:22 PM

                                      Went to Il Barilotto tonight. They're not posting the Restaurant Week menu on their site. The special menu was spot on: 2 starters, 3 mains, 2 dolci. Generous portions. We ate just about all the dishes offered. Here goes:

                                      Pork shank atop an herbed mustard cole slaw. Pork shank was fall-off-the-bone delicious. Slaw enegized by the herbs. Would have licked the plate clean if at home.
                                      Bisque with shrimp and mussels. Rich but not cloying. Stock had depth. Shrimp and mussels were very delicately cooked.

                                      Fried Florida grouper over a bean puree with olives and tomatoes. Very well balanced dish. Bean puree alone would have made a fantastic dip.
                                      Penne in a light cream sauce with peas and shrimp. Subtle flavors. Crowd pleaser.
                                      There was also a free range chicken dish.

                                      Chocolate mousse. Classic. Minced peach at the bottom of the glass was a nice touch.
                                      Crepes. Hit of the night.

                                      Service was excellent. One fun note: fellow in the party behind me wanted to bail off the menu for "chik parm with a side of penne alfredo." Server asked chef, then politely replied that chef was "unfortunately" only able to work off the dishes listed on the menu. I thought the staff was nice not to point out the Olive Garden is but a few miles up the road. I'm not an elitist, but come on! You can eat chicken parm with a side of glop at every fricken pizza joint in the northeast. The guy running this kitchen has been frying fish professionally since he was 14. Trust him. You're in good hands. If he writes it down on the menu, it's going to be good.

                                      1 Reply
                                      1. re: markp
                                        hudsonvalleyfoodblog RE: markp Mar 27, 2008 09:44 AM

                                        Loved your post

                                        Il Barilotto in my opinion is a top class restaurant. I think it would thrive in any major city, including manhattan.

                                        Real funny about the chicken parm. Who doesn't love chicken parm but come on, live a little.

                                      2. d
                                        DaleW RE: MisterBill2 Mar 19, 2008 06:31 AM

                                        Last night we went to Sonora, a "Neuvo Latino" place in Portchester for the Hudson Valley Restaurant Week. Sometimes places stint on their selections for these promotions, but Sonora gave a lot of nice options.

                                        Betsy started with a nice shrimp ceviche with avocado and tomatoes (they actually listed a red snapper ceviche, this was brought without explanation, but was Dish of the Night); my starter was a lobster and avocado quesadilla with chipotle, creme fraiche alioli, and guacamole. Other options were a salad with beets and a skirt steak empanada appetizer.

                                        For main course, I had lamb chops with chimichurri sauce, served with roasted garlic and wild mushroom mashed potatoes. Betsy had a vegetarian paella (good, but too heavy on the yellow peppers). Other choices were striped bass and chicken.

                                        Betsy took a couple bites of two desserts (as I don't eat), a too-sweet sponge cake and a good chocolate bread pudding. Sorbet was other option.

                                        Just as with NYC Restaurant Week, these deals are a good way to try a new place IF the restaurant doesn't treat you as a second-class citizen. This was a good deal at $26 (about same as most main courses on regular menu). Portions were large, food was good though not outstanding.

                                        6 Replies
                                        1. re: DaleW
                                          dolores RE: DaleW Mar 24, 2008 03:04 PM

                                          So what's the consensus?

                                          Did anyone discover any new amazing restaurants?

                                          1. re: dolores
                                            i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream RE: dolores Mar 24, 2008 05:59 PM

                                            Within the comments, there are some great reviews of different places...

                                            1. re: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream
                                              dolores RE: i_eat_a_lot_of_ice_cream Mar 25, 2008 02:44 AM

                                              Thanks, ieatalotoficecream. I still love your moniker, for obvious reasons.....

                                            2. re: dolores
                                              MisterBill2 RE: dolores Mar 26, 2008 10:27 PM

                                              John Michael's in Purdys (formerly Purdys Homestead and Box Tree). Amazing food, great service.

                                              Relish in Sparkill (Rockland) was also a very pleasant surprise.

                                              Tavern in Garrison was surprisingly good.

                                              Valley is still great, even with a new chef.

                                              Stoneleigh Creek was ok for the price but not for their regular prices and mediocre service.

                                              Hopefully my comments are among some of those that you enjoyed on Liz's site. I'd better win the free tickets she was offering!

                                              1. re: MisterBill2
                                                misslaura RE: MisterBill2 Apr 14, 2008 03:51 PM

                                                You've been to Valley recently? Is it as good as it used to be (according to reviews I saw, sadly I've never been)? I'm trying to decide between Monteverde and Valley for a birthday dinner. Valley seems a little more reasonable but only if it's good.

                                                1. re: misslaura
                                                  MisterBill2 RE: misslaura Apr 16, 2008 10:17 AM

                                                  Yes, we had a great meal at Valley during RW. I saw Jeff Raider (the former chef) at the Food/Wine Expo last week and he said he took the ricotta ravioli appetizer and madelines dessert with him to One. But I'd definitely go back (and it is MUCH cheaper than Monteverde!).

                                          2. b
                                            byramgirl RE: MisterBill2 Apr 15, 2008 08:01 AM

                                            Had a good meal at Harvest on Hudson the other evening, and they are running the Hudson Valley Restaurant Week special until the end of April. They also added a steak option to the special menu.

                                            1 Reply
                                            1. re: byramgirl
                                              MisterBill2 RE: byramgirl Apr 16, 2008 10:18 AM

                                              3 courses of dinner for $26.09???

                                            2. f
                                              foodguy1980 RE: MisterBill2 Mar 26, 2009 11:03 AM

                                              Just had dinner at Il Barilotto for RW last night. Being a long time customer at Il Barilotto I was incredibly happy with the RW offerings. My wife and I couldn't believe how delicious the selections were. I had the crispy polenta appetizer and the slow roasted pork for my entree. I was so full I could barely eat my dessert. After going to other places for RW and witnessing how they were being chintzy on the portions and the item selections I was really satisfied with my experience at Il Barilotto. Service and ambiance first rate as usual.

                                              P.S. They are featuring new Italian wines by the glass to go with your RW menu (in addition of course) and they were quite delicious so check it out.

                                              Show Hidden Posts