Boulderites: Colterra or Black Cat for anniversary dinner?
IMO, you can't go wrong with either. Black Cat is smaller and more intimate, if that matters. We went there for our anniversary. We made our reservation on OpenTable and other requests or comments or whatever they have, we indicated that it was our anniversary dinner. They poured us some complimentary bubbly and wrote "Happy Anniversary" in chocolate on the rim of our dessert plate. I'm going to try to attach the photo. Sorry if the colors are weird, but the pic was taken w/out flash. The dessert was actually very lovely.