Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jan 4, 2008 01:21 PM

my husband insisted on inviting 12 people to celebrate his birthday

Where should we go. Open to location and food. Prefer good food over trendy atmosphere. Thanks.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I love Otto for big group celebrations, but I'm sure some people on this board would disagree. I think the food (pizza/antipasti/cheese) is great, plus it's such a festive atmosphere. Always puts me in a fantastic mood.

    5 Replies
    1. re: kpsquared

      I thought of Otto although I may not be able to get a reservation for this Saturday (I procrastinated!). How loud does it get at night? I've only been there during the day.

      1. re: Aimee

        do what i did for my birthday, go to daisy may's for the big pig gig. it is fun, food is awesome, and it's BYOB.

        1. re: jon

          This is totally on my radar! What's the atmosphere like there at night?

          1. re: Aimee

            i can't really comment on the atmosphere because we had about 20 people there and we took up most of the space and they reserved two long tables for us. if it's only 12, more than just your party will be there and i'm sure it will be fun (we had fun basically having the place to ourselves). for 12 people i would suggest 1/2 pig and the pork butt and a few sides. and don't forget the beer (and bottle openers)! enjoy!

          2. re: jon

            I just called to make a reservation. This was a great idea - thanks!

      2. If you are thinking of Otto, consider Crispo instead. Way better food, and you can probably get a private room for 12.