Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Dec 31, 2007 08:12 AM

Suggested improvements for this crabcake recipe

My GF requested crabcakes for NYE.

I already bought the ingredients for this recipe.

Do you suggest going with this or can you suggest any improvements?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Looks good to me except for the cilantro. I can't stand cilantro (that's a genetic marker, if you have the right gene combination, cilantro tastes like old pennies or soap to you). So I'd leave cilantro out, but otherwise it looks like a nice recipe to me! :)

    1. Good ideas, but I would cut way back on the herbs and lemon for the crabcakes themselves. I personally want the crab to prevail, and you've got the same flavors in the sauce...

      Also - while I love panko, for crabcakes I love crushed Ritz or Townhouse crackers, unless you're going for a lighter flavored crabbcake. Maybe the crackers inside and rolled in the panko...

      Have fun, and let us know what you did!

      1 Reply
      1. re: Richard 16

        I like crushing those little oyster crackers for crabcakes.

      2. Find yourself a recipe a lot less busy and bready than this one.

        1 Reply
        1. re: FrankJBN

          I agree with Frank- way too much bread. For instance, when I make crabcakes- I'll use a pound of crabmeat- and about 10-15 saltines.

          I also agree with leaving out the cilantro- I love cilantro, but it doesn't go well with everything. I'd sub parsley, or just leave it out. It's a pretty 'herby" recipe, so leaving it out would be best, I think, since it's the crab that you want to shine.

          The resting period, I have found is crucial for keeping them together.

          One more thing- I usually make a remoulade sauce to go with crabcakes.

        2. Many thanks for the input. I ended up just winging it. Mayo, lemon juice, one egg yolk, some Dijon, scallions and parsely, some saltine crumbs.

          In the fridge now.