Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Dec 17, 2007 07:16 AM

Gramercy Tavern vs. Babbo- which to pick?

Hello all,

My boyfriend has reservations at both Gramercy Tavern and Babbo for my birthday (his sister is going to take the reservation we don't use). I don't know which one to pick-- I'm leaning toward Gramercy since I've never been there. Any advice from people who have been to both/either recently?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
        1. I hate to split the vote- but I would go with Gramercy hands down. I was at Babbo last week and it was an absolute nightmare- it is a complete bottleneck in the bar- you have to fight to get your coat checked, the service was apathetic and the food was sub-par. I am so disappointed because we have been going for years and our past two visits have been lackluster when compared to the old Babbo standards. On the other hand, Gramercy is always a lovely experience- the service is gracious and the food is better than ever. I know we all have different experiences depending on the night, the service, etc. so I would be interested to know other experiences.

          1. i love babbo, but i ate at gramercy tavern last night and it was one of the best dining experiences i've ever had in the city. service was incredible, from making the reservation, to coat check, to server, busboys, etc. the food was amazing! get the duck breast with duck leg confit. wow is all i can say. and save room for either the hot chocolate or the greenmarket apple cider. much different from babbo. if you're looking for romantic and a relaxing night, ,go to gramercy tavern. if you're looking for crowded but fun, go to babbo.