HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Per Se or Eleven Madison?

MJT Dec 12, 2007 09:00 AM

If I had a choice between the two for dinner which one should I choose? I'm from San Francisco and have had French Laundry and Keller's other ventures out here in the West.

Thanks for the help.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. s
    Singar RE: MJT Dec 12, 2007 09:07 AM

    If it is just between the two, Per Se hands down.

    If you have tried Keller already, however, you may want to try another restaurant. In my opinion, Jean Georges and Daniel are both superior to Eleven Madison. Although you will find plenty of EMP loves on this board.

    6 Replies
    1. re: Singar
      jvish RE: Singar Dec 12, 2007 09:17 AM

      Per Se defintely.
      I really dont put EMP in the same class of restaurant at all.
      dont get me wrong its a very very nice place, but not on the same level as Per Se

      1. re: jvish
        tpigeon RE: jvish Dec 12, 2007 10:03 AM

        +1 if you are looking to have the best meal. If you care about trying something different, you will be just fine at EMP as it is a great place. I agree that JG and Daniel are better than EMP but EMP is a bit more casual and lower maintenance and hold up pretty well to Daniel at least (I know because I recently ate at Daniel and EMP on back to back nights).

        1. re: tpigeon
          doublesuited77 RE: tpigeon Dec 12, 2007 11:33 AM

          i ate at both places in the past 2 weeks and here is my take.

          From a FOOD only perspective, EMP is better. I thought their execution was crisper and didn't try to overengineer some things. Per se tried to be more inventive, but they really didn't deliver.

          Per se was saved though by the quality of its service and wine list.

          1. re: doublesuited77
            tpigeon RE: doublesuited77 Dec 12, 2007 05:37 PM

            I am sticking to my guns from a food perspective that Per Se is quite a bit better. Value is a whole other discussion...

            1. re: doublesuited77
              JohnnyBooy RE: doublesuited77 Dec 12, 2007 05:50 PM

              Per Se hands down. I was disappointed by EMP's food

              1. re: doublesuited77
                jvish RE: doublesuited77 Dec 13, 2007 04:29 AM

                There really is no comparison between these 2 places.
                Everyone is obviously entitled to their opinions.

                But its not just the service and wine list that make Per Se a better restaurant. The food at EMP is very good, put not on the same level
                as Per Se
                If someone is not someone who dines frequently in NY and their choices are Per Se and EMP. Per Se will be a much more memorable experience

        2. m
          MJT RE: MJT Dec 12, 2007 03:42 PM

          What about Cru?

          1 Reply
          1. re: MJT
            RCC RE: MJT Dec 12, 2007 03:53 PM

            Per Se is on a different league than either Eleven Madison or Cru.

            Food, service and overall execution are notches above at Per Se.

          2. o
            omnomnom RE: MJT Dec 12, 2007 08:35 PM

            Per Se hands down in all aspects, its at a completely different league compared to EMP and Cru.

            1. g
              gutreactions RE: MJT Dec 13, 2007 04:38 AM

              Just heard last night from a recent visitor to Per Se (second timers) that he and his wife enjoyed the food and wine but left hungry after leaving quite a bundle. They ate again later in the evening at a casual spot...The trouble with many of our current crop of 'innovative chefs' is they believe all plates are now small plates but you still have to pay big...

              Show Hidden Posts