Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Dec 7, 2007 06:31 PM

Help: thickening chicken-pie filling

I'm making a pascualina de pollo - an Argentine chicken pie, with two crusts. My filling (chicken poached in chicken stock, various savoury vegetables, with a velouté sauce from homemade stock and a roux) seems a bit soupy, and I don't want to destroy the bottom crust (though it will of course be a bit soft). The taste of the mixture is perfect - utterly delicious. Should I add some breadcrumbs, make more roux, or what?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I often thicken soups, gravy or my chicken pot pie filling with a butter and flour mashed together. I got this from some recipe long ago and it works. Take about 4-5 Tbsp. of butter, near room temp in a bowl and sprinkle a few Tbsp. of flour over it. Mix with your hand by pinching it so you get a coarse crumb consistency. Then drop some of it into whatever you need to thicken, like your filling, and stir. It work remarkably well, plus its easy and you don't need to make a roux. Hope it works.

    1. Although a bit de-classee, I have no problem using a little cornstarch slurry. It does not have the raw issue of a flour slurry.

      1. Though I'm no expert on this area, I suspect a very light coating of oil on the top side of the bottom crust might help, but I'd thicken the sauce too. I put a bit of oil on my pizza crust when using wet stuff like fresh tomato to help keep the water from making the crust soggy.

        1. I am no expert either but I keep instant mashes potatoes on hand to thicken soups, stews, fillings and the potato taste would keeps in line with the vegs you use.

          1. OK, are you blind baking the bottom crust? And to make your filling non-soupy, make your velouté sauce almost a paste. so when it all bakes together the added liquid from chicken/veggies makes it, nice thick.