HOME > Chowhound > Chains >
Do you create unique foods? Get great advice
TELL US

Beef tenderloin from Costco?

d
dogboy Dec 4, 2007 06:27 PM

I am cooking beef tenderloin for my family Christmas dinner and I have found the price for tenderloin at my local butcher nearly twice the price at Costco. Is this a case of "you get what you pay for"? I know I will have some waste and have to do some trimming to get similar sized filets if I buy from Costco, but what about the quality? Does anyone have any feedback on the whole beef tenderloins purchased from Costco?

Thx,
~Dogboy

  1. m
    morleroy82 Feb 24, 2014 11:34 AM

    I purchased whole tenderloin from Costco, and it was fabulous. I trimmed it and cut it in to steaks, and a small roast. It was excellent.

    1. a
      AmaroneMan Apr 29, 2010 04:02 AM

      I can't stand Costco.

      I suppose the store itself is good and I like the products, but the people who shop there walk far too slowly. If they moved more slowly they'd be going backwards!

      1 Reply
      1. re: AmaroneMan
        coney with everything Apr 30, 2010 04:56 AM

        Go when they first open, amaroneman. If you get there before they start offering free samples, I find it's a lot easier to get around. But once the samples are out there, forget about it.

      2. m
        mchinsky Jan 29, 2009 10:59 AM

        Most people don't know, but Costco sells genuine USDA Prime Beef (the brand is 1855 which I think is part of Swift). They only sell it via the costco.com website. Search for 1855. I know people say there isn't a difference, but their Prime tenderloins can go toe to toe (when cooked properly) with anything they serve at Mortons or Smith and Wolenskys.

        Prices are the best I can find for delivered USDA Prime. Especially when you buy the larger "family packs"

        9 Replies
        1. re: mchinsky
          s
          sjsjets May 24, 2009 09:31 AM

          Just got back from Costco. Prime Beef Tenderloin for $10.99/lb. Partially trimmed Choice was $12.99.

          FWIW - Julia Child always bought beef from Costco. As to the Prime v. Choice argument about filet mignon, most major steak chains, Mortons, Ruth's Chris, Capital Grille use Prime meat (some dry aged, some wet aged) but almost all use Choice for filet mignon.

          1. re: sjsjets
            m
            malibumike May 24, 2009 10:06 AM

            I have studied this subject Prime vs. Choice Filet Mignon and IMHO there is very little difference since Filet Mignon has very little fat (read flavor) to begin with, that is why most restaurants serve it with some kind of sauce. You do notice a fairly big difference in Rib Eyes Prime vs Choice.

            1. re: malibumike
              m
              mhale Jul 11, 2010 12:45 PM

              for the past 9 months Costco has been buying meat from 4 different suppliers. I am only speaking on behalf of the USDA Prime Rib Steak. Sadly Costco has taken the route of big business and sacrifice quality for profits. Their Prime Rib Steaks and now lean and very little marble, small package and thin cap. I would rate is choice + but not prime by any standards. I have been looking for local butchers in the Salt Lake area that have the beef Costco use to carry but they do not. I am still looking. It would be nice if Costco would carry quality meat again.

            2. re: sjsjets
              g
              givemecarbs May 26, 2009 10:37 AM

              Interesting thread, useful now as well as when it was originally posted. I didn't know that sjsjets. I finally signed up for Costco almost a year ago and am still discovering the wonders therein. If I get a whole tenderloin for the grill should I cook it whole or slice it into individual cutlets? Any ideas for flavoring the filet(s)? Getting too hot and sticky in these parts for heavy sauces.

              1. re: givemecarbs
                f
                fourunder May 27, 2009 04:32 AM

                If I get a whole tenderloin for the grill should I cook it whole or slice it into individual cutlets?
                ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
                For a larger group, definitely a grilled roast filet of beef. Never cutlets, but steaks for smaller numbers.

                Any ideas for flavoring the filet(s)?
                ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
                Kosher Salt and Fresh Cracked Pepper on the roast filet of beef.......Melted Bleu Cheese on steaks.

                1. re: fourunder
                  c
                  cstr May 27, 2009 09:28 AM

                  I agree, you don't need to spend the extra $$ for a prime tenderloin but, you should for ribeye or NY strip loin.

                  1. re: fourunder
                    g
                    givemecarbs May 27, 2009 01:05 PM

                    Thanks fourunder!

                    1. re: givemecarbs
                      f
                      fourunder May 27, 2009 01:35 PM

                      You could also try stuffing the the roast filet of beef with any combination of:

                      Cheeses...Bleu, Gorgonzola, Provolone or Goat
                      Broccoli Rabe, Spinach or Asparagus
                      Sausage or Bacon
                      Crabmeat or Crawfish
                      Tomatoes or Mushrooms

                      Slice like pinwheel steaks.

                      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBZwLMH7klU

                      http://homecooking.about.com/od/beefrecipes/r/blbeef50.htm

                      http://www.finecooking.com/videos/how...

              2. re: mchinsky
                Kazy Ctn Jul 14, 2010 09:23 AM

                UPDATE - Costco is now selling Prime beef in select stores. I personally have seen unbutchered strips and ribeyes. Slightly pricier, but FAR less than you could find elsewhere..

              3. g
                guurtje Jan 12, 2009 01:17 PM

                Hi, I found Costco tenderloin to be great but with one problem for me. It gives me restless legs. I am very sensitive to MSG so that tells me they are putting something on their meat that does not belong there. Anyone else have this problem? Thanks

                4 Replies
                1. re: guurtje
                  c
                  cstr Jan 13, 2009 07:44 AM

                  It just meat nothing added, I'd check what else you ate.

                  1. re: cstr
                    ccbweb Jan 13, 2009 10:00 AM

                    I agree with cstr, according to all of the labeling (and how it tastes) Costco tenderloin is just tenderloin.

                  2. re: guurtje
                    ipsedixit Jan 13, 2009 02:47 PM

                    MSG gives you restless leg syndrome??

                    1. re: guurtje
                      m
                      misterhyde Jan 21, 2009 05:53 AM

                      Beef tenderloin is naturally high in uric acid/purines. If you have hyperuricemia or a similar disorder, proceed carefully.

                    2. r
                      Ranger05 Feb 8, 2008 03:46 PM

                      I can't imagine you'd be dissapointed w/ Costco loins. Personally i've found Costco's beef to be a slight bit better then that of most local butchers i've tried. Saving twice the cash and most likely ending up with a cut of meat thats as good or better than your butcher sounds like a no-brainer. Go w/ Costco!

                      7 Replies
                      1. re: Ranger05
                        Shane Greenwood Feb 9, 2008 05:59 AM

                        Cooks Illustrated's Test Kitchen did a review of tenderloins a couple of years ago and Costco won out against some other very reputable butchers and more expensive options.

                        1. re: Ranger05
                          k
                          KevinB Feb 11, 2008 03:17 PM

                          My local groceries ("No Frills" and "Price Chopper" both sell vacuum-packed strip loins for $3.99/lb - which is a lot less than Costco charges! I find them very tasty, and I don't put anything on except for a grill mix (which is mostly salt and pepper). I have nothing against Costco, but the groceries sell the loins in 2-5 lb portions, instead of the 10-20 loins at Costco, and as a single guy, I can only eat steak so often.

                          1. re: KevinB
                            jayt90 Feb 13, 2008 11:18 AM

                            Those are USDA select strips, Costco is choice or AAA.
                            Another option is Angus AAA rib eyes, last day sale, at A&P/Dominion.

                            1. re: KevinB
                              c
                              caitlink Feb 17, 2008 06:28 PM

                              I don't find the meat at Price Chopper that appetizing, or Food Basic for that matter. We do buy striploins from No Frills and I find them to be very good. But no where near the Costco tenderloin we serve at dinner parties.

                              The pieces at Costco are quite big but we usually cut into smaller portions and freeze.

                              1. re: KevinB
                                e
                                embee Feb 25, 2008 02:55 PM

                                The whole strip loins and tenderloins at those stores is USDA Select, which is really low quality meat. What's somewhat shocking to me is that the high priced kin of No Frills (Loblaw's) and Price Chopper (Sobey's) also sell this stuff.

                                No mainstream supermarket in the US routinely sells such poorly graded meat. Since meat grading is based on a visual inspection of what are, essentially, clues, and inspection/grading do not guarantee eating quality, it is possible to get a good slab of select (or a poor slab of prime for that matter). But the odds are against you.

                                The meat at Costco is more likely to be graded USDA Choice or Canada AA or AAA.

                                1. re: embee
                                  j
                                  jlawrence01 Feb 25, 2008 03:28 PM

                                  >>No mainstream supermarket in the US routinely sells such poorly graded meat.<<

                                  I have seen it in various Safeway (Dominicks), SuperValu (Jewel), Krogers and WalMart stores, the four largest supermarkets in the US. How much more mainstream can you get?

                                  1. re: jlawrence01
                                    e
                                    embee Feb 25, 2008 06:35 PM

                                    I'll need to defer to you on that. It marks a major change from when I lived in the US, and (later) when I spent a lot of time there :-(

                                    Stores such as Safeway, SuperValu, and Kroger advertised from the rooftops that they never sold anything below Choice. I wasn't aware that things had changed. (There were no Wal-Mart food stores at the time.)

                                    Our first Wal-Mart Supercentres in Toronto seem to be selling mainly Canada AA.

                                    My other comment regarding Canada still holds. Loblaw's and Sobey's are positioned as high end stores selling only Canada AA and AAA beef (and the Certified Angus brand at some Loblaw stores). Selling Select graded meat borders on scandalous. It is labeled honestly, but customers don't understand the meaning and think they are getting a bargain.

                            2. o
                              oaktowngirl Dec 5, 2007 09:33 AM

                              We have served the tenderloin from Costco with pride at our dinner parties. It is good quality at a reasonable price. If we did not purchase the meat at Costco, we would not be able to afford to offer our guests tenderloin. (Makes us look good to the in-laws!)

                              5 Replies
                              1. re: oaktowngirl
                                m
                                mark48 Feb 8, 2008 03:01 PM

                                I have a good friend who works for a large agribusiness. he sells meat to Costco. when I told him I love their flank steak (london broil yum) and their tenderloin he told me "Costco only buys choice or better and they sell it for pennies /pound over their purchase price. If you buy your meat anywhere but Costco, you are probably getting screwed" I believe him, and I buy all my meat and poultry there. try their rotiserie chicken, best 5 bucks you'll ever spend! I pick up 1 a week at least!

                                1. re: mark48
                                  coney with everything Feb 9, 2008 05:32 AM

                                  Mark, does your friend know if Costco stipulates that their meat not come from "downer" or sick cows?

                                  1. re: coney with everything
                                    r
                                    ricepad Feb 10, 2008 12:01 AM

                                    It's hard to imagine that a downer would grade at choice or better.

                                    1. re: coney with everything
                                      x
                                      xanadude Feb 10, 2008 09:13 PM

                                      I'm under the impression that downers are not fit for human consumption in the US (post BSE). While I have no doubt that awful things are done to circumvent this rule (google Hallmark/Westland, for example), no stipulation would be necessary, as it's required by law.

                                      I could be wrong, though.

                                      1. re: xanadude
                                        coney with everything Feb 11, 2008 04:42 AM

                                        check out the food media and news board for a discussion of why to be picky about where to buy your beef

                                2. d
                                  diner101 Dec 5, 2007 09:30 AM

                                  I may get a lot of different opinons on my reply. None of the previous posters have answered the real question: how does Costco tenderloin and rib roasts compare to Andronico, Draeger's, Whole Foods, Piedomont Grocery, local butchers, and Costco price per lb is much cheaper? I find Costco's is just as good as the higher priced ones. I have even tried the "aged" prime rib from Whole Foods (San Mateo) and find very little diffference. So, save some money and buy at Costco since tenderloin is always tender. Anyone differ??

                                  2 Replies
                                  1. re: diner101
                                    m
                                    malibumike Dec 6, 2007 12:48 PM

                                    In studying Tenderloin I have found that most opinions including mine find that there is almost no difference in prime or choice Tenderloin because there is very little marbeling. Now rib eye steaks there can be a big difference in taste/tenderness because of the fat content and distribution through the steak, the more marbeling the more likelihood that it will be graded prime. Most caterers like to serve Tenderloin because they make the most profit on it, they dont need to buy prime. By itself Tenderloin has very little taste that is why when you go to a restaurant they almost always serve it with some kind of sauce to liven it up. That said I wouldn't waste my money buying from Bristol Farms, Whole Paycheck, or the like, you'll just throw your money away - buy it from Costco.

                                    1. re: diner101
                                      Shane Greenwood Dec 6, 2007 01:15 PM

                                      Read the Cooks Illustrated article. They compare Costco tenderloin against several specific purveyors including local butchers, mail order and supermarket. They break down the price per pound comparison and relative quality. I think it was the Feb 2005 issue and you can find it on their website. It's the most rational answer to your question that you'll find.

                                      BTW diner101: the OP's queation wasn't about Andronico's, Draegers and Whole Foods, so that's why nobody is answering that question.

                                    2. s
                                      swsidejim Dec 5, 2007 08:46 AM

                                      I like Costco, but I have only purchased meat from them once or twice, it was ok, but not as good as what I can purchase at a local butcher.

                                      I prefer to support my local family owned butcher. They have prime beef, as well as dry aged beef, so I have no need to go elsewhere. Also the money I spend stays local, and keeps a mom & pop meat market open, one less swallowed up by a corporate behemoth.

                                      2 Replies
                                      1. re: swsidejim
                                        baron45 Dec 5, 2007 09:17 AM

                                        I know we're talking about beef, but here's something about pork. Although Costco pork is good, you really can't beat the prices and freshness of pork sold in Chinatown or the Asian supermarkets. They will typically sell pork chops for $1.89 a pound and it's the lean boneless ones, not the fatty lower-grade cuts that Safeway advertises for the same price.

                                        1. re: baron45
                                          Ruth Lafler Dec 5, 2007 09:32 AM

                                          But is there anything more tasteless than a lean, boneless pork chop? I'm usually looking for the opposite: pork with at least some marbling (the more the better). Not to say that supermarket pork is good -- it isn't, and most of it these days is injected with salt solution so they can guarantee it as moist and tender. If I want brined pork, I'd rather do it myself.

                                      2. grishnackh Dec 5, 2007 06:27 AM

                                        I'll echo the other posters here to say that I've had very positive experiences with Costco's whole tenderloins. During the summer I love to cut one up into thick cubes and marinate for some of the most indulgent shish kebabs you will ever taste.

                                        Alton Brown did an episode of "Good Eats" about where to buy them [Costco natch], how to trim them, and how to cook the various parts. You can likely find it on YouTube.

                                        1 Reply
                                        1. re: grishnackh
                                          b
                                          brendastarlet Dec 5, 2007 06:34 AM

                                          I was at a dinner party with well-to-do friends in Chicago, who buy all their meat for parties at Costco. Even though I am a strong believer in supporting local merchants, the meal tasted delicious. So I would say, go ahead.

                                        2. Shane Greenwood Dec 5, 2007 06:15 AM

                                          Cook's Illustrated did a piece on whole beef tenderloin a couple of years ago (Feb 2005 issue). They gave several beef tenderloins the full test-kitchen treatment. The Costco tenderloin was the winner. For flavor, texture and price it can't be beat. You do have to trim it yourself, but at least you get to keep the chain to use for another dish.

                                          1. j
                                            Janet Dec 4, 2007 10:13 PM

                                            We find Costco meat to be very good. Their quality is as good or better than groceries. We have bought the tenderloins and cut filets, cooked the whole tenderloins. We have never had a problem with Costco meat.

                                            1. f
                                              fourunder Dec 4, 2007 07:21 PM

                                              One of the things Costco prides itself on is it's quality of products and their ability to save their customers money. If they can find a source for any product to save and increase their profit margin....quality will not be sacrificed.

                                              Unless you are purchasing from a butcher who offers hanging beef only for his customers.... most butchers purchase cry-o-vac beef, the same that is supplied to other markets and commercial restaurants. Just the mere fact of purchasing from a butcher per se, does not guarantee quality beef. It all comes down to grades.

                                              Costco sells only USDA Choice. Prime Grade is the best. Select Grade is below Choice. Standard is ungraded meat.

                                              The grading system is used by Meat Packers and only if they pay the government for the service. The grading system has to do with the marbling(Fat) content which determines grade. Kobe beef for example is believed to be the best steaks due to their high fat content which results in a tastier steak if cooked properly.

                                              Buying from Costco is recommended.

                                              9 Replies
                                              1. re: fourunder
                                                h
                                                Humbucker Dec 4, 2007 07:55 PM

                                                The USDA grade doesn't matter too much with tenderloin because the tenderloin has very little fat and basically no marbling.

                                                1. re: fourunder
                                                  x
                                                  xanadude Dec 4, 2007 08:31 PM

                                                  Aging also matters, as does breed, diet, and even the individual cow.

                                                  1. re: xanadude
                                                    Pollo Dec 5, 2007 06:38 AM

                                                    Aging tenderloin is not realy necessary since it's tender already....

                                                    1. re: Pollo
                                                      f
                                                      fourunder Dec 5, 2007 08:06 AM

                                                      Aging meats does tenderize, but it is also done to intensify the flavor.

                                                      Note that for the tenderloin , this would only be done in most cases when it is part of the short loin still attached to the bone with the fat layer protecting it from direct air contact.

                                                      1. re: fourunder
                                                        Pollo Dec 5, 2007 08:33 AM

                                                        Yes, but in case of the tenderloin it's like tenderizing butter....

                                                      2. re: Pollo
                                                        x
                                                        xanadude Dec 5, 2007 08:07 AM

                                                        it's also flavor

                                                    2. re: fourunder
                                                      r
                                                      ricepad Dec 6, 2007 11:29 AM

                                                      One clarification: Costco's contracts with their suppliers specify "USDA Choice or better", meaning that if the supplier runs out of Choice, they may have to provide Costco with Prime to meet the order. Every now and then, you'll find a sub-primal with a 'Prime' stamp on it. Not very often, but when I'm in Costco and have a little time to spare, I'll troll the meatcase, hunting for the 'Prime' meat. Buying USDA Prime at Costco's USDA Choice prices is the best of all possible worlds!

                                                      1. re: ricepad
                                                        grishnackh Dec 7, 2007 07:00 AM

                                                        Ricepad, that is a good datum to know. Thanks!

                                                        1. re: ricepad
                                                          l
                                                          lergnom May 27, 2009 05:40 PM

                                                          The Costco's in E. MA generally have prime.

                                                      2. kungful Dec 4, 2007 06:55 PM

                                                        I've bought the whole tenderloins from Costco a couple times and been very happy.
                                                        The quality is superior to Safeway/Albertsons/generic grocer

                                                        Show Hidden Posts