HOME > Chowhound > Pacific Northwest >
Are you making a specialty food? Tell us about it
TELL US

Disappointed w/ Elliott's, looking for great nontouristy places for oysters in Seattle(?)

g
GDSwamp Dec 3, 2007 06:15 AM

In town for a few days and feeling perversely lucky to be wandering around downtown in this stormy weather - its perfect for the fish markets, guys in orange overalls, views of the Sound.

Last night at Elliott's (which a bunch of folks on chound recommend) was a bit of a disappointment. Oysters were good, but didn't like the gimmicky frozen mignonette (it was watery). The rest of our food was incredibly plentiful but just alright. Our waiter was so enthusiastic about everything that we felt like jerks for finding the fish and sides uninspiring.

Anyway, who cares about all that other food? We should have just gotten oysters and skipped the rest. Along that line, I'm wondering if there's a place in the city that's top-notch for just sitting and eating oysters (rest of the menu irrelevant), and that maybe feels less like a Seattle Seaside Themepark and more like a straight-up oyster bar.

Or would we have had a different experience if we'd just sat at the bar at Elliott's...?

Thanks

  1. Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. o
    oliveoyl Dec 3, 2007 08:49 AM

    yep, just sit at the bar, it's much better than the dining room ...schukers at the olympic hotel is pretty great for oysters also ...

    1. h
      howard 1st Dec 3, 2007 09:26 AM

      the draw at elliot's - in addition to the view - is their happy hour policy of oysters progressing in price as the afternoon wanes. if you are not bothered by paying upwards of $2 per oyster, then the advice about shucker's is good or the oyster bar at oceanaire. sadly, our fair city lacks any if the down-n-dirty oysters joints of questionable hygiene but wonderful bivalves so common in other shellfish havens

      1. terrier Dec 3, 2007 09:48 AM

        The bar at Elliott's is better, yes, but I say go back to the market, forget the boys in orange who throw the fish and wander over to Jack's Fish Spot instead.

        Order a dozen on the half-shell and sit at the counter. It doesn't get more bare-bones but it's legit. The cioppino and the fish & chips are pretty good as well.

        1. j
          jaydeflix Dec 3, 2007 03:35 PM

          I always liked The Brooklyn or FX McRory's for oysters. Definitely sit at the bar at FX (or in the bar area... the dining room sucks). The Brooklyn's happy hour oysters are worth the low price.

          Chinook's out at Fisherman's Terminal has a nice view and good oysters as well, and awesome salty buttery garlic bread.

          Dang, now I need to go to Chinooks.

          1. Charles Dec 3, 2007 04:41 PM

            Also the Flying Fish in Belltown. I am not sure, but I think they are still doing oyster happy hour at 0.25 apiece before 6:00 it is hard to beat. Mostly an upscale crowd, after work hipsters scoring a nosh and a cocktail.

            1 Reply
            1. re: Charles
              s
              savorlicious Dec 5, 2007 09:18 AM

              I have never had good experiences with the oysters at Flying Fish. I want to love them but in my experience, the haven't been shucked well - I always get shell bits. Even though it is a chain, I have always gotten great oysters at Oceanaire (7th & Olive). And as with many of the other recommendations, just sit in the bar.

            2. m
              mrnelso Dec 4, 2007 09:20 AM

              For sure you need to have a look at Jack's Fish spot in the Pike Place Market.

              1 Reply
              1. re: mrnelso
                landguy Dec 5, 2007 10:57 AM

                Another vote for Jack's. Why bother with any place else.

              2. a
                alki_chick Dec 4, 2007 12:18 PM

                Shucker's is great as well as the Brooklyn but if you don't mind a some what hole in the wall I suggest Emmett Watson's Oyster Bar in Pike Place Market.

                3 Replies
                1. re: alki_chick
                  b
                  bluedog67 Dec 4, 2007 12:51 PM

                  I was also going to suggest Emmett Watsons's - presuming it is still there. Yes it is in the market, but lacks the toursit/themepark feel.

                  1. re: bluedog67
                    d
                    doublesuited77 Dec 5, 2007 05:17 PM

                    Shuckers by far...and it isn't close

                    1. re: doublesuited77
                      a
                      A2fay Dec 5, 2007 11:11 PM

                      Oh contrare mon frere!!!The Brooklyns happy hour is THE BEST for a true raw lover and the Flying Fish for oysters and any other seafood needs is ALWAYS a home run;)

                2. g
                  GDSwamp Dec 12, 2007 06:18 AM

                  Thanks for the recs, all. I had only a few meals at my disposal, since the Seattle trip was just 2.5 days, but I ate well. Never did get to go to another strictly oyster-centric spot after Elliott's, but did have a great plate of Quilcenes at Steelhead Diner (their frozen mignonette was actually better - less watery - than Elliott's, but I still think the whole idea is a dumb gimmick) and a quite good plate of some other variety at Le Pichet. Also nice frites at Pichet, a good burger at Steelhead, a really excellent meal at Zoe, and a better-than-I-can-get-in-Philly Thai lunch at a very crowded hole-in-the-wall somewhere around First and Columbia, and a delicious $2.75 apple from a produce stand near Pike Place Market (should've known better).

                  All in all, very good eating. Next time I'll try Emmett Watson's and Elliott's happy hour if I'm on my own dime, and some of the other places people mentioned if someone else is paying the tab.

                  Show Hidden Posts