HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Discussion

?s for marshmallow makers

I'd like to make some for Christmas gifts, but don't have a stand mixer. I have a hand-held which is pretty powerful, but would my HAND last?

Do you have any technique advice and/or flavor favorites to share?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. I've got to be honest, having made homemade marshmallows several time, I can't even imagine doing it with a hand-held mixer... They whip on a super super high speed for 10 minutes... And they get quite thick -- I think you might burn out the motor on a hand mixer. Do you have a friend who has a stand mixer that you could borrow? And I'm assuming you've seen the 500+ post thread on egullet about homemade marshmallows and all their flavor variations?

    6 Replies
    1. re: fearlessemily

      no- I don't go to egullet but I'll look there. I have a lead on a stand mixer! thanks for the feedback.

      1. re: toodie jane

        I have only a strong hand-held mixer - not even a high end one, just Black and Decker - and it's never burnt out making marshmallows, nor has my arm fallen off. You're just whipping a lot of sugar goo and gelatin, not a stiff dough. Just be sure to use a really large bowl, because the volume of the mixture increases a lot.

        1. re: Caitlin McGrath

          Only you know whether your arm will fall off, but if you can borrow a stand mixer, by all means do so, your arm will certainly thank you. I wouldn't avoid the project for lack of one, though. I've never made marshmallows but I have made genoises and kourabiedes (Greek shortbread) with 10+ year old KA hand mixer and while my arm wasn't particularly amused, the mixer didn't blink The consistency of the genoise batter sounds somewhat similar and it takes quite a while to beat whole eggs to moderately stiff peaks. Beating 1 1/2 lbs of cool butter for 30+ minutes for the cookies certainly isn't the lightest-duty task you can set a mixer too...

          1. re: MikeG

            my Viennese pastry instructor showed us a trick to holding a hand mixer for less strain: grasp the mixer around the body (sliding you hand under the handle, not around it) and there is much less shoulder strain.

            1. re: MikeG

              As I noted, making marshmallows with a hand mixer is far different from beating a stiff dough - and it is certainly easier, in my experience, than whipping eggs for genoise. I've never had the luxury of having a stand mixer to use for anything, but I've not found marshmallows to be challenging with my hand mixer. You do need a hand mixer with stamina, though.

        2. re: fearlessemily

          I agree with Emily. My husband burned out the motor on our handheld a few years ago when he was on a big marshmallow making kick. The stand mixer is pretty much necessary.

        3. Over the summer, I ate at a 3-star Michelin restaurant in Epernay, France (Champagne region) who served canteloupe-flavored marshmallows. Sensational! They were served in a log form (about 10" long x 1-1/2" wide x 1" high) on a platter with a pair of sterling silver scissors. Really wonderful. You're making me think I ought to try marshmallow-making for Christmas gifts! I do have a Kitchen Aid mixer that I dislike and never bother to use. But I think I'll dust it off and make some marshmallows this weekend. Thanks.

          1. I made marshmallows last year (and I'll be making them again this year) and it was so easy with the stand mixer. I do agree, however, that since it's not a stiff dough that it might not be impossible to make them with a hand mixer. Besides, people were making marshmallows long before there were mixers of any kind, though I can't imagine making them by hand!

            1. Two things: first, I just saw that the Good Eats tomorrow at 8PM EST is about making marshmallows. Second, I have personally burnt out the motor on a hand-held mixer on marshmallows.

              Good luck!

              7 Replies
              1. re: optimal forager

                watching Alton pour the hot syrup into the egg whites and seeing the viscosity of the finished product has made me rethink using a hand mixer. I'm glad you gave me the heads up about his show; it gave me some very valuable tips. Thank you!

                1. re: toodie jane

                  oops I see there were no egg whites--I came into the show as he was pouring the syrup into the large bowl--in Alton's recipe. I found a Gourmet recipe that uses 2 egg whites, and instructions include using a hand mixer--maybe I'll try that one.

                2. re: optimal forager

                  I saw this last night as well. My husband has been wanting to make marshamallows for a while now and I haven't gotten around to researchign the how to, etc. Is Altons recipe/method a pretty typical one? Is there a better one to try out there?

                  1. re: ziggylu

                    I watched it too. I bought ingredients a couple days ago, and was waiting to see the show. His recipe seemed like the most common one. Similar to Martha Stewart's one. You can Google it. I guess there are some recipes that include egg, but they seem to be less favored.

                      1. re: ziggylu

                        OK thanks. I think I"m going to try making some next week. I'd like to make peppermint...do i just add some extract in? If so, at what point, early on or at the finish?

                        1. re: ziggylu

                          I bought some TJ's pepermint marshmallows this week, and they'd poured a layer of regular marshmallow into the pan, then topped with a layer that had VERY finely crushed peppermint candy for a second layer. Not too over the top minty. Nice. If you use mint extract, be careful-- use a toothpick to pick up drops. Add drop by drop. Like julietq I now use peppermint essential oil (after a 'mishap' with extract).

                    1. I made chocolate covered peppermint marshmallows the other day as a test run for Xmas. Using Martha Stewart's recipe (the EXACT same one as the one on that egullet thread, btw) and I substituted peppermint oil for the vanilla. I melted some lovely 70% Vahlrona, added a few tablespoons of powdered sugar, and dipped the cut squares (use scissors to cut them- it's easier than a knife) in the chocolate. Cooled on wax paper.

                      **drool**

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: julietg

                        Juliet, I'll be right over to save you from eating all of those marshmallows by yourself...