Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Nov 17, 2007 06:13 PM

Dark molasses substitute?

I'm making pumpkin pie and recipe asks for 2Tb dark molasses. Is there something I can use instead? Thank you and Happy Thanksgiving to all!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I found this: Molasses Substitute

    For 1 cup, use 1 cup honey; or 3/4 cup firmly packed brown sugar; or granulated sugar plus 1/4 cup liquid (water or other liquid called for in recipe); 1 cup dark corn syrup; or 1 cup pure maple syrup.

    I think I'd go with the brown sugar.

    3 Replies
    1. re: Pat Hammond

      Pat, thanks so much. I'll just added some extra brown sugar to the recipe...just don''t need another bottle (or jar) of some esoterica in my already overloaded cabinet!

      1. re: Sarah

        Or you could finish off the brown sugar, and replace it with a jar of molasses. Next time a recipe calls for brown sugar use white plus molasses (to taste). I do, though, keep some expensive Billington's on hand. But most of the grocery store brown sugar is just white plus molasses.

        1. re: Sarah

          Molasses is not esoterica at my house ;) Not only can I not do Christmas baking without it, it's also great for BBQ ... even a tad in spaghetti sauce (though I usually use brown sugar if I have it).

      2. I think it just adds to the dark/spicy taste. You can use brown sugar instead of white sugar (I don't know your recipe -- if it calls for brown sugar + molasses OR white sugar + molasses; I'm saying, if it's white sugar + molasses, replace ALL the white sugar with brown). Maple syrup would be nice too.

        What I do is add the eggs at the end. That way I can taste the batter and fiddle with the spices without worrying about raw eggs.

        1. brown sugar is white sugar with molasses added back in, so that's the way to go if you want to keep to that flavor profile.

          6 Replies
          1. re: Karl S

            I've done the molasses + white sugar = brown sugar substitute and it comes out tasting **much** heavier molassesy than I usually want. I like the flavor of molasses in things like gingerbread or other spicy things, but I am not sure I care for a heavy molasses flavor in, say, chocolate chip cookies. Please advise.

            1. re: willownt

              Instead of thinking about replacing brown sugar, it might help to think of molasses as a seasoning. My gut sense is that for cookies where I want just a hint of this flavor, I would start with 1T per cup of sugar.

              1. re: paulj

                Also, there are different kinds of molasses. There's a very dark and a lighter, table molasses available here, on the grocers shelves. You may find that using the lighter molasses, to the recommended 1-2 tablespoons per cup of white sugar, to be a milder flavour, where even 1 tablespoon of the dark molasses may be too strong a taste for you. Experiment a little.


                1. re: violabratsche

                  I wouldn't stop buying brown sugar, in any event, but I am curious about this. I do normally buy the stronger stuff and I'm sure that makes a difference, but I *like* the strong dark taste in gingery treats but I'm looking for something else in other things (say in cinnamon toast or streusel or chocolate chip cookies). Something that doesn't scream molasses.

                  1. re: willownt

                    just buy brown cane sugar, rather than brown beet sugar. less molasses taste, no clumping problems

                    1. re: soupkitten

                      Use dark brown sugar if you are going to substitute it for Molasses and sometimes it is just better to go buy the ingredient because the flavor will probably be different.

          2. And it's cheaper, too. Unless it's different in the US than Canada, brown sugar costs almost twice what white sugar costs, and having molasses around means I can use the cheaper white sugar and a little molasses, and I can make those nice dark bran muffins and gingerbread cake, and the dark gingerbread for Christmas......

            I was pondering the lack of molasses in the pie, and if I were REALLY without molasses (heaven forbid), I'd use something dark, for the colour, like coffee. That could be an interesting flavour in the pie, too.