Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn [Moved from Manhattan board]

[eldereater]

Are there still any good seafood houses in Sheepshead Bay?

[parkslopemama]

Does anyone know if Jordan's Lobster Dock is still there? That was pretty good.

[bigmackdaddy]

Yup it is.

[JFores]

No.

[sam1]

i have to agree here.

[Brettsy]

As far as I'm concerned, the marinara sauce (medium or hot) that comes with the fried calamari at Randazzo's is still unparalleled anywhere in the world. Deep, smoky and perfect. The accompanying bread is also unparalleled—as in, I can't imagine how they could make it so horrendously awful.

[bigmackdaddy]

Randazzo's is great if you want to see Old Brooklyn, as in most of the patrons, otherwise the seafood is overcooked and bland. I'm not a fan of that sauce either.

[fishermb]

There's not a whole lot of places to get a plate of scungili, I'm still a fan of certain dishes at Randazzo's.