Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Southwest >
Nov 12, 2007 06:43 AM

Garland's Lodge - Sedona, AZ

I just returned from my annual journey to Garland's Lodge, in Sedona, AZ. If you don't know the history of the place, you can check it out at, but - in short - it's an old rustic lodge on Oak Creek with gorgeous guest cabins throughout the property. It's definitely an Arizona tradition; my parents had been going there for decades and my wife and I took over the annual tradition about three years ago. Basically, you stay in the cabins and they serve you an INCREDIBLE breakfast each morning at the lodge, an afternoon tea with snacks, and a great dinner each night. The kitchen is run by chef Amanda Stine (check out her cook book; great recipes and history of the lodge). No phones, no television, no cell reception (tough for me!)....and it invites you to relax fully.

Unfortunately, nights at Garlands are sold out years in advance but - if you're patient and a little bit flexible, you can often get in on a cancellation. People fight over their nights at Garlands in their divorces....seriously. Like a reservaton at The French Laundry, it's that coveted.

We usually stay Friday and Saturday nights, and had fabulous Swiss Eggs and freshly caught trout for breakfast and wild salmon and rack of pork for dinner. You don't get a choice of your dinner entrees, so let them know if you have any dietary requirements and they will be honored. We don't even tell them my wife's requirements; they always remember from prior years. They also remember that it's our anniversary weekend, and they put our anniversary on the menu, and even get the year right. In about 40 years I'll need them to remind me how many years we're ve been married! Nice personal touches. They do have a very limited number of dinner reservations each night for people not staying at the lodge.

The best part of the experience is that you get seated with other "Lodgers" at dinner. It's part of the tradition; they usually give us our own table on the first night and we sit with someone new on the second night. Irononically, this was the first year that we had our own table both nights. (Did we look creepy? Smell bad?!?!) It was nice to be together, but being seated with someone else (at least one night) adds to the charm of the place and we always come back with some great stories. We always meet interesting people, trade stories, and go back to our cabin at night with great stories. People often go the same weekend each year, so you start to know people who are there the same weekend as you year after year.

My wife and I are usually the youngest people there (we're in our early 30s) but feel that the Garlands tradition is one for all ages. We always feel a little bit out-of-place at first due to our age, but that goes away. We live in N. Scottsdale, and it's so refreshing to escape the conspicuous consumption that surrounds us for a place that harkens back to simpler times. It puts other Sedona fine dining to shame. If you were considering L'Auberge, try Garland's first. You won't be disappointed and you will have found one of our state's true gems.

I know that the Garlands folks are Chow Hounds too, and I wanted to say thanks for another incredible weekend full or relaxation and food. Garlands certainly doesn't need the press; they have waiting lists each year, but I thought that it was worth mentioning on the SW Board since I've never seen it here before and it is a uniquely Arizonan foodie tradition. We'll see you next year and thanks, as always, for the memories.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I love it, too and cannot recommend it highly enough. My stays have alway been single nights enroute between Los Angeles and Santa Fe. My fantasy would be a week or longer, arriving with a bunch of books and never starting the car engine after driving across/through the Creek to get there.

    Only area where we disagree is that I actually prefer not to join others over dinner. My book is my company. My first visit I was unaware of the practice and when I saw the place cards in the dining room I actually left and went into Sedona for a truly terrible dinner. When I checked out, they allowed that they had been worried and have since always remembered to let me read, eat and drink a bottle of wine in solitude.

    A great, great place.

    1. May I add "kudos" to Amanda Stine for being a very flexible as well as talented chef. Some years ago, I took an out-of-town CH guest to Garlands. Just before dinner, my guest announced that she doesn't eat pork and roast pork was on the menu. With nary a pause, Chef Stine produced an alternate entree which was pronounced "wonderful" by my guest.

      Everything about Garlands is relaxing and designed to produce a time of repose. It is one of only a few places that I can name without intrusive guest-produced noise.

      1. I just wanted to chime in here and let everyone know that we also had a wonderful meal there about 2 years ago when visiting Sedona. We did not stay there, but called the day before and were able to get a dinner reservation with no problem. Maybe we were just lucky, but I encourage others to try if you are visiting the area. The place is beautiful and sooo relaxing and off the beaten path. Far better than anything else we ate in Sedona. I remember it being very reasonable priced also. Note: it is a prix fix meal. Maybe one of these days, we'll actually stay there!

        1. One more comment: dinner is great, as you all have attested. But breakfast is the best part of the whole experience. Freshly caught trout with corn oysters for breakfast....who knew that could be so good!

          1. We love it too, and are lucky enough to live in town. We try to always take visiting friends for dinner. It is unique and very special.