Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Food Media & News >
Oct 18, 2007 01:11 PM

GQ article: "20 best burgers in America"

Article from GQ:

Here are the 20 best burgers in America

20. Hamburger Sandwich
Louis' Lunch
New Haven, CT

19. Our Famous Burger
Sidetrack Bar and Grill
Ypsilanti, MI

18. Hamburger
Poag Mahone's Carvery and Ale House

17. Double Bacon Deluxe with Cheese
Red Mill Burgers

16. Hamburger & Fries
Burger Joint
San Francisco

15. Build Your Own Burger
The Counter
Santa Monica

14. Hamburger
J. G. Melon
New York City

13. Cheeseburger
White Manna
Hackensack, NJ

12. Hamburger
Bobcat Bite
Sante Fe

11. Grilled Bistro Burger
Bistro Don Giovanni
Napa, CA

10. Number Five
Keller's Drive-in

9. Cheeseburger
Burger Joint, le Parker Meridien Hotel
New York City

8. Hamburger
Miller's Bar
Dearborn, MI

7. Buckhorn Burger
San Antonio, NM

6. California Burger
Santa Monica

5. Kobe Sliders
Barclay Prime

4. Rouge Burger

3. Not Just a Burger
Spiced Pear Restaurant at the Chanler Hotel
Newport, RI

2. Luger Burger
Peter Luger Steak House

1. Sirloin Burger
Le Tub
Hollywood, FL

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The burger at The Counter in Santa Monica is awful. Completely lacking in flavor and it falls apart when you're halfway through it. I'm amazed it made the list!

    7 Replies
    1. re: hrhboo

      Especially when it would have been easy to include Father's Office, the Apple Pan, 25 Degrees or Lucky Devil's instead of the Counter...and why would they mention just the Santa Monica Houston's, isn't it a fairly large chain?

      1. re: Chowpatty

        It's also odd that the list contains kobe burgers, sirloin burgers, cheese burgers, bacon cheeseburgers etc, in addition to the Build Your Own at the Counter (which could have any number of crazy combinations). It is impossible to make a fair comparison.

        1. re: hrhboo

          Maybe its the burger that looks the best when eaten in a snappy suit?

        2. re: Chowpatty

          Apparently the Santa Monica Houston's is different. I've been there and couldn't tell what was special about it but I heard that Oprah has a favorite menu item from that place as well.

        3. re: hrhboo

          I can't believe it either. At minimum it should have included Father's Office over the Counter.

          I also can't believe that the list only has 2 burgers from Los Angeles, which is burger central. It's a very east coast centric list, come to think of it. Of the 20, 8 are from New England.

          1. re: DanaB

            There are only two from New England: one in CT and one in RI. New York and New Jersey are definitely NOT in New England!

            1. re: BillieJean

              And I only count eight if you include the two from Philly as well. The poster must have meant the Northeast Corridor.

        4. When did this list come out. It seems that they do one every six months or so. Will say:

          Haven't been to the Counter. But other than Oprah's 'blessing' have not heard anything too favorable about the place

          Lugers is way over rated.

          Burger joint is good. But it's all prefab even the casual look of the place. Food is all processed frozen stuff anyone can get at Cosco.

          J.G. Mellons should be much higher on the list (their fries could be much better.).

          2 Replies
          1. re: Withnail42

            Lugers is not over rated, the bacon cheeseburger is awesome. One of my favorite lunches is a Luger burger with well done fries( fried in tallow) and an ice cold mug of Beck's. What is overrated is Le Tub. Last year I went out of my way on a trip to Florida and could not have been more disappointed. It was way to big, poorly cooked and not very tasty. No sear on the outside, just not that good. It came on a lousy roll with bad underfried frozen fries.The view was terrific.

            1. re: stuartlafonda

              Luger's burger isn't over-rated but it is inconsistent. Sadly everything at Luger's is inconsistent these days and this includes the porterhouse. When it's on it's the best when it's off it is merely very good.

            1. #16, Burger Joint in SF is a joke compared with the burgers at Zuni Cafe and Slow Club.

              3 Replies
              1. re: Frosty Melon

                I was just thinking that...Burger Joint isn't even the best in SF. I had to read #16 twice to make sure I read it right.

                1. re: Frosty Melon

                  I agree 100% - Zuni makes an awesome burger

                2. Philly is rockin' it with two in the top 5 baby!

                  3 Replies
                  1. re: Chinon00

                    The London has Philly's best burger.

                    1. re: famedalupo

                      I've had neither London's, Rouge's or Prime's burger (although I'm sure that they're all fantastic). The top 5 I've had in order are:
                      1) Good Dog
                      2) Royal Tavern
                      2a) Standard
                      4) North 3rd
                      5) Monk's

                      1. re: Chinon00

                        I posted in another thread about my most gluttonous day ever- lunch at Peter Lugers in Brooklyn, dinner at Barclay Prime.
                        As you can imagine, there were alot of great flavors, most of them cow related. The best thing I ate were the sliders at Barclay Prime. The porterhouse at Lugers was ridiculously good, as was the strip at BP. But those sliders....mmmm....