HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What are you cooking today? Share your food adventure
TELL US

Where can I find good cupcakes

a
akimat21 Oct 13, 2007 02:09 PM

My sister's birthday is coming up and she wants cupcakes instead of a cake, where is a good place to get them from in new york city. Please do not say magnolia because I don't think she would like frosted cornbread. Also I called two little red hens and I refuse to pay 80 bucks for 30 cupcakes. But any other suggestions are welcomed :)

  1. g
    gab Oct 14, 2007 05:59 PM

    My faves are from MItchel London. The icing is delicious and the cake isn't dry.

    1. a
      akimat21 Oct 14, 2007 04:38 PM

      anybody ever heard of tonnie's minis, how are those cupcakes?

      1. a
        akimat21 Oct 14, 2007 04:24 PM

        How small are SSS's cupcakes are they smaller then magnolia's?

        1. jenniebnyc Oct 14, 2007 09:44 AM

          Since I live a block from Buttercup this is my go-to. I really like Sage as well. They are located in Long Island City, but they deliver.

          http://www.sageamericankitchen.com/ki...

          My all time favorite cupcake is at Tate's in Southhampton. I am making my family purchase coconut cupcakes from here for my b-day next month. So yummy, but they don't deliver.

          1. c
            clamneck Oct 13, 2007 04:45 PM

            Cupcake Cafe

            1 Reply
            1. re: clamneck
              n
              nativeNYer Oct 13, 2007 05:20 PM

              i really like buttercup bake shop but, like with hamburgers, everyone has a different opinion. i think it's the cream that really wins me over and the cake tastes light and fresh. i always thought i preferred moist cake but even though these are not moist, they are still amazing. buttercup has an east and west side location and the cupcakes are $12.60/dozen. according to this website, you can get 30 cupcakes for $54.30. i love the red velvet ones but they have countless types listed on the website:
              http://www.buttercupbakeshop.com/ws_m...

            2. s
              SRHNYC Oct 13, 2007 03:56 PM

              CRUMBS!!!! They are MAGNIFICIENT. There are several locations in the city - I have been to the one on E 8th street. I have tried Magnolia Bakery, Sugar Sweet Sunshine (my office orders from there during celebrations) however I prefer Crumbs hands down. Why? They are FRESH, always moist and have such a variety! I am the ultimate chocaholic so I especially love the Reeses PB and Oreo cupcakes - they are to die for!

              1 Reply
              1. re: SRHNYC
                l
                LolaNYC Oct 14, 2007 04:56 PM

                Crumbs is good, but only if you order them. Then they will be made fresh for you. I've bought them from when walking right into the store and they are often dry and more often taste like freezer burn.

                When fresh I've always found them good. They are expense, $3.50 for the specialty version, but they go a long way. They are so big, we always cut them into quarter because everyone wants to taste as many different falvors as possible.

              2. l
                Lucia Oct 13, 2007 03:49 PM

                Billy's
                Little Red Hens is also good--bigger than Billy's
                Lots of opinions on this, so you might do a search.

                2 Replies
                1. re: Lucia
                  jakew8 Oct 14, 2007 03:19 PM

                  The OP specifically said that Little Red Hens was too expensive!

                  1. re: Lucia
                    a
                    akimat21 Oct 14, 2007 04:26 PM

                    I did hear little red hen's was good but man I cannot bring myself to pay that price unless they are bigger then average size cupcakes and they taste extremely good

                  2. a
                    AC041 Oct 13, 2007 02:33 PM

                    Without a doubt, go to Sugar Sweet Sunshine Bakery in the LES. I think that they have the best cupcakes in the city.

                    http://www.sugarsweetsunshine.com/

                    3 Replies
                    1. re: AC041
                      k
                      kathryn Oct 13, 2007 09:36 PM

                      At $1.50/cupcake, SSS are probably the most economical, too.

                      1. re: kathryn
                        r
                        RedVelvet Oct 14, 2007 02:46 PM

                        Economical in size, too, I'll add.
                        I had an issue with their attitude for a long time but last week I decided to give them another try. Very nice girl at the counter (none of the owners), polite and smiling. I got 4 cupcakes - 2 of the sexy red velvet, 1 sassy red velvet, 1 ooey gooey. Besides the miniature size (do they make cupcake pans that small?? I mean really, 3 normal bites a cupcake) they were kind of blah. The frosting on the red velvet was buttery (nothing wrong with butter, it's better than shortening, but I expected cream cheese frosting - or am I wrong?)
                        The other two kinds were just I expected given my previous experience with SSS, cocoa flavored but no distinguishable taste between them, the only difference being the colors of the colored sugar and sprinkles on top - a bit too generous for my taste.

                        Definitely a matter of personal taste, but for me no more SSS - just as I gave up on Magnolia when they started charging $5 for a measly (pre-marked on top, they say) slice of cake. I'm all for supporting small businesses but when I feel I'm taken advantage off I'd rather give up and eventually do my own baking.

                        1. re: RedVelvet
                          g
                          gabandgobble Oct 14, 2007 03:09 PM

                          I have to agree that Sugar Sweet Sunshine has really good cupcakes, much better than Magnolia's. Magnolia's cupcakes are way too dry, while Sugar Sweet Sunshine's are fluffy and moist. I really liked the yellow cupcakes and the pistachio cupcakes, the frosting on the pistachio tastes like it's made from cream cheese, which makes it totally awesome.

                    2. g
                      gloriousfood Oct 13, 2007 02:24 PM

                      Make my Cake, 116th & St. Nicolas (one of 2 locations).
                      http://www.makemycake2.com/

                      Show Hidden Posts