Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Washington DC & Baltimore >
Oct 8, 2007 03:15 PM

Great Georgetown place with excellent wine list

In DC from out of town and looking for a terrific restaurant which has a really good wine list. Preferrably something which is not a chain-type place or a hotel restaurant. Any recommendations would be appreciated.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
    1. re: elegantelliot

      Hook is new and good and Citronelle is the best restaraunt in town if you really wont to go over the top.

      1. re: elegantelliot

        From personal experience, I think Citronelle is overrated.

        I sometimes wonder how many of the people here extolling the place have actually eaten there.

        1. re: Hal Laurent

          agree w/ opinion on citronelle. michele is one of the "old gods". loved fabio but has re-located to the big apple.

          1. re: Hal Laurent

            I've eaten there and I loved it. But it is a techinically a hotel restaurant. I don't remember a ton about the wine list since I was with my father and when he is present he's in charge of the wine. But the food is exceptional and perfectly creative.

            1. re: Hal Laurent

              I've only eaten at the lounge, which I highly recommend. Informal, no reservations necessary, and the service is fast. Hit it before a movie. Go for the soft shell crab ($16 per person.) Completely astounding. If you like it, then keep on ordering. Go on to the Mushroom cigars ($14, enough for two) and the Tuna Napoleon. Desserts are $10. You just might change your tune.

            2. re: elegantelliot

              It's also considered one of the best wine lists in the country (see james beard award for wine service)

            3. re: elegantelliot

              Sonoma is actually on Capitol Hill. But perhaps you might want to try out their sister restaurant Mendocino in Georgetown.

            4. Citronelle is wonderful, IMO. Sure it's located in a hotel, but so what? If wine is what you care about, and from your title G'town is where you want to be, also check out Mendocino Grille and Wine Bar.

              3000 M Street NW, Washington, DC 20007

              Mendocino Grille & Wine Bar
              2917 M Street, NW, Washington, DC 20007

              3 Replies
                1. re: elegantelliot

                  Second for Mendocino Grille! I really like their food. I can't remember if it's all California wines or not, though.

                  1. re: pomme de terre

                    I'd say Hook or 1789 (1789 is a bit off the beaten track--near the University, but it's a DC staple with great food and a lovely history)

              1. Thanks for the suggestions everyone. We tried both BLT and Citronelle. BLT was good, food was excellent, unpretensious steak house fare with a a flare. Meat was excellent. Wine list was very good and expense. The place was a little loud and cramped - but quieted down once the happy hour ended - but all in very friendly and comfortable.
                Citronelle - was an great food experience rather than a great meal. The dishes were very clever (especially the lobster pasta disguised as a can of caviar) but rescued from being too much by tasting delicious. The the wine list was stunning and very expensive, with a handful of bargains. The unfortunate aspect was the dining room itself and the general feel of the place - it was like eating in a nice basement in the dark - our party had to ask for a pen light to read the menu and wine list and the air-conditioning vent kept going on an off at oddly high volume. Service was good though a waiter's attempts to take away the same half empty wine glass got a little annoying.