HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Do you create unique foods? Get great advice

Seeking Burgers Near Union Square

kspace Oct 6, 2007 09:52 AM

Hey gang - Any suggestions? - K.

  1. guttergourmet Nov 22, 2007 04:32 AM

    Washington Place near 6th avenue-The Stoned Crow is better than all previously mentioned burgers (and I've had them all).

    1. l
      lookingforpig Oct 8, 2007 12:58 PM

      Borough Food and Drink has a really good burger, just north of Union Square.

      1 Reply
      1. re: lookingforpig
        ESNY Nov 21, 2007 07:54 AM

        Completely disagree. I think the Borough burger was terrible the cheddar was completely wrong for a burger and they can't cook it to the right doneness. Add that to terrible service and a mediocre rest of the menu.

        Go to Shake Shack. Since its colder out, there is no longer any wait and the burger is still fantastic. otherwise, Molly's is good but is a huge, loosely packed burger. I like goodburger but haven't tried the new location near Union Sq but as long as its comparable to the one on 43rd, it should be good.

      2. Bob Martinez Oct 8, 2007 11:04 AM

        In case you want to sit down (rather than wait on line for 45 minutes) the Old Town bar serves a very respectable burger in a classic old time New York saloon environment.

        And it's very close - 45 East 18th St.



        1 Reply
        1. re: Bob Martinez
          TBird Nov 21, 2007 07:35 AM

          "(rather than wait on line for 45 minutes) "<--- i have never waited 45 minutes at shake shack. i have walked away because of the line appearing to be 45 minutes tho, but don't assume that there is always that long of a wait.

        2. cmballa Oct 7, 2007 09:50 AM

          My friends and I call the single-patty Shack Burger the Gestalt Burger. If you add patties or mushroom caps or make other odd decisions, the delicate balance between charred protein, carbohydrate and mayo-enriched vegetables is replaced by a gluttonous mess.

          1. b
            brantHealthShoppe Oct 6, 2007 05:52 PM

            I'm loving BLT Burger lately - get either the BLT Burger (w/american cheese) or the Marguez Burger (though it could be spicier). Great milkshakes!

            1. l
              Lucia Oct 6, 2007 03:10 PM

              Shake Shack is my favorite--it's sort of nearby. In the more immediate vicinity, Stand and BLT Burger will do.

              1. h
                hugglyj Oct 6, 2007 03:03 PM

                i would second just going up to shake shack but i wouldn't get a double shackburger - do the shack stack which is disgustingly gooey and delicious. it's a single beef patty and then their portobello cap stuffed with cheese breaded and fried instead of a second beef patty.

                deliciously cheesy...mmm...yummers.

                1 Reply
                1. re: hugglyj
                  CalJack Oct 6, 2007 04:02 PM

                  The shack stack is indeed a goolicious mess, but for accuracy's sake I'll point out that it actually does include 2 cheeseburger patties with the cheese-stuffed portabello cap sqished between. It's way more than the bun could ever hope to handle, but the decadence factor is pretty alarming to behold.

                2. r
                  roze Oct 6, 2007 10:28 AM

                  Bar Six on 6th avenue and 13th street, Molly's whiich is up a little on 3rd and 21 st but awesome burgers and Old Town Bar on 18th street. There is also the burger joint Stand on 12th and University which is supposed to be really good but I haven't tried it yet.


                  1 Reply
                  1. re: roze
                    steve h. Oct 7, 2007 10:45 AM

                    i'll second molly's. sub onion rings for the fries.

                  2. Brian S Oct 6, 2007 10:27 AM

                    Goodburger, on Broadway just north of Union Square, should change their name to Excellentburger


                    1 Reply
                    1. re: Brian S
                      CalJack Oct 6, 2007 01:05 PM

                      Brian, I find your opinions and reviews to be among the most detailed, insightful, and accurate I've read on chowhound, but I have to disagree with your Goodburger recommendation. The patty they prepare is average in flavor, marginal in size, and lacks any memorable char or otherwise crispy exterior. The supporting cast (lettuce, tomato, bun) offer decent contrasting textures, but little else. And the price becomes silly the minute you try to put cheese or - god forbid - bacon on your burger ($7 for cheeseburger and $9 for bacon + cheese with tax). Fries (not included) fall into the McDonald's family (thin and frozen), but I understand why some people enjoy them.

                      While nowhere else is quite so convenient to Union Square (with the exception of Stand, which I'd classify as a small step up from Goodburger), I'd urge you to take your taste buds and your money up to Shake Shack (double shackburger ordered rare or medium will give you a significantly better return on your investment), Molly's (GIANT chargrilled patties on 3rd Ave @ 22nd), or Blue Smoke (11.50 for a thick patty with a salty kick and excellent accompaniments - especially the fries).
                      Veselka on 2nd Ave @ 7th St and Royale over on Avenue C will both give you excellent bang for your buck and are likewise worth the walk.

                      Good Luck, and please just promise you won't go to Corner Bistro.

                    Show Hidden Posts