What's the best Middle Eastern food in the city? Is there anything that would blow one's mind? If not, really good would do.
My mind was recently blown at Gazala Place on 9th Avenue between 48/49 (I think). The chef said her cuisine is Israeli-Druze. She makes her own pita in the front. The place is small and the food is cheap. Try the cheese/cake/vanilla/pistachio pudding.
Do you mean the City (5 boroughs) or just Manhattan? If you mean 5 boroughs, ask on the Outer Boroughs board and you will get suggestions on Atlantic Avenue and Bay Ridge, Brooklyn.