Thanksk for the recs - I've printed info on both places to bring w/me, menus etc. We now have a couple to choose from in different areas, so we can play it by ear based on where we are when we get hungry.
I was just at Carmen Anthony's fish house in Woodbury yesterday for lunch and it was excellent. Had the seafood chowder and lobster roll. Both were excellent. The service was great and it is a very nice place. It is just a couple of miles north of I-84 on Route 6. Jay