I went once and liked it very much - nice fresh seafood, and I felt like the food was prepared with care. This was in May. But then I moved to Raleigh - so it's hard to say, maybe they are inconsistent.
Went last week for a work event. On the expensive side and rather uninspired [Think of hotel food without the hotel]. Not worth a return trip with so many other good places in Durham and Chapel Hill.
I've only been once, and it was almost a year ago, but it was fairly bad, and nothing I've seen on this board has made me want to revisit the place. I'd look elsewhere unless you find an updated and different opinion.