HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

RESTAURANT ADVICE FOR A FIRST NY TIMER.

  • 18
  • Share

I NEED A RESTAURANT ADVICE FOR A NY FIRST TIMER.

I WOULD LIKE TO TRY ORIGINAL NY FOOD AND A MOST IF YOU TRAVEL TO NY.

THANK YOU EVERYONE.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. Can you give more information about your preferences and budget? Are you willing to travel to any neighborhood? Right off the bat, I would recommend Katz for pastrami and Joe's for a slice of pizza. There are also numerous postings on bagels/pizza and other NY "local" specialties.

    Enjoy your trip and I'm sure you'll get more help if you provide more info.

    JeremyEG

    4 Replies
    1. re: JeremyEG

      I am looking for traditional NY food, If i could get there by subway i will be there...
      This are may choices: GOOD FALAFEL, BEST PIZZA, BEST HOT DOG, GOOD DELI, HOT WINGS, GOOD LUNCH SPECIAL I CHINA TOWN...I WILLL BE in Ny for a week...

      1. re: josephml1

        Best Pizza- Difara's (brooklyn), Patsy's (uptown).
        Good Deli- Katz's (LES)
        Chinatown- NY Noodletown, Grand Sezchuan, Hung Fat
        Best Jewish Appetizers (Lox, smoked fishes, roes)- RUSS AND DAUGHTERS (LES)

        enjoy fb

        1. re: josephml1

          FABULOUS falafel at Ali Baba on McDougal between West 3rd and Bleeker. Much better than the very over-rated Mamouns.

        2. re: JeremyEG

          Joe's wasn't worth the trip. Make a chow trek there. Flavorless slice. Crust was perfectly crispy, but without flavor, what's the point? It is the "Famous Ray's" of the aughtie-aughts.

        3. What about a good and cheap Gyro?

          2 Replies
          1. re: josephml1

            Karavas in the Village. Two locations:

            West 4th, west of 6th Avenue
            Christopher Street, west of 7th Avenue

            1. re: josephml1

              Bereket LES (right by Katz's).

            2. Peter Lugar in Brooklyn for steak you will never forget. Both places are worth the wait. The Carnegie in Manhattan for Jewish deli like you will not get or see anywhere. Get a delicious Pastrami sandwich (The size of 2 hands!) that will melt your heart like good news. Eat the garlic pickles they give you not the bright green ones and use mustard on your sandwich which will come on rye. Get a hot dog and papaya drink at Grey's Papaya in Manhattan and read the signs on the walls about Columbus and the benefits of the Papaya. Go to Mot street in China town and feel your choice. There it is..advice from a native New Yorker of 5 generations who now lives in Boston

              5 Replies
              1. re: geese

                Forget Carnegie. *The* one and only place in Manhattan for superb pastrami is Katz's!

                1. re: RGR

                  Amen to that, RGR!
                  I HIGHLY recommend the pastrami Reuben. Wow!

                  1. re: LeahBaila

                    I take my pastrami at Katz's straight. When it comes to Reubens, I prefer mine with corned beef, which, I believe, is the classic style.

                    1. re: RGR

                      It is the classic style (with corned beef), but man oh man, subbing pastrami for corned beef makes a killer sandwich.

                      1. re: LeahBaila

                        I'm with Leah. A tradition reuben is made with corned beef, but I much prefer it with pastrami.

              2. One interesting spot is Congee Village in China Town. This is a huge restaurant that has several authentic offerings but more interesting is that it has private karaoke rooms on the lower floors. These are quite an experience to simply walk by.
                For pizza, I am a sucker for John's of Bleecker but I love a really cheesy pizza, which this certainly provides.
                I get tired of people arguing over "best hot dog." To me, the good ones all taste the same and the bad ones are just bad. How about great sausage? One good spot is Lederhosen on Grove St. in the West Village. All sorts of wurst and beer served by the liter make this little spot a fairly authentic German dig.

                Enjoy your time here. You will be dazzled even if you happen to miss all of our suggestions.

                1. Thank you for your Opinions: about a good steak, falafel, good jewish deli is going to be very useful.

                  PLEASE KEEP IT COMING.

                  1. *I agree with all of the above posts, and here's my two cents:
                    - Best Burger: Joe Allen on W. 46th Street (but make sure you go after 8pm to avoid pre-theater crowds). Also great after 6pm on a Sunday evening - big show biz hang out. And as I said, ther burger are my favorite and always available.
                    Enjoy your visit!

                    1. THANK YOU FOR ALL THE RESTAURANTS...I AM HUNGRY..