HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Tell us about it

Shallots vs Onions

MSK Sep 11, 2007 08:53 PM

When cooking on the fly or developing your own recipe, when would one be better than the other?

  1. meatn3 Sep 11, 2007 10:13 PM

    There are several things I take into consideration. Texture: if it is cooked & you want crunch use onion. Shallot,especially if it is finely minced can almost disappear, so its a good choice for a smooth sauce. Time of cooking: If you want the flavor to stand out during a short cook use onion, shallot will mellow faster and blend with the other flavors quickly. Raw: shallot can have a very sharp bite, onion usually not quite as sharp raw. Price: onion usually less expensive. A lot is just your personal preference, so enjoy experimenting!

    4 Replies
    1. re: meatn3
      jamesm Sep 12, 2007 07:43 AM

      It all depends but I generally think of shallots as being for sauces dressings, etc...while onions are part of the actual dish itself.

      1. re: jamesm
        Becca Porter Dec 2, 2009 05:29 AM

        I agree, I think with shallots: sauces, salad dressings, chicken piccata, roasted vegetables.

      2. re: meatn3
        hae young Dec 2, 2009 04:33 AM

        when you said "the shallot will mellow faster" , did you mean the shallot will caramelize much faster than onion with butter and oil in the pan? after i seared my steak on the pan, i found troble to caramelize my onion quickly in the same saute pan with browned butter and oil. so i have to ask you if i saute shallots after searing steaks with browned butter and oil instead of onions , can i caramelize the shallots more qucikly by sauteing it 2 or 3 mins?

        1. re: hae young
          greygarious Dec 2, 2009 05:44 AM

          I do not know if, cut to the same size, there is any difference in saute speed between shallot and onion. Most recipes calling for shallots in sauce specify very finely mincing them. My suspicion is that one reason shallots are usually called for in sauces is that only a small amount is used and a shallot is the right size, as opposed to using just a quarter or less of an onion. Shallot is described as having a flavor between garlic and onion so the recipe can omit garlic.

          To speed the cooking time of onions, keep some chopped/minced onion frozen in a zipper bag. Break off what you need and put it directly into the hot pan. Because freezing breaks the cell walls, it will cook faster, even from frozen, than freshly-cut onion. Hard to believe, but it works!

      3. o
        ozhead Sep 12, 2007 09:04 AM

        Shallots vs. onions? I'll take shallots and the points.

        1. fayehess Sep 12, 2007 09:17 AM

          I think it all has to do with flavor. Each onion has it's own, even within the same varieties--if you buy a big old red onion that has been hanging around for a year in the bottom bin of a deli, that's one thing, and all together different than if you buy a tiny red onion still tight and bursting with life, from the farmer. I always suggest when you are trying to get to know an ingredient, have it alongside three or four other varietes, and for onions just saute each with a little olive oil and kosher salt. Taste them all. If you want to go a step further, do one set over a medium to hot flame for about five minutes, and then same variety, but longer cooking time--twenty minutes over a low to medium flame, and then of course, raw. (of course you could braise them all together as well with aromatics and stock to see what they taste like when they are in the same pot, but they we're talking about a whole day commitment) fayefood.com

          1. ChristinaMason Dec 2, 2009 06:19 AM

            I think shallots have a little more of a garlicky bite to them, so I usually use them when garlic would not be inappropriate. Onions cook up a little bit sweeter, I think. I like to use both together.

            1 Reply
            1. re: ChristinaMason
              coll Dec 2, 2009 06:26 AM

              I've been subbing shallots for both/either onions and garlic, I notice when I do my husband seems to enjoy the dish more. They are now a staple in my fridge.

            Show Hidden Posts