HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >


What's the best grilled cheese?

We can count panini, but its best if you order an item called 'grilled cheese'.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Eisenberg's Sandwich Shop or Burger Heaven...both serve up the "classic" with white bread and American cheese.

    1. im a fan of the 3 cheese with truffle oil panini at 'ino...though i usually get it as part of my quattro panini...very rich.

      also, the grilled cheese at chat and chew rules...is that place still in business?

      1. The grilled cheese at 'wichcraft. Gruyere and carmelized onions on rye (i think).

        3 Replies
          1. re: vvvindaloo

            Third this! Though it is really not the classic combination.

          2. re: ESNY

            I like that one too. Also the grilled cheddar with smoked country ham is really great. It comes with pear or quince, depending what's in season.

            One I want to make is Suzanne Goin's grilled cantal with caramelized onion and thyme. She serves that at Lucques in L.A.


          3. i agree, burger heaven does a good job.

            so does jackson hole.

            googies used to, but its no longer in business.....

            1. Hands down the grilled cheese at Green Table in Chelsea Market. Sharp, melty cheddar cheese + fragrant, fresh, thick-sliced multi grain bread + fresh, sweet butter, served with microgreens.

              1. Chat N Chew on 16th between 5th ave and Union Sq West. Comes with cheddar, american and swiss and you can add on ham or bacon and tomato. The bread is perfectly grilled everytime (I go there fairly often) and comes with some great fries.

                Best I've ever had.

                1. Gotta go with Bar 89. American, Cheddar, Colby and Swiss. Bacon and tomato (or anything else you want) Served with Waffle Fries, fresh veggies and fruit.

                  1. I agree with ESNY - the grilled cheese sandwiches at 'wichcraft are delicious. There are two, neither of which may qualify as standard grilled cheese, but their main ingredient is cheese, and both are soooooooo good:

                    grilled fontina with black trumpet mushrooms & white truffle fondue on pullman white bread


                    grilled gruyère and caramelized onions on rye bread

                    I miss all the good food in NYC!

                    1. "Say Cheese" is a small casual restaurant in Hell's Kitchen that specializes in grilled cheese.

                      649 9th Ave, New York 10036
                      Btwn 45th & 46th St

                      I especially like the "Florentine," which includes sauteed spinach and mushrooms with Jack cheese on olive bread from Amy's Bread. They also have the best tomato-cheddar soup in town.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: Nina_P

                        That's the place...I go for the BT, comes with bacon and tomoto on olive bread.

                      2. Big Daddy's Diner on Park Ave South has a great grilled cheese with cheddar and jalapeno jack on marble rye. And you can get tater tots with it!

                        1. The Original New York Milkshake Company on St. Marks has a really good, no frills, grilled cheese just like mom made them. I used to eat them almost everyday on the way to work.

                          2 Replies
                          1. re: Foie

                            You are so right Foie! In fact that was the first place that came to mind when I saw this thread. too bad it is closed! We need a place like that in EV.

                            1. re: Foie

                              Yeah my daughter (and I) are still mourning the demise of NY Milkshake Co. Their shakes and free pretzels were nice too. (BAMN is in the space now and though I like the automat concept the food sucks) . I agree that Say Cheese mentioned above is good and after taking her there I'm happy to report my daughter forsook Kraft American cheese forever in favor of gruyere on her grilled cheese. The fontina and black trumpet mushroom with truffle oil at 'Wichcraft is a great adult grilled cheese and is Mrs. GG's favorite (besides the gorgonzola, bacon and frisee which is their best sandwich).