Resturant needed for Anniversary Dinner.

[LMM1339]

I am in need of a great recommendation for an Anniversary Dinner. We are both under 25 so are looking to have a great time with each other but not spend a lot. We are not looking to spend more then $50 pp. Sushi, Italian, or American food. He is somewhat of a picky eater. The place can be indoors or out, pref more on the romantic side. Please give me some great places for us to enjoy a great dinner together anywhere in Manhattan.

[lfjacob]

I know they both get mixed reviews, but I had good experiences at Il Buco and Barbone. Particularly Il Buco if you request to be seated in the back room which is so quiet and romantic and gives you a nice view into the kitchen. I took my boyfriend there for his 25th birthday (he's a fairly tough critic of restaurants) and he absolutely LOVED it.

[erin07nyc]

Malatesta and Piadina in the village area are delicious, affordable Italian. Not sure if they take reservations, though... pretty sure Piadina does only for groups 4+. Malatesta is great in the summer with all the open windows. Piadina is more dark and cozy. From what I've tried, both have excellent salads, pasta and desserts.

[JungMann]

Teodora or August would be great choices for Italian. Whym, Red Cat or the Harrison might be a little more adventurous. Personally, my favorite romantic restaurant is Alta. When it's not too loud, I think the dining room is smouldering.

[LeahBaila]

While it isn't one of the cuisine choices above, Pylos (Greek) is very romantic and has wonderful food.
Also: August, Lavagna, The Orchard, Apizz

[LMM1339]

He isn't really a fan of Greek but I love the look of that resturant, it's perfect!. Know of any others. I will def. be trying that place but with girlfriends. Thanks!

[sheronda295]

One of my Italian favorites is Trattorio Dopo Teatro: http://www.dopoteatro.com/home.html