HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >


help improve my tourtiere!

After a trip to Quebec, I came home and made tourtiere - but it turned out dry and crumbly. The filling didn't hold together. What's going wrong?

I simmered ground pork with various spices for about an hour. The recipe didn't call for any fat or binder. I added an egg white anyhow before pouring the filling into a pie crust, hoping the filling would hold together better. I baked the pie shell filled with meat at 350 for about 40 minutes.

Everything tasted good, but the tourtiere fell apart like any ground meat would.

Help me make my next one stick together better!
Anybody have experience making great French-Canadian tourtieres?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Did you add any mashed potato, potato flakes or dry bread crumbs to the meat mixture? Did you drain the meat, or cook it until the liquid was all gone? Did you use a lean meat?

    I've made tourtiere every year for new years for about 30 years. I've never had it fall apart the way you describe. The meat is cooked, starting with enough water to see it, through the meat in the pot. Do not drain it all off, nor cook it until the liquid is all gone. I don't recall ever cooking the meat any longer than about 20 minutes, unless it was a stew meat. (In Texas a couple of years ago, I couldn't find ground pork, so I used what seemed to be a stew pork. It worked fine.) By choice, I have always used ground meat. For me, that's part of what binds the meat pie together, WITH some breadcrumbs or potato. Some years ago, I saw the prep of tourtiere on some program, that described adding dry breadcrumbs, a tablespoon at a time, to the cooked meat, and let it sit a few minutes, between additions, until it has absorbed all the liquid. It tends to take a couple of minutes to soak up more of the lovely juices. (Who? Me? Patient? I tend to start with 1/4 cup and then a tablespoon at a time, but that's from experience. It probably would not have worked if I'd done that the first time.) If the meat is too lean, you may have some problems getting it to bind, but I've not come across that, myself. (I remember that as a comment in the program. I wonder if it was Jeanne Benoit...)

    I came across a tip somewhere. (I'm a fiend for tweeking recipes) A little summer savory in the crust adds just a little added dimension to the dish. I've tried it and it's a nice thing to do, for any meat pie that uses a pastry crust.

    Good Luck with your next attempt!


    7 Replies
    1. re: violabratsche

      Hmm - breadcrumbs! Good idea, and strange that it wasn't in any of the recipes I saw. I used 1/4 cup water for 1 pound (450g) of ground pork. I DID drain off the water and fat. Probably a bad idea - but I didn't want the pie to be "swimming". Next time I'll try not draining it, and adding a bit of breadcrumb.

      BTW, I also got the idea of adding savory to the crust! Yum!

      1. re: bellywizard

        bw - I don't know if you've seen the recipe I posted, it's here:
        It does call for some bread crumbs. Also, I find the allspice is very nice (I grind it fresh). Adding stock, not water, will give it more flavor too. (I've gotten excellent reviews for this recipe from my Quebecois friends!)

        1. re: morebubbles

          Oh, I love that recipe that you posted, morebubbles! I don't care for celery, but I like the flavour of celery leaves or celery powder/salt in the meat mixture. I have a LOT more breadcrumbs available than 2 tablespoons, but don't always use it, and what a GOOD idea to make the flavour richer, by using stock. I'd forgotten about that. It seems to me that I use more liquid than that, but I do tend to do it all by touch, now.

          If you can find a homemade fruit chili/fruit relish, there's nothing in the world like it to have with the tourtiere.


          1. re: violabratsche

            Hi AnniG! Agreed on your points - I do intend to make a fruit relish of some type-cranberry? fruit ketchup? rhubarb? don't know yet (or simply buy one at one of the markets here) for using with tourtiere. And I do use celery leaves as well as the stalks, I like the leaves for cooking. Homemade stock makes a lot of difference! I do use heaping tablespoons of the breadcrumbs, and I do not drain any liquid.

            1. re: morebubbles

              The New York Times ran a tourtiere recipe on 19 December 2001 (adapted from a cookbook by Julian Armstrong) that I like a lot, and it includes a quarter-cup of rolled oats. The oats disappear completely in the cooking but help to hold the whole thing together. Of course, many tourtiere recipes (and they are countless--approximately one per household) include potatoes, but I personally don't like that taste and texture. As for relish, some Quebeckers make a rhubarb ketchup, spicy and sweet, that I think makes a nice accompaniment.

      2. re: violabratsche

        Tourtière in many french canadian families is unique. Some vary the meats used, the spices, potatoes or flakes even the pie crusts. The one identifying ingredient that's never to be left out however is the clove spice without it you would not have tourtière. The recipe I use is my families and has been passed down for at least 6 generations. My family settled in Montreal in the 1600 and later moved to Upper Canada (Ottawa area). The recipe changed due to non availability of different meats. Here is my recipe:

        Equal portions of ground pork, beef, veal or 1 lb minced pork
        1 small onion, chopped
        1/2 tsp salt
        1/2 tsp savory
        1/2 tsp dry mustard
        1/4 tsp ground cloves
        1/2 cup water (or chicken broth)
        1/4 - 1/2 cup fine bread crumbs
        1. Place all the ingredients in a saucepan except the bread crumbs. Bring to a boil and cook 20 minutes, uncovered, over medium heat, stirring often to break up the meat. Remove from heat.
        2. Add a few spoonfuls bread crumbs, let stand 10 minutes. If the fat is sufficiently absorbed by the bread crumbs, do not add more. If not, continue in the same manner. Cool and pour into a pastry-lined pie pan. Cover with pastry. Bake in a 375F oven for 30 minutes. Serve hot.

        My family makes a green or red tomato relish to top it with but if you don't want to bother making some you can buy Habitant green or red chow chow, although not the same close enough. We have also been known to serve it with pickled beets (my mom used to can them).

        1. re: Suds46

          Suds, I recognize that recipe as exactly the original that I had, used, and still use as a base. I haven't used veal as it's been so expensive, however, I may check and see if I can find a package that's small enough and not too dear. Thanks for posting it, as I am pretty sure I lost the original along the way. (Long story, not worth the telling)


      3. The recipe i have used for years calls for 1 lb. groound pork, 1 med. onion chopped, S&P, savory, some ground cloves, 1 bay leaf, 1/4 C. boiling water. Cook all 20 mins skimming fat. remove from heat and pour filling into a prepared pie crust, preferably one made with lard. Top with another and bake 375 F. 30 minutes until browned. We like a bit of pork gravy with ours.

        I usually make it for Christmas Eve supper. A couple of years ago I prepared it early in the day and since it was pretty cold outside I put it on my screened porch on the table to await baking. My youngest dog was very insistent on going out side but from a different door (poods are pretty smart dogs). We did not figure out what was going on until my DH brought the pie in and looked very puzzled. He asked if the pie had looked as it now did when i put it out on the porch table. The Loulu had found a hole in the screen that needed mending and each time she went out she let herself into the porch and had been systematically eatiing the top crust off. I baked it anyway. It was still good.

        2 Replies
        1. re: Candy

          Candy, your recipe looks like a lot of the ones I've seen. Yours doesn't use any breadcrumbs or oats, or other binders. Have you ever had trouble with your filling falling apart & not sticking together? Do you have any other helpful tips? Does your filling have much liquid (water, fat) when you pour it into the crust, or is it pretty dry at that point?

          1. re: bellywizard

            It is always firm and slices well. I do let it stand a bit. Now I am very careful where i let it srand and keep an eye on it. Oh I'd say it is a bit moist going into the crust and it does pick up some fat from the lard in the crust

        2. Nothing improves tourtiere than ketchup. Not that nasty sweet stuff Heinz makes but good, sharp spicy homemade ketchup. I'd comment more directly but I think everyone else has the basics covered. Although, just for a comparison, here is Madame Benoit's recipe: http://www.recipesource.com/main-dish...

          1. I add mashed potatoes to my tourtiere....my DH is from Quebec and he doesn't object!! I'm not sure that it's an authentic part of tourtiere but will help bind the meat so give it a try!

            1. Ingredients roughly translated from Quebecois. Chapelure is breadcrumbs.

              500 G of chopped fresh pig taken in the buttock
              1 large onion thin slice
              125 ml of chapelure
              salt, pepper, a pinch of nutmeg

              Here's a great piece from CBC--the great Toutiere debate: http://archives.cbc.ca/IDCC-1-69-1371...

              Most telling comment from the French guy--his mother changed her recipe around 15 years ago because pork has become so lean. She adds veal!

              1. after reading this thread, guess what's for dinner in this California home tonight?
                what kind of chutney or fruit compote is usually used with this meal?
                would it be a typical cranberry sauce?

                9 Replies
                1. re: iL Divo

                  You might be horrified to hear this, but in my husband's French-Canadian family, the "compote" of choice for mom's tourtiere is ketchup. I go with the flow (hey, who am I to mess with tradition?), but I do mix some hot sauce into the ketchup to take the sweet edge down several notches.

                  1. re: TorontoJo

                    Oh TorontoJo...my husband won't like that compote of ketchup, HE'LL LOVE IT!!!
                    So say I make green beans, applesauce, fried clams and macaroni and cheese for dinner all on one plate right? He then goes to frig grabs the ketchup and
                    everything on the plate gets a squirt and then he sorta eats it all in one bite together on a fork, yea, applesauce too. Sick man I tell ya even puts ketchup in the mix for tuna sandwiches. Very
                    odd duck I will say but sooooo cute :)))
                    oh forgot, how do I pronounce this word?

                    1. re: iL Divo

                      Don't know if this has already been mentioned but I use a combination of ground veal and pork. I also grate raw potatoes rather than use mashed. I find it adds a nice texture. Ditto on the chicken stock.

                      Oh, and must have mango chutney!!!!

                      1. re: iL Divo

                        Close - tour-tee-ehr. The final "r" should be a French guttural, of course! :)

                        1. re: biondanonima

                          Oh I love it, thank you biondanonima.

                          So here's the breakdown of dinner tonight.
                          l made my Tourtiere almost as stated on a few recipes.
                          Didn't follow just one, read several and went from there.
                          I can't leave anything [recipe] already good alone and this was no exception.
                          I bought a large chicken breast, two boneless pork chops and a pound of 80/20 hamburger meat. In the meat grinder went the chix and I put the pork chops in the Cuisinart and crumbed that too. Then combined those 3 meats with the other half of onions and garlic I'd prepared. [I have the other half of the mixture of meat in the freezer now for my next [and there will be a next] Tourtiere so it's ready to go.
                          What I did differently was adding the 3rd meat meaning the chicken breast, and I also, don't know why but put in a teaspoon of black sesame seeds for a bite factor in there, did the mashed potatoes in there too plus 2 T of my own dried bread crumbs. All else was the same.
                          The crust was dellicious and the stuffing I made, the other mashed potatoes and the green beans finished the dinner with gravy over the pie, the tates and the stuffing. Delicious and so want to thank whoever started this thread or idea [bellywizard is that you?] and just know this is now going to be a staple in the household. Loved this meal, was so pleased to have seen it, thank you.

                        2. re: iL Divo

                          iL Divo, um, wow. And yeah, kinda ick. But that's why we love them. :)

                          1. re: TorontoJo

                            "um, wow. And yeah, kinda ick".................. < wut? :/

                            oh no really, it is so heartwarming and cozy feeling to eat it.
                            next time, I will make a warm compote of some fruity kind, but tonight, no time and no need, we had plenty as you can see, for dinner.

                            1. re: iL Divo

                              Aww, sorry. No offense intended. The dinner sounds wonderful! It's just that the thought of applesauce and ketchup is rather disturbing. :o)

                              How did your tourtiere turn out?

                              1. re: TorontoJo

                                oh didn't know what post you were referring to, no prob.... :)
                                if you read the post above it gives a breakdown of dinner and how I made it.
                                but here's the answer to your question.

                                "Delicious and so want to thank whoever started this thread or idea [bellywizard is that you?] and just know this is now going to be a staple in the household. Loved this meal, was so pleased to have seen it, thank you."

                    2. When in Rome, do as the Romans do.

                      www.canadianliving.com has several recipes for Tourtiere. The one I like is French Canadian Tourtiere. The other recipes have mushrooms (huh?) which I have never seen used, but probably tastes good too.

                      My favorite tweak is to make the meat filling, fill pre-made tart shells shells, (shameless cheating!) then pipe on mashed potatoes or mashed sweet potatoes over the top of the mini-pie. Brush with butter if you want a browned top. They are the ultimate Christmas appy and will give you some schmaltz to get through several holiday drinks!

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: applgrl

                        Thanks! for the canadianliving link. Lots of info there.
                        Will make the pear/tomato compote, as well.