Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >
Aug 8, 2007 12:00 PM

Best Banana Cream Pie?

I was reading the thread about Coconut Cream Pie, and thought, gee, I am not a fan of Coconut Cream Pie, but man, do I love Banana Cream Pie!

It has been years since I have had a really great piece of Banana Cream Pie in a restaurant, and I seem to remember it was at a place on or near Roncesvalles but that was more than a decade ago!

Usually if I get the craving, I make it from scratch, because I never see it on any menus.

Do any Chowhounds know of any places that serve a mean Banana Cream Pie?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Not one reply... I guess I am alone in my love for real Banana Cream Pie!

    1 Reply
    1. re: LovelyAsia

      It used to be the signature dessert at Senses. 'Course, that was five or six chefs ago...

    2. I, too, love banana cream pie. I'm not sure, but I thought that Queen of Tarts on Roncesvalles makes one. Too bad they're all the way at the other end of town from me...

      Recently, I purchased a banana coconut cream pie from It's the Icing on the Cake, on Queen East. It was definitely more banana than coconut and was quite good, though it didn't have whipped cream atop, requiring that I whip up a batch at home.

      I think banana cream pie is tougher to do than coconut, as its shelf life (bananas turn brown, alas) is shorter, which may account for the difficulty in finding one in shops.

      1. Is Barney's still open on Queen W, and serving awesome BBCP? They were famous for it.

        1. The best banana cream pie I've had was in a truck stop about half an hour west of sudbury on the TransCanada. I'm sorry it's not in Toronto ( I wish it was), but if you're ever driving out that way, make sure you stop in.

          1. Haven't been there but apparently Ruth's Chris Steak House on Richmond St. has banana cream pie on the menu.

            Your post reminded me of a recipe for banana RUM cream pie I came across a while ago that made me drool. Here it is -

            Ruth's Chris
            145 Richmond Street West, Toronto, ON M5H 2L2, CA

            3 Replies
            1. re: JamieK

              I know this is not home made but Loblaws now has a series of home made pies, the chocolate cream pie is a bit too rich the coconut is oh so wonderful and they have a banana cream pie which isnt too bad from Presidents Choice. Try one let me know what you think. Tour boi

              1. re: Tour boi

                Thanks to everyone for the great responses!

                I will definitely try a few of those suggestions - just not all at once!

                Chowhounds are the best!

                1. re: LovelyAsia

                  The Tulip on Queen St East - I remember having a banana cream pie there and it was goooood old school pie. also, rather large it got doggy bagged and enjoyed over two days!