Second, third and fourth on Saul. Downtown Atlantic is so basic. Jolie is pretty good on Atlantic. Check out Mai at 3rd and Atlantic for awesome Southeast Asian food. I thin Bartabac is over-rated personally. Good dim sum at Chance.
I'm also on Bergen and Bond. Another option to the Smith St. places is to walk up to Atlantic Ave and go to Downtown Atlantic. It's consistently good and make sure to get some cupcakes to take home. It's on Atlantic between Hoyt and Bond.
Is the italian restaurant -- CANNOT think of name! -- at Carroll and Hoyt (down carroll from hoyt, across the bridge on the left side going towards third) still good? Italian food, Oh i know it, MONTE's.