HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >

Grill 23 a Hit, Again.

CocoDan Aug 2, 2007 08:28 AM

I'm well aware that Grill 23 & Bar doesn't get much support on this forum, but I have to say I've never had a bad meal there. Jay Murray is a talented chef, and proves it time and again with ever changing specials and an interesting list of seafood items. From salads and appetizers to desert and coffee, all four of us left more than satisfied. The waitstaff is top notch, and made everyone feel special. Needless to say, their wine list is world class, and covers a broad range. Alex, the wine manager knows her stuff and makes you feel comfortable. We had: Halibut, Salmon, Tenderloin and Steak Au Poivre. Wine: Lail Vinyards, J. Daniel Cuvee. This is not just a steakhouse, it's a dining experience, albeit a very noisey one. Yikes! Oh, and bring money.
Enjoy,
CocoDan

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Sal Monella RE: CocoDan Aug 2, 2007 08:33 AM

    That's encouraging. We used to be BIG Grille 23 fans but the last few times (6-12 months ago) we went were such a disappointed that we decided to spend our "steak money" elsewhere. The food at that time was just horrible given our level of expectations over many years. The steaks shrunk, were poorly cooked, and inedible. Even the side dishes disappointed. At these price points, a customer should expect the best out of an established restaurant. Hopefully, they've bounced back but I'm not willing to pass on Oak Room in lieu of Grille 23 just yet. I'm curious to see what other CHer's have to say.

    3 Replies
    1. re: Sal Monella
      d
      donjay RE: Sal Monella Aug 2, 2007 09:04 AM

      Re: Grille 23: We were treated rudely (not ignored...rudely) by a upstairs bartender who told us "I'm leaving in 2 weeks so I don't give a sh*t about anything", 18-24 months ago. Just that is enought for my wife and I to go to the other 2000 steak places in town

      1. re: Sal Monella
        g
        gramercyfoodie RE: Sal Monella Aug 2, 2007 11:54 AM

        I'm with you - we went about a month ago...I thought the food was so inadequate. We had this crab cake mess with sauce that was more appropriate for chinese chicken (it tasted like sweet and sour sauce right out of the bottle). My steak that I ordered medium rare came out burnt and charred like a hockey puck. The dessert (I think chocolate cake) had freezer burn on it. I was really unimpressed. I would never, ever return.

        1. re: gramercyfoodie
          BillieJean RE: gramercyfoodie Sep 17, 2007 01:43 PM

          While I always enjoy Grille 23, I agree with gramercyfoodie on the "char" issue. I have to remind myself to say "No char", otherwise it does come out burnt and I particularly don't like that taste. I know others do. I just think it ruins a good and expensive piece of meat!

      2. b
        bachslunch RE: CocoDan Aug 2, 2007 11:14 AM

        I also thought it was excellent the one time I went, though it can get noisy and it's as expensive as the steakhouse chains (though to my mind better then these). Part of the reason it hasn't been mentioned much is that the Chowhound moderators wouldn't allow it because of some kind of infraction for quite a stretch -- haven't noticed that lately, though.

        Anyway, I liked everything when I went: excellent bread, spinach side, and the best steak I've ever had in Boston by far, a Kobe Cap.

        1. j
          jackal RE: CocoDan Aug 2, 2007 11:41 AM

          glad to hear someone's had a good experience there. the one and only time i've been, the food and service were both equally lousy. while cooked correctly, the porterhouse was boring...tasted like an $8 cut i'd pick up at Shaws. don't get me started on the paltry seafood tower (would you like a little fish with your ice, sir?).

          still the best prime grade cut i've ever had was at Aujourd'hui a few years back.

          1. g
            gingersnap RE: CocoDan Sep 16, 2007 05:38 PM

            just got back from grill 23. beyond disappointing. we have been a couple times of year for the last few years, always found it reliably good when we felt like a steakhouse. iceberg wedge salad was a wilted head in the hugest puddle of blue cheese dressing- totally drowning in it. truffled tater tots we adored in the past were like cafeteria tater tots without a drop of truffle. sent them back and traded for regular mashed potatoes, which were not so good either. broccoli gratin was just broccoli in a puddle of milk and butter. mushroom ragout was good, though very salty. aged 14 oz new york steak really good, but i dont know about for $44. porterhouse not so good. filet side was identical in taste and texture to swansons hungryman salisbury steak frozen dinner. pathetic. will definitely not be returning, way too many good places to go instead.
            although bartender said ortiz and a-rod were in there for dinner with wife/ gfriend and friends last night after game and they could barely find a table for them it was so packed. so maybe others are having better luck with food there?

            1. NiKoLe1625 RE: CocoDan Sep 17, 2007 02:56 PM

              It's really upsetting to hear that people have had such bad experiences at Grill 23 because everytime i've eaten there it has been excellent! I always find that the food is consistently good as well as the service. Maybe i'm just lucky, but I think that its a great restaurant!

              1. a
                Area Man RE: CocoDan Jul 1, 2009 09:37 AM

                My family and I had a very nice meal at Grill 23 on Monday this week.

                The good:
                -The Aged New York Strip was the hit of the table. Ordered medium rare, it had excellent texture and flavor (I wish I had been the one to order it).
                -The Porter House ordered rare was also excellent, and prepared as requested. The flavor, while very satisfying, was noticiably second-rate compared to the aged NY Strip, which left us all determined to age our steaks at home.
                -The Steak Frites was on the other side of the table; I didn't get a bite but reports were positive. I did have some fries and they were very good.
                -Mushrooms were firm and deeply savory. Another big hit with the table.
                -Caeser Salad was very good
                -Greens Salad was very nice
                -Bread pudding was delicious
                -Caramel Profiteroles were also a big hit

                The okay:
                -Asparagus- rather uninteresting, this didn't stand up next to anything else on the table.
                -Truffle Tots- there was some hype for these and we felt these tater tots with some truffle oil didn't live up to it. Perhaps unfair; we were expecting to be wowed. Maybe we're missing something.

                The staff was very friendly from drinks at the bar all the way to the final goodbyes. We were there for a quite a while; the atmosphere on the first floor was a bit noisy at 7:00, but was lovely at 9:30. I saw some other threads asking about dress code; most men were wearing jackets but many were not.

                1. j
                  jmf2188 RE: CocoDan Jul 2, 2009 10:19 AM

                  just thought i would add...Grill 23 is my favorite restaurant in boston!!!

                  Show Hidden Posts