Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
Jul 31, 2007 07:55 PM

Pizza in Dublin/Pleasanton

I'm still getting used to my new surroundings and need some pizza advice. I'm getting tired of NY Pizza, plus it's not that great. Amici's I like, but it's kind of expensive.

Anyone have thoughts on Garlex or De La Torre's. And is Papa Johns any good compared to the local stuff? I used to be a huge fan of Round Table but the quality has really dwindled over the past decade or so and I've become more fond of thin crust pizza.

My favorite places in SF were Paulines and Arinells and I had two enjoyable meals at pizzeria Delfina. I also love Pizza Antica in Layfayette. Do we have anything like these places in Pleasanton/Dublin?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Slim pickens in this area for really good pizza, but I'd recommend Gay 90's in Downtown Pleasanton for solid traditional style pizza. Tomatina's in Dublin has a nice, not too expensive, thin crust variety that is becoming one of my favorites. If you want to venture out to neighboring San Ramon, there's a branch of Zachary's for Chicago Style pizza. I'm not a big fan of deep dish, but those who like it seem to love Zachary's take on it.

    6 Replies
    1. re: toofacetious

      I've always found Zachary's over-rated, but probably because I am not a big fan of Deep dish pizza.

      I've been meaning to give Tomatina a try. Thanks.

      1. re: toofacetious

        We had tomatina las weekend and really liked. This will be our new go-to place for pizza, too bad they don't deliver. Thanks!

        1. re: toofacetious

          I love Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, and Zachary's version is one of the worst I've had.

          1. re: toofacetious

            I'm not a fan of Zachary's deep dish, but I think their regular pizza is a respectable pie. I'd be willing to put money on it being better than any of big chain places.

            1. re: SLRossi

              Zachary's thin-crust pizza is eccentric, somewhat similar to the Cheese Board's. I like it once in a while for a change, but anyone who's narrow-minded about crust probably won't.

              1. re: Robert Lauriston

                I've always avoided Zachary's because I am not fond of Deep dish pizza, but maybe I'll give the thin crust a try.

          2. my sister and borther in law like pyzano's in castro valley... i'm eh about it though.. they usually get the pesto pizza... i think they rant and rave about it that it's okay.... i think other people like it too.. i haven't really tried all of their pizza's though... if other people have gone here, they may want to comment. i'm sorry if i haven't been too helpful... i usually try to say the reasons behind my endorsements/non-endorsements.... <=)