Best key lime pie in Manhattan or Queens?

[cidonie]

Hi. My bf loves key lime pie. Where is the best one served in Manhattan or Queens? (In Queens, would greatly prefer Forest Hills, LIC or Woodside/Sunnyside areas).

Thanks so much - hope everyone will have a great work week.

[lchang]

I second the Billy's Bakery rec for key lime pie. It is delicious.

[Desidero]

The key lime pie at Billy's Bakery (9th & 22nd) is terrific.

If you are a fan of Steve's Key Lime Pie, you can find it at Good Fork on Van Brunt St. in Red Hook.

[NYCnowLA]

virgils has very good key lime pie

[lisette]

Not exactly a pie, but Ciao Bella (there is a location in Grand Central in the food court) sometimes has key lime gelatto with graham cracker crumbles in it. It is delicious!!

[ChowDiva]

The best is Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie. There's a shop in Red Hook, but I think the pies are sold in some grocery stores in Bklyn and the city (maybe even Queens). I'd check their website.

[Woodside Al]

I'd go to the website and find the places that sell it. Because the experience at the store in Red Hook is far too often marred by the owner's nasty disposition.

[sam1]

strangely enough, i really enjoyed my slice at houston's on 3rd ave a few weeks back during a business lunch.

otherwise, my standard is steve's key lime pies from red hook. they serve them at waterfront ale house in murray hill...but i prefer the one in brooklyn on atlantic ave better.