new american/diner in west 30s

[adjuncteater]

i'm trying to recall the name of a cute little new american place i went to in the west 30s maybe a year ago. not a huge space, dim lighting and candle votives if i'm recalling correctly, and hearty, simple food. i had some kind of rosemary potato pizza and my friend had a steak--perhaps there's a Mediterranean or Italian theme to the menu, but if so it's not overwhelming (i.e. i don't recall it as an "italian" restaurant). any help? it was between 34th and 40th i believe, about 9th or 10th ave.
thanks!!

[harrison]

probably Market Cafe - 9th ave around 37th st.

[egit]

Yeah, that's gotta be Market Cafe:

http://www.menupages.com/restaurantde...

They even have that pizza on their online menu.