HOME > Chowhound > Mid-Atlantic >


The old Toyko restaurant in Eatontown on Rte 35.

what happened to the old toyko on 35? it was a really good place, but the new place ( i think it is called Little Tokyo) stinks.... what's the deal and is there anywhere nearby that has good sushi?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The sushi at Osaka at the Station on Main St in Bradley Beach (near the train station) is pretty good.

    1. I really like the sushi and sashimi at Kyoto Sushi in Atlantic Highlands - on Rt 36 next to CVS. Their cooked food is nothing special, but the sushi counter serves great quality fish and nicely prepared.

      Kyoto Sushi & Hibachi -- 2389 State Route 36, Atlantic Hghlnds - (732) 708-1088

      1. Sawa in Eatontown.

        Yumi in Sea Bright.

        1 Reply
        1. re: fershore

          Izu in Long Branch in the 7-11 strip mall (Montgomery Steet) has fabulous sushi! They are a small little [place only about 12 tables but everything is FRESH. Andrea Clurfield gaveit a great review back in Feb. We've been going for about 1 year. Def. my fav place, I would say better than Sawa.

        2. I believe it is called Sashimi 2 now. I had lunch last week and it was good. I ordeded the sashimi lunch (no crustaceans) and a salmon/yellow tail roll. My daughter had the shrimp tempura and we both had miso soup. I liked it alot. The staff and sushi preparers are very friendly and ask how lunch was, and tell you they hope to see you soon.

          4 Replies
          1. re: Barbarella

            No its still Izu Sushi.. 31 Montgomery Avenue. I was there last week. They give out green"frequent flyer" business cards. I'm not familiar with where Sashimi 2 is but Izu is in the west end section of Long Branch by the Windmill. Are we talking about the same place?

            1. re: stack_c

              No, my place is by the Wendy's and Mc Donald's on Hwy 35 South in Eatontown.

              1. re: Barbarella

                The place by wendy's/mickey d's is the old Toyko - right????

          2. It's not horrible, but I now prefer Ichiban on Rt. 35 in Ocean. Sawa in Eatontown is also very good.

            6 Replies
            1. re: DJMarilyn

              Like DJMarilyn I used to frequent Ichiban. If I recall correctly the sushi was pretty good. Of late however we have been going to Takara, also on 35 in Ocean, for our weekly sushi fix. Not great but acceptable.

              1. re: DJMarilyn

                Ichiban is also my spot in this area. I also like Fune for the korean sides. :D

                1. re: joonjoon

                  Where is Fune located? My fiance is Korean so I'd like to take him there. :)

                  1. re: DJMarilyn

                    Hey Marilyn,

                    Fune is on West Park Ave. in Ocean. Here's the Google map: http://maps.google.com/maps?f=l&h...

                    If you like Sushi and are in red bank you should also check out Sono in Middletown. As far as quality of fish goes it doesn't seem to get much better than that in central NJ.

                    1. re: joonjoon

                      I'm eager to try Fune.

                      I think Sono is Middletown is good, but Kyoto in Atlantic Highlands is markedly better. (Kyoto for sushi/sashimi only. I wasn't impressed with the cooked food at Kyoto.)

                      1. re: joonjoon

                        joonjoon, thanks for the info and the head's up on Sono. We will try both as soon as possible! :)

                2. Fuji is my absolute favorite! Rt 35 in Shrewsbury in the Staples strip mall (There used to be a Treasure island there-it's across from the Acme/Marshall's shoping area and just south of the library). They have some of the best sushi I have ever had. Try the King Louis roll on the special sushi menu. Really great. They also have hibachi, but I have not tried it.

                  2 Replies
                  1. re: Densell

                    Our one and only time trying Fuji, we were not overly impressed. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't outstanding either. Not enough to encourage us to go back. I guess we could try again. :)

                    1. re: DJMarilyn

                      I had the same experience at Fuji - not bad, but no reason to go back. As far as the original post - Tokyo was one of the better sushi restaurants in the area but I really don't like what they've done with the place. I don't understand why someone would buy a well-established place like Tokyo and mess with it like that. For example they used to have my favorite yaki-udon in the area, but now it's not on the menu! Grr.

                  2. My guy and I went to Takara in Oakhurst this evening. The decor is very very nice, the food was quite good, however unfortunately the service was quite slow. Our server, Crystal, was very polite and explained they had a server walk out earlier so they were short-staffed. We saw she tried her best, so it was all good. I noticed the Tatami rooms and noted that we would have to try them sometime. Hopefully with some friends as 2 in a room might not be acceptable.

                    There were some birthdays going on, so they banged on a gong, and came out with a cupcake. The lights dimmed and disco lights came on with upbeat music playing over the speakers. I thought was so cool.

                    Four thumbs up for Takara from us. :)

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: DJMarilyn

                      dj...was this your 1st visit? I am asking because I heard it was sold.
                      Have you tried Sumo in Wall?

                      1. re: tuxedo

                        Yeah, that was our first time at Takara. I've driven past Sumo, but haven't been there. I'm actually really looking forward to the Shogun opening on Rt. 34 near Wall Circle Park.