HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Pongsri Chelsea Review with Photos

  • 5
  • Share

I was "in transit" last night and decided to stop by the Pongsri location on 23rd St. to get a bit to eat on the way home.

I haven't been to the other Pongsri locations -- there is one in Chinatown, etc. -- so, I can't compare, but the Chelsea location is an okay place to get pretty good Thai food if you are in the neighborhood. It's almost always a mixed-bag. Some things are amazingly good. Others are ... blah. Sometimes, a single dish can be both amazing and blah. This trip was typical.

(For the life of me, I can't understand the dearth of good Thai restaurants in the city. For eight or nine million people, you have two restaurants with a really great reputation? Seems pretty strange ... We're a long way from Thailand, though. Maybe there just aren't many Thai people here.)

Anyway ...

The 23rd St. location of Pongsri is a newer place that has just opened up in the last couple of years. The dining room is spotlessly-clean -- pristine, if you will -- and quite comfortable. Decor consists of some big vases full of flowers and wall-hangings. Main eating area is medium-sized and fits some fifteen tables. If you are accustomed to eating Asian food in locales with a bit more of a grungy character in Manhattan, Pongsri will come as a very pleasant surprise.

Usually when I go, I order an appetizer and a bowl of curry or a plate of noodles. One good appetizer is the peurk todd, which are deep fried slices of taro root served with a sweet/spicy sauce. They remind me of French fries. The fried spring rolls and fried tofu are also pretty good.

This time, I ordered the "fresh spring roll" instead. These were rice-wrapper rolls filled with Chinese sausage, sliced omelette, cucumbers and ... sadly ... "krab" -- imitation processed crab fish food. The rolls were smothered with one of those sweet, dark Chinese sauces. I can't really say that I would knowingly order anything that contains "compressed krab food" or whatever they are calling it these days and I wish I could say that the appetizer was good, but it wasn't. It wasn't ill-prepared. It wasn't anything. It just wasn't good.

For the main course, I ordered the ba-mee green curry, which epitomized both the delights and shortcomings of a meal at Pongsri. The curry "sauce" was fantastic -- everything it should be. Creamy with coconut milk, fragrant with kafir lime and fresh herbs, spicy with green chilis. The noodles were the perfect thing to wrap around the sliced beef and fresh vegetables floating in the sauce. The bowl "looked" beautiful.

The problem was ...

The vegetables were undercooked. The green beans, in particular, were undercooked to the level of being unpalatable. The rest of the vegetables -- carrots, peppers, etc. -- are fine cooked or raw, but green beans? No.

Anyway, I picked out the beans and really enjoyed the rest of the dish. And this is what eating at this location of Pongsri is like: Enjoying some things a lot and picking out the rest and ignoring it.

On previous occasions, I have really enjoyed their pad Thai, the green and red curries with rice and the pad key mao. But there is always something that keeps the meal from being really exceptional. This is a good neighborhood place -- fine if you live in the area or find yourself passing through. It's a bit of a pity that they aren't just "that much better."

 
 
 
  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. I work in the area and frequent this Pongsri location quite a bit. I'm not an unadventerous person but have found the best way to for me to enjoy a lunch there is to stick with favorites, like the curries, especially. It's a great lunch spot or somewhere to go for when you're in the neighborhood, but I wouldn't go out of the way for it.

    1. I used to be a regular at the 2nd Avenue & 18th location, and found the food to generally be good, but not outstanding. A lack of greasiness was the hallmark.

      Issues with servers/service let to a boycott.

      1. I've not been to this location. I've had about 15-20 very good meals at the 48th St. branch.

        1. Good Review. I live across the street and eat there all the time. I think the food is very tasty and fresh. The delivery is the best. I practically put the phone down and the food is at my door

          1. I eat at the Chinatown location the most and soemtimes go to the theater district location. The Chinatown location favorites include whole fish (chili), shrimp cakes, many curry dishes, the cold spicy shrimp salad dish (name escapes me at the moment), soups, etc. Both locations have proved consistent and food is v. good. Theater district restaurant has nicer decor/ambience.