HOME > Chowhound > San Francisco Bay Area >
What's your latest food project? Share your adventure
TELL US

Sonoma- El Dorado Kitchen, girl and fig, La Sallate, Shiso?

sparkplug Jun 7, 2007 06:51 PM

My boyfriend and I will be staying at the Inn at Sonoma for 2 nights and need help choosing 2 places for dinner. After extensive research on this site and others as well as reviewing the menus, I've narrowed it down to El Dorado Kitchen, girl and fig, La Sallate, and Shiso. I can't find much on Shiso but what I did find was positive. I would love to have any and all thoughts and experiences on these places.

  1. c
    Columba Mar 2, 2010 01:55 PM

    Shiso Restaurant is closed.

    Catering is still available.

    http://www.shisorestaurant.com/

    1. m
      mikester Mar 2, 2010 12:43 PM

      Just a quick report here (consider this an update, not a response to a 2.5 year old post):

      My wife and I stayed in Sonoma this past weekend, dining at The Girl and The Fig on Friday and La Salette on Sunday. Both were very good, we enjoyed ourselves at both. Loved the cocktails at Girl and Fig (my wife had their signature fig "martini" cocktail, I had the sazerac) as well as the interesting and well-priced wine list, and of course the dishes - I had the braised boar shoulder with polenta as the main, which was fantastic my wife loved her duck confit, and of course their cheese selection is wonderful.

      At La Salette, we both enjoyed the uniqueness of the portuguese-influenced menu, which included things like tiny, beautifully fresh white anchovy fillets, morcilla (blood sausage, finished in their wood-burning oven), bacalhau cakes etc. For those a little less adventurous, my wife loved her scallops - she said these were some of the best scallops she can remember having - these too were done in the wood-burning oven. The plates were beautifully composed, and the wine list has some interesting Portuguese options.

      Service was great at both places, with very attentive and knowledgeable (but not intrusive) wait staff. We would recommend both places !

      1. c oliver Dec 7, 2009 03:34 PM

        Does anyone have any updates on any of these places? We'll be in Sonoma for a week and almost all of these sound like solid possibilities. TIA.

        2 Replies
        1. re: c oliver
          PolarBear Dec 7, 2009 05:11 PM

          General's Daughter closed a year ago last August, can't recall the latest incarnation.

          1. re: PolarBear
            susancinsf Dec 7, 2009 06:15 PM

            The new incarnation is Estate; Italian. I am not a fan, based on one visit (wasn't a fan of General's Daughter either). It is a beautiful space, but the service was spotty and the food didn't impress (this was about a year ago or more, however, so more recent reports would be helpful).

            I do like La Sallette though it has also been a while since my last visit there.

            -----
            Estate
            400 W Spain St, Sonoma, CA 95476

        2. o
          Otts Feb 21, 2008 02:02 PM

          La Sallette is a very good choice. Two other places not mentioned that we like are Meritage and the General's Daughter. We have stopped going to El Dorado Kitchen after a terrible experience with a mishandled reservation.

          Also for something totally different and good are the taco trucks along Highway 12. These are in Boyes Hot Springs There are three of them out there with one serving lunch, too.

          1. w
            Wendy_san Feb 21, 2008 09:24 AM

            Another vote for both Shiso and El Dorado Kitchen, though I haven't been to either real recently. Have never been to girl and the fig -- always wanted to try. Have fun!

            1. p
              PINONVY Feb 19, 2008 06:24 PM

              Couple other places worth a try; Depot Hotel, Swiss Hotel, Della Santina, and Harvest Moon Cafe. All wonderful spots with great food. And I cannot understand the negative comments on LaSallette, we eat there often, and always enjoy it. But, then, we ARE portuguese...

              1. c
                Chilanga Jun 7, 2007 10:29 PM

                I really like Shiso, we've eaten there 5 or 6 times. Everything's been very fresh and well-prepared. Don't shy away from the cooked small plates, they're as good as the sushi and rolls. Service is very nice, if a little on the casual side. It's a very modern looking room, not at all wine-country in style. There are sake flights, cocktails and a short wine list. And if ginger creme brulee is on the dessert menu you must have it.

                I've been to El Dorado Kitchen once and also liked that a lot. Great cocktails, excellent food and a more urban atmosphere.

                1 Reply
                1. re: Chilanga
                  sparkplug Jun 15, 2007 07:52 AM

                  Thanks for all your input! I really don't think we'll go wrong with any of them, but El Dorado Kitchen seems more like our kind of place than girl and fig, so I think we will do that for one night. Now to just choose between Shiso and LaSallette! I'm leaning toward LaSallete because it seems so different than anything we would have here at home. We go for sushi at least once a week....

                2. Carrie 218 Jun 7, 2007 09:26 PM

                  I'll put my plug in for La Salette. Food that is served at El Dorado Kitchen and girl and the fig are so similar to likes of Boulevard and Range and are becoming commonplace. La Salette is truly different in its Portuguese inspirations and great food. Besides, the rolls that are served are truly exceptional. Watch what dishes are served straight from the wood-fired oven, specifically if they are a special of the evening, and order those! You won't be disappointed.

                  1. LikeFrogButOOOH Jun 7, 2007 09:17 PM

                    I've been to El Dorado Kitchen a few times, and it's quite good, though I don't know if I would choose it as a dinner destination for a two night visit. I haven't been to the others, as I'm so rarely in Sonoma, so I can't say for sure. El Dorado Kitchen is definitely a place to go for cocktails, though, for its dim lighting and hip interior design. A fun place to go with solid New American cuisine by a guy who used to work at the French Laundry. One thing to note is the ever-changing music. On our second visit, we learned that the speakers are connected to the chef's ipod and are on random, so you might like the music one night and not the other. That was the case months ago. Hope you enjoy your stay!

                    1. sgwood415 Jun 7, 2007 08:05 PM

                      Girl & the Fig is great. La Haye should be on your list too. Those are two of the best restaurants in Sonoma. G&F has a more casual atmosphere and is a little bigger with a great bar area if you just want to have a glass of wine and some apps.

                      1. kare_raisu Jun 7, 2007 08:01 PM

                        I havent tried any of these places yet - but I have been in all in a reconaissance of sorts of the Sonoma dining scene being a recent transplant.

                        LaSalette intrigues me the most followed by Shiso.

                        La Salette's menu includes a feijoada completa, caldo verde, and an awesome span-port charcuterie and cheese list - I am planning on going here soon.

                        There is one dish I am interested in at Shiso - the Tokyo style Pork curry which Is pretty rare up here to come across. I saw a flyer advertising a special to-go bento specifically for farmer market evenings.

                        I love the design of the El Dorado kitchen and I have only sat outside near the pool with a drink. Their 'Kitchenette' is opening this week I think.

                        I have heard nothing but good things about the girl and the fig - I really like the bar and the cheese nook.

                        I apoligize for lack of concrete information. I have however had a great meal at the Nepalese restaurant and nice pastries at the Basque bakery. Rworange reccomended me Sonoma market - and I am so glad she did - it is not to be missed.

                        Show Hidden Posts