Kingfish or Steelhead Brewing
I just wanted to follow up and say thanks for the responses. Back in June, we ended up going to both!
Beer, fries, wings, and quesadillas at Steelhead while shooting pool. Plenty fun, pretty good beers, and the bar food was just fine. Servers were very nice and responsive.
Then sit down dinner at Kingfish. Service was slow because they were packed on a Saturday night. Food was as expected - just ok. Most of us had the prime rib, which was surprisingly decent. Appetizers, cocktails, and desserts were like any chain restaurant.
Thanks to the posters.