Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Washington DC & Baltimore >
May 31, 2007 02:06 PM


I just learned about an amazing-sounding New Orleans sandwich called a "Mufaletta." Is there ANY chance I could find such a thing in old DC?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. While you may be able to find a jar of the olive salad made by either Central or Progress groceries in N.O., a home made version is likely the closest you'll get around here. It's one of those things that has a special roll, etc., that you can't get in other regions.

    Alternatively, I think Central Grocery ( the place I bought them from when there on biz) did FedEx their Muffelettas, in pre-Katrina days, so if you have not had the pleasure, it may be worth it for you to get the real thing. No web presence though, if you give them a call, they may be able to hook you up.

    Or, fly there and pick a few up to bring home! :)

    2 Replies
    1. re: MsDiPesto

      The Red & Black at 1212 H street NE serves Mufaletta.

      1. re: sharonc

        It's been a long time since I've had a good mufaletta, and I was in the area, so I stopped by Red & Black last night to try theirs--only to be told that they only food they had was gumbo and jambalaya (which was especially odd given that the special of the night was free red beans & rice w/ a 2 drink minimum, but apparently they had no red beans & rice, either). FWIW, I did try the gumbo, which was just OK--good for something to eat while listening to a band, but not something I'd go out of my way for.

    2. Acadiana has one on the menu, but it's deplorable (maybe the only bad thing there?).

      I've not seen others in this area.

      Thinly related, I was introduced to it first in Columbia, MO to what turns out to be a very faithful incarnation of the sandwich. More thinly related, Highlands NC, where my mom-in-law retired to, has a handful of places that all do decent interpretations of it.

      Really a shame that DC doesn't have one any of us have found - AND that Acadiana fails so miserably at their attempt - it really isn't even an interpretation, in my mind. If you try theirs first, you'll do yourself harm by guaranteeing you'll never order one anywhere.

      1. (Ducking) There's always the Orignal sandwich at Schlotzsky's!

        1. I just happened to see the word "Muffaletta" on the main board, I'm not a New Orleans stalker hijacking your thread.

          Anyway, as I'm sure you know, a large part of what makes a mufaletta special is the olive salad. Recipes vary but it basically consists of chopped up green olives, cauliflower, onions, carrots, celery, and spices all cured in oil. And the special bread is a substantial round roll of supposedly Scicilian origin, about the size of a volleyball to basketball in diameter. The meat and cheese can be anything Italian, salami, capicola, etc., then some provelone cheese. They are traditionally served cold, but some places serve them toasted which since I'm not in the New Orleans board I can safely say I prefer. You can find jarred olive salad at and other places, I'm sure. You can make olive salad yourself too of course, but I suggest buying some first to see what it's supposed to taste like before commencing experimentation.

          11 Replies
          1. re: uptownlibrarian

            The Italian Store on Lee Highway in Arlington has muffaletta on their menu. I haven't tried it there or in New Orleans though.

            1. re: cheesepowder

              Huh - somehow never noticed it there. I would guess that they would have at least a decent interpretation of it. Not that you can ever get to the front of the line to order anymore...

              1. re: Dennis S

                I can't get past the Capri. I wonder if the muffaletta has prosciutto? Or maybe I could get the olive stuff on the Capri...

                1. re: flavrmeistr

                  No proscuitto... Central Grocery's version is Genoa Salami, Mortadella and Ham... Also provolone and mozz cheese. I actually ran across a very good bread choice awhile back and reminded myself to remember where - of course I forget... but I am almost sure it was Wegmans.

                  1. re: flavrmeistr

                    According to their website, the Italian store's version has prosciutto.
                    "Round Sicillian bread, over stuffed with mortadella, provolone, smoked prosciutto & genoa salami, topped off with olive condite and our famous olive oil dressing!"

                    1. re: cheesepowder

                      Sounds like lunch to me! Maybe some hot sweet peppers to go with.

                  2. re: Dennis S

                    I was in the area today, so I stopped by to try the muff, and it appears that the reason that neither you nor I had ever noticed it on the menu is that it isn't there--they make it, but when I asked where it was on the menu, the guy I was talking to stopped, looked at the menu for a good five minutes, and then said, "Oh, there it is", and pointed at a reprint of a 1999 article from the Post about their muffaletta that was one the wall.

                    (Then he paused again, and realized that they were out of the olive spread, so I ended up getting a Capri instead. That makes me 0 for 2 on getting muffalettas from places that have been suggested in this thread...)

                    1. re: sweth

                      That is odd. The muffaletta is on every menu from the Italian Store I have ever seen. It is on the one I am looking at now from my cabinet. It is on their on-line menu:


                      I have never known them to run out of the olive condite, although I have experienced a shortage of the mufalletta circular roll. It is always best to order them early, and often.........

                      1. re: dcs

                        It's on their printed sandwich menu, left-side center. Like flavrmeistr, I haven't been able to get past the Capri. I've ordered enough of their sandwiches to try all the meats they use (on the sandwiches) and by far, the Capri is my favorite.
                        Altho, I've been curious to try the muffaletta. How much more filling is it over a large sandwich?
                        re: waiting in line. Rule of thumb for the place is call ahead if you're not going to be there by 11:15am (or wait for late lunch)

                  3. re: cheesepowder

                    I've had it. In fact, it is all I ever get there anymore. It is FANTASTIC!!!

                    As long as they don't run out of the right bread or anything. They say it is for 2 people, but it is sooo good that one person can snarf it down and regret how much they ate later. Just as it should be with a Mufaletta.

                    1. re: cheesepowder

                      I Think that the version there is actually quite good. I've also tried one at Louisiana Express in Bethesda and while I generally like their food (not their beignets or cafe au lait-unfortunately) their mufaletta was very blah.

                  4. This is the same problem with cuban sandwiches or Italian beef or doner kebabs: there's no Cuban/Italian/Turkish community in DC to support/create them. The key ingredient is the bread, difficult to duplicate.

                    Although it sounds like I have to check out the Italian Store's version.

                    3 Replies
                    1. re: monkeyrotica

                      The neighborhood around Mangialardo's was an Italian neighborhood. Thirty years ago when I started going there it was a grocery store, more than twice the size it is now. There were several Italian enclaves in DC. Around the Florida Avenue Market where Litteri's is. Until about fifteen years ago much of their deli staff still spoke Italian. Catania's Bakery on North Capital served the Italian community and that's where both Mang. and Litteri's get their bread. They're open for retail sales on Saturday mornings.
                      I have no idea why Mang. and Litteri's don't do Muffs. They'd probably do good ones but it's hard to beat what they turn out.

                      1. re: MakingSense

                        Here's an interview with Joe Maingialardo about starting the grocery and where the G Man sandwich got it's name. What a shame he doesn't make his own sausages anymore.


                      2. re: monkeyrotica

                        FWIW, Levante's in Bethesda seems to get the doner kebab bread right, but their meat and sauce leave a lot to be desired.