Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
May 31, 2007 08:05 AM

Anyone been to CRAFTBAR recently?

Thoughts? Experiences? Comparisons to the Bar Room at Modern?


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Not really in the same league--food doesn't aspire so high (it is much simpler), and some dishes are lackluster.

    6 Replies
    1. re: Lucia

      You mean... CRAFTBAR is simpler than Bar Room??

      1. re: Liquid Sky

        Yes--Bar Room has nothing to do with bar food.

        1. re: Lucia

          Thanks, Lucia. I got the feeling Bar Room was "small plates" (similar to tapas).

          1. re: Liquid Sky

            Yes, Bar Room has a small plates menu. The small plates all tend to be more complex than the food that I've had at Craftbar, which serves a traditional app, entree, dessert menu.

            1. re: Lucia


              Any standouts at Bar Room? Besides the tarte flambee...

              Also, is this one of those places you need to show up kind of early to get a decent seat?

              Many thanks.

              1. re: Liquid Sky

                I always make a reservation on Opentable, so I'm not sure. When I go (usually weekend nights), it's pretty packed. My only standout was a well-prepared pork belly the last time. Otherwise, food (except for pastas) tends to be solid, but not great. I also like the "crispy" chocolate cake.

    2. I have not been to Modern, but the last time I was at Craftbar the food was horrible. Way too much salt and the menu was very average.

      1 Reply
      1. re: smithreers

        Okay... thanks, smith. Too bad, because it is a nice-looking place.

      2. While my experiences at Craft and Craftsteak have been excellent (and both have got mixed reviews from other hounds), I personally prefer the Bar Room at Modern than the Craftbars. Both the food and service were better at the Bar Room. I particularly enjoyed the egg in a jar, the foie gras torchon, the steak tartare, the gnocchi with sweetbread, the walnut quail, and the donuts

        1 Reply
        1. re: kobetobiko

          Did somebody say "foie gras"? I'm so there!!

          Thanks, tobiko. I love quail too.

          Can someone explain this "egg in a jar" thing I keep hearing about?