HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >


Best Bagels - Middlesex/Monmouth County

What does everyone feel are the best bagels in Middlesex and Monmouth counties?
They really are tough to come by sometimes.

I really like Bagel Giant in East Brunswick- esp their energy bagels.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. So glad you did this--I'm looking for some better bagel places in Monmouth County!

    Right now I usually get mine from Wegman's actually, especially the flaxseed.

    2 Replies
    1. re: veganish

      The best I've found are from Terrace Bagel rte 9 North in Freehold right across the highway from TGIF.

      1. re: Eric in NJ

        I get my bagels from Terrace as well. I don't think the bagels are great (they are on the chewy side), but much better than anything else in the area. The cinnamon raisin bagels are particularly good there.

    2. I've been spoiled by great bagels from a place near my in-laws' in Long Island. The best bagels I've found in northern Monmouth are at a deli/bagel store in Ursula Plaza in Long Branch. I couldn't have been more surprised.

      1. I lIke Bagel World on Rt. 9 North in Manalapan.

        Veganish is right about Wegmans, they have pretty good bagels, too!

        1 Reply
        1. re: Angelina

          I prefer whole foods to the wegmans bagels though, little bigger although Wegmans other breads are incredible.

          I will always miss Merlin's Bagels that used to be in West Long Branch in the shoprite plaza.

        2. I live in Eatontown. In my area when I go for Bagels I usually head to Master Bagels (Eatontown/Shrewsbury) or Grandma's (Little Silver). Gotta love Grandma's Bagels.

          1. Bagel Oven or the Bagel Station both on Monmouth Street, Red Bank. Oven is east of Rt. 35 and the Station west.

            1. folks the BEST bagel in Mon cty is in Belford at Bagel Station Plus.
              If you have never experienced their double size, you are missing out!
              106 Leonardville Rd
              Belford, NJ 07718

              add: while you're in the area support the Belford Seafood Co op :)

              9 Replies
              1. re: HillJ

                I live in Atlantic Higfhlands and haven't tried Bagel Station in probably 6 years or more. I wasn't impressed back then they were kind of soft bready in texture then. I'll have to give them a shot again. The absolute best bagels I remember were from a shop at what now is the Menlo Park Mall. Years ago before it was closed in there was a shop that had all the baking equipment in front so you could see the bakers rolling, boiling and baking them. Mmmmm to go back in time.

                1. re: Eric in NJ

                  ..and Eli's Bagels in Aberdeen is another throw back; including bialys.

                  1. re: HillJ

                    Eli was my neighbor :-), ny sister was very good friends with one of his daughters. Nice guy, a little nutty tho. Great bagels and bialys!

                      1. re: HillJ

                        About the bagels or him being a bit nutty? :-)

                        1. re: sivyaleah

                          lol, a bit of both. Those bialys were just de-lish!

                  2. re: Eric in NJ

                    Do you know the name of the place in Menlo? Is it actually in the mall, my interest is piqued.

                    1. re: yankeefan

                      Sorry to say it isn't there anymore, this was back in the 60's when Menlo was just a group of stores. There used to be a supermarket on one end and a deli I believe called Tabachanic's (sp) then the bagel shop next to that. LOL now that I think of it there was a head shop over there too I believe called media one shop.

                      1. re: Eric in NJ

                        OMG--does this bring back memories. I worked in a record/audio shop in Menlo in those days called The Sound of Music. I used to get sandwiches from Tabachnicks, and I remember the head shop nearby, which sold a line of tie-dyed clothes, beads, and other cutting-edge examples of '60s couture.

                2. I love Bagel Masters on Broad Street (at the Corner of White Street) in Shrewsbury. They have a killer salt bagel with scallion cream cheese.

                  2 Replies
                  1. re: MartiniQueen

                    yummm...scallion cream cheese and salt!

                    1. re: MartiniQueen

                      We are new to Shrewsbury and we LOVE Bagelmasters...so good! We usually just get whatever type of bagel came out of the oven most recently...nothing like a fresh warm bagel. I love the guys who work there too! It's grand central!