Any suggestions? Want to pick some up for a Memorial Day BBQ.
Ended up going w/ Brewsters. The service was kind of eh, but the food more than made up for it! Thanks for all of your suggestions, we'll definitely be heading back there.
Buoy One in Riverhead...across from Snowflake has lobster bakes to go, for delivery or they will cook them right at your house. All three options seemed to be very reasonable in price.
When we are staying at the marina at Meschutt Beach, we get a takeout clambake with lobster from Brewster's in Hampton Bays. Food has always been good.
That's a great suggestion, because I usually stay in Hampton Bays. Do I need to place the order beforehand, or can I just run in?
I would suggest that you call it in ahead, or better yet place the order in person, because it gets very busy just around dinner time with people doing takeouts.~Fred19
Thanks - I'll let you know how it goes!
Hey Fred - do you have any other info on Brewsters? I can't find it online (phone number, etc). Is it definitely Hampton Bays, or is it one of the surrounding towns?
Brewsters Seafood Mkt252 E Montauk HwyHampton Bays NY 11946631-728-3474
Just west of the canal, across from CPI.
Another place that locals say is very good is :
Cor-J Seafood36 Lighthouse RdHampton Bays, NY 11946Phone : (631) 728-5186
I think Cor J is just a seafood market, maybe they have to go, but there is a restaurant behind them which used to be good seafood. I just read a review as there are new owners, but can't remember details or the name unfortunately.
The restaurant part was OK when it was Tully's, and fair when it was the Blue Lobster.
Most Recommended Discussions on General Tristate Archive
May 18, 2013
Best bagels in Tristate area?
UPDATED Jan 01, 2013
Bosnian restaurants or deli...
UPDATED Dec 14, 2012
Announcement: New Board Breakdown...
UPDATED Oct 01, 2012
Black Bear Meats
UPDATED Jul 26, 2012
Whole Belly (Ipswich) Fried...
UPDATED May 20, 2012
Cold Dishes for Hot Weather
See All 34 Recipes »
About/Contact CHOW |