Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
May 15, 2007 04:18 PM

My Favorite Baked Stuffed Lobster Recipe

After a spirited and enjoyable discussion regarding lobsters on the General board, I talked my husband (it wasn't hard) into picking up some lobsters for one of his favorite dishes - baked stuffed lobster. I've been using this recipe for about 10 years now and really feel it's the best one we've ever had. So I thought I'd share:

It's from my favorite lobster cookbook "Lobster at Home" by Jasper White. It's full of information, cooking tips, times, guidelines, and diagrams in the Lobster Primer section taking up the first 40 pages - everything you need to know. Highly recommend it to anyone looking for a good lobster cookbook. It has all the classic recipes from lobster stew to New England lobster rolls (including a recipe for making the classic split-top rolls) to Lobster Newburg, but also contributions from various chefs like Robuchon, Puck, Bayless, Kinkead, Boulud, etc. For you Bostonians - it even has the recipe for Lydia Shire's (Biba) fantastic lobster pizza. That, along with Gerald Clare's Lobster Pad Thai, are tops on my to-do list.

I've probably made half the recipes from the book, and they've all been winners. He's pretty specific in his recipes, so they've always come out perfect.

Here is the basic recipe at this link:
But with these variations and tips:

He says Ritz crackers are the best (and that's what I use) - or oyster crackers or New England common crackers, 3 ounces crumbled, instead of the cornbread. Bread crumbs won't stay crispy. Always mix the stuffing at the last minute so it doesn't get soggy, do it gently, and don't pack the stuffing tightly or it will affect the lobster cooking evenly. If using cooked lobster and/or crabmeat instead of raw scallops or shrimp for the stuffing, let onions and herbs cool before adding. We've used all the variations but most often (like last night) 4 oz of the Phillips lump crabmeat from Costco since we always have a can in the refrigerator. Another tip is to use 1-1/2 to 2-1/2 lobsters since smaller overcook and larger cook unevenly. Lots of butter, but I wouldn't cut down - it's one of the reasons it's so good, and the brushed butter on the tail and claws keeps them from getting dried out. Even without parsley or tarragon last night (I used some fresh chives), it was delicious as always. I served it with Green Goddess Salad from "Sunday Suppers (link below), and we cooked our 2-1/2 pounders exactly 30 minutes.

If you follow the exact baking times, they always come out perfectly cooked.

1-1/2 17 minutes
1-3/4 20 minutes
2 lbs 24 minutes
2-1/2 30 minutes

Green Goddess Salad:

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Oh God, that looks so good, can I eat your pictures????!!!!!!!!!

    1. Thank you for this post. I've been trying to think of a birthday dinner menu. One thing that makes me hesitate though it hard to cleave the lobsters in two while they're still alive? I've only made steamed lobster where you just throw them in--have never really cut through the shell, much less while they're alive, and I have poor knife skills. Do they flail about?

      3 Replies
      1. re: traceybell

        Oh wow, I totally forgot that important part. My husband does it. I'm actually too squeamish myself - I know that it has a decentralized nervous system and is instantly and quickly killed, but sometimes it twitches after and freaks me out. ; )

        Some say to put it in the freezer for 15 minutes so it goes to 'sleep' and doesn't move around as much. I just asked him and he says it's not hard at all - it's really just one movement - but you have to have a sharp, heavy knife

        This is how he does it:

        He then finishes splitting it in half, removes the 'stuff' in the head and thorax, and the vein/intestinal tract that runs down the tail. He uses a meat mallet to crack one side of each claw as the recipe says (helps it cook evenly).

        BTW, this recipe is closer to the book than the one on the Emeril site I linked above:

        1. re: Rubee

          Well, if you're a total weenie about it (like I was when I tried to make Lobster Thermidor once), I actually had the guy at the meat/seafood counter do it for me!! He took those babies and sawed 'em right down the middle.

          1. re: aurora50

            I think I'll give it a try since I'm going to get my lobsters from a wholesale place and they probably won't do it for me. The video clip helps quite a bit. Thanks!

      2. Rubee, I'd be curious if that book has Jasper's recipe for Lobster and Scallop Chowder? I have this tatered recipe of Jaspers' (Awesome awesome) from the Boston Globe - some time ago - but haven't found it any of his cookbooks. Recipe is to die for.

        3 Replies
        1. re: lexpatti

          That sounds fantastic!

          I just checked - there isn't, though there is a recipe for lobster and corn chowder like this:

          Now I want to make your lobster and scallop one - is it much different? I'd love to make it. He does have a book called "50 Chowders: One Pot Meals - Clam, Corn, & Beyond". I wonder if it's in there.

          1. re: Rubee

            Hmmm, I never saw this post back in May - sorry about that Rubee! I just checked my tatered recipe and yes, almost the same ingredients but instead of corn - (1/2 lb of cape scallops). Everthing else seems the same except my recipe calls for 2 c of chicken stock and 2 cups of water where yours is 4 cups of lobster stock (which I like better).

            I've made it a couple times, totally awesome adn better the following day as the flavors meld!!

            My sister did a recent one - Corn and Crab Bisque that was fantstic too but I could change up Jasper's easily.

            1. re: lexpatti

              Thanks so much Lexpatti! That looks delicious.

        2. Thanks, Rubee; we're gonnah do baked stuffed lobsters instead of turkey this THX...Hey, gottah support that lobster industry!
          The link to the recipe has changed; here's the new one...

          1 Reply
          1. re: galleygirl

            Hi GG!

            Thanks for the updated link. I hope you like the recipe as much as we do. I made it with scallops once too, though usually we make it with crabmeat. I'm kicking myself that we didn't swing by J. Hook's on the way to the airport last week.