I heard about a "cupcake war." Here are my results
- mynameisolivia May 4, 2007 12:10 PM
I just came back from my 7 day trip to NYC. I was on a mission. A cupcake a day. Thank god I didn't actually do this (though it was my bday week so I deserved it).
The BEST cake. Pricey, but enough for 2. Dean & Deluca's. My best friend introduced me to the yellow cake with white frosting. That cake. Oh my god. It was even better when I had the last bite in the afternoon. (Make sure that they are the cupcakes made by D&D- they also sell crumbs which i did not try and Little Red Hens which had really great cream cheese frosting, but the cake on the dry side; not as dry as Buttercup though).
Buttercup Cafe. Dry. Would not go back. Had the red velvet. Good Icing though.
Sugarsweet sunshine. AAAAHHH. The perfect little cupcake. $1.50. Reminded me of cupcake wednesdays in grade school.
Magnolia. I didn't make it this trip. Which I have for the last 4 years or so. They still have the best Banana Pudding.
Is it my imagination or have the cupcakes at Buttercup on Second Avenue (50-51) gotten both smaller and more expensive recently? I think that their icing/cake ratio was among the best, as was the icing itself, but the cupcakes I bought last week were very disappointing. Has anyone else noticed this? In addition, I can vouch for the ersatz Hostess cupcake at Crumbs. Otherwise, I don't care for their products. The icing is too thin, and I find that the flavors don't live up to what they are supposed to be like. But that Hostess imitation is the perfect combo of actually good product and Proustian memory.
I brought a box of cupcakes from Billy's on Ninth Ave. in Chelsea to a birthday party last fall. They were a big hit. I don't eat sweet stuff, so it just tasted like ... sugar to me. Other folks raved, however.