HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >

Discussion

Cookshop, Peasant or Place on W. 10th

  • 5

Group of six going on a Sat nite. Concerns are good food, enough room at tables, air conditioning and noise level. Which of these would be best or suggestion that meets criteria stated above. Thanks in advance.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. I was not a fan of Cookshop, and Peasant was annoying with the all-italian menu. Haven't been to Place on W. 10th, but that could be an option.

    1. Peasant

      1. Service at Cookshop in December was cheerful, but the food itself was clinically depressed. I don't like giving poor reviews, but this was the sad state indeed of my meal.

        1. The Place on 10th. Consistently good food, nice atmosphere, especially for a group. Not too quiet but also not obnoxiously loud. Not sure how busy they get on the weekends but if you call you can find out.

          1. I think Peasant has the best food of the three, but for a group, I'd go to The Place (either location).