HOME > Chowhound > Washington DC & Baltimore >

Discussion

Hot Dog in NOVA

It used to be that Joe's Dog House in old town Herndon is our regular summer spot. Good food, casual surrounding, and cheap. I recently found out that they have closed. Does anyone know of another similar type of place for Fairfax county or Loudoun county?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. Hot dog in NOVA leads me quickly to the Vienna Inn on Maple. As for good food, casual and cheap in Herndon, Jimmy's fits the bill (they have keilbasi).

    1 Reply
    1. re: Dennis S

      Oh, and while I've never had the dogs there, 5 Guys does them.

    2. I think the grilled all beef dogs at Hard Times Cafe are decent. There is a location in Herndon.

      http://www.hardtimes.com/locations/He...

      1. Weenie Beenie's in Arlington, but still cheap, good, and worth a drive, particularly for the halfsmokes.

        http://www.washingtoncitypaper.com/di...

        http://www.dcist.com/archives/2006/05...

        1. For an upscale treat, EatBar sells a homemade hot dog that literally was the size of my 8 year old's forearm for $10 including fries. It was pretty good, but at 10 semolians a pop, it will not be a regular item for most.

          3 Replies
          1. re: dcs

            But, the EatBar dog is a homemade dog complete with homemade castup- so very very good.

            1. re: jpschust

              I'm sorry, but one should never use ketchup on a hot dog, as the hot dog is mustard's domain. EatBar's mustard also appeared homemade and was quite tasty, although it could have used a tad more vinegar or salt. The homemade ketchup was excellent when used in combination with the french fries, where it belongs. ;-)

              1. re: dcs

                Oh I'll agree, but I'm just saying that's how it's served. I had the castup on a corndog, which is a different story.

          2. Del Merei Grille on Mt. Vernon Avenue in the Calvert Plaza serves a hot dog platter that has some connection to a famous hot dog in the VA area. You can check their website for more info. They serve two with accompanying items. I have seen many folks order this in their bar area and they all look really happy.

            2 Replies
            1. re: alexfoodie

              I think it's connected to the Vienna Inn hot dogs. But the Vienna Inn hot dogs aren't that great, but their cheap and it's good beer food for a tavern like the Vienna Inn.

              1. re: rcheng

                I'll second your post, rcheng, about the Vienna Inn. Their chili dogs are OK, but for all I had heard about them, I was expecting something great. They were just, well, OK.

                They are cheap, though.

            2. I had a 5 Guys hot dog for lunch today. Beef, split down the middle and grilled, good flavor and bite, decent roll. You can make it sloppy with cheese and/or chili but I just had it with mustard, relish, and onions.

              If only I had someone along to share the fries. They must give you a potato and a half in a "regular" order, and they were good enough to eat the whole thing. Everybody says 5 Guys quality and service varies among locations. This was on Gallows Road just South of Lee Highway in the same shopping center as the Great Wall market.

              5 Replies
              1. re: MikeR

                I wasn't as big a fan of the Five Guys hot dog. Here's a message I posted on my hot dog there:

                http://www.chowhound.com/topics/31411...

                1. re: rcheng

                  So what's a good hot dog in your experience? I never thought of descrbing a hot dog in terms of "bite" so I guess I'm not a hot dog gourmet. What I don't like is a mushy hot dog, and I've had a few of those in my life.

                  1. re: MikeR

                    To me, it comes down to whether the dog has a natural casing. Caseless wieners (most of what you find in the supermarkets) are almost universally mushy, particularly if boiled. You end up with a soggy cylinder of waterlogged bologna. You can get some "bite" out of them if you grill them carefully, but they'll never be as snappy as a natural casing dog. But you can also mess up a casing hotdog; witness the "dirty water dogs" they sell off the carts downtown.

                    1. re: monkeyrotica

                      That sounds like a pretty good description of what I don't like - that boiled bologna sensation. I suspect that there are good and bad ways to prepare a hot dog, and that comes into play as well. But I'm not inclined to pay $10 for a hand made hot dog when there are a few good $10 hamburgers to be had.

                      I think rcheng has a good thought - it's the environment as much as the sausage that makes them good, or at least helps forgive sins. It was a nice day the other day when I had a dog at 5 Guys and I was thinking all that was missing was a ball game, and I don't even like to watch baseball. <g>

                    2. re: MikeR

                      "So what's a good hot dog in your experience? "

                      That's a good question MikeR. I'm don't eat hot dogs that often, so I don't consider myself a big expert either, but I recall enjoying Nathan's brand hot dogs.

                      In my opinion, a big part of the hot dog is the experience and memories. Hot dogs seem to taste best when you're at a ballpark or tailgate with friends and family. Or at a backyard bbq or picnic. Or when camping with friend and family and roasting your own hot dogs on a stick in front of an open fire. It's times like these that make even the most mediocre of hot dogs great.