HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Are you making a specialty food? Get great advice
TELL US

Love Eggs, Avoiding Yolks

Jim Leff Apr 26, 2007 07:46 PM

Egg Beaters are a disgusting tasting product with questionable ingredients.

Separating my own whites from yolks is time consuming and wasteful.

I'd imagine commercial pasturized whites are pretty yucky (and less nutritious, too).

Is there a delicious but viable alternative out there?

  1. Servorg Jan 24, 2014 12:49 PM

    Just saw this on Youtube and figured it was worth posting here. One of the neatest little tricks ever: http://www.youtube.com/embed/iAp8pEaWB1Y

    1 Reply
    1. re: Servorg
      HillJ Jan 25, 2014 06:04 AM

      I'm equally impressed that you remembered this thread OR went looking for a similar topic found 2007 and posted the video here.

    2. chef chicklet May 15, 2007 03:00 PM

      Some really good information on this topic.Thanks for addressing this problem with eggs in a carton. I find them smelly and will toss them, they just don't smell fresh at all to me.

      I would rather make my own, sometimes with the BYGO opportunities, we save a little by just making our own. And frankly I think that pale yellow stuff is disgusting, I'd rather have Supreme Egg Foo Yung with shrimp, bean sprouts garlic, scallions and veggies and a little sauce on top any day.

      1. l
        laylag May 15, 2007 12:54 PM

        Jim, Egg Beaters are the worst tasting egg substitute on the market. If you're willing to try another rather than just the whites, give Better than Eggs a shot. I think they taste pretty decent for omelets and scrambled. Also, believe it or not, Costco's Kirkland label has an egg substitute that tastes, to me, like Better than Eggs and are about 1/4 of the cost.

        1. misohungrychewlow Apr 28, 2007 07:50 PM

          I have been enjoying the egg whites sold at Trader Joe's, with and without a whole egg added.

          4 Replies
          1. re: misohungrychewlow
            Ruth Lafler Apr 28, 2007 08:06 PM

            Yeah, I only use them as an ingredient on other things (I actually don't like eggs), but they're "100 percent egg whites, no added ingredients." The brand is Papetti Foods, and they're based in Elizabeth, NJ, so I would assume they're available on the NY area.

            1. re: misohungrychewlow
              Will Owen May 2, 2007 10:31 AM

              Trader Joe's here (California) also sells Nulaid, an egg product that's just whites with minimal other ingredients. On a friend's recommendation I bought a carton yesterday, and this morning scrambled about 1 1/2 eggs' worth with my usual S&P and dash of Tabasco, using spray grease plus a small glob of canola margarine in a regular skillet. I'd never mistake the result for whole egg, but it was remarkably good, though I think with only salt in an ungreased non-stick pan it would be pretty blah.

              1. re: Will Owen
                Jim Leff May 2, 2007 07:06 PM

                Yeah, i'm making them in ungreased non-stick. So blah it is...and I might as well keep it simple, so I'm just separating eggs and doing it that way. But thanks for the product recco, good to know about Nulaid (great name)

              2. re: misohungrychewlow
                fldhkybnva Jan 25, 2014 11:39 AM

                I go through probably 6 cartons of egg whites a week. They are in nearly every store now 100% egg whites and work great if you like egg whites. I often add whole eggs but often like to use them for quick scrambled eggs or frittatas.

              3. m
                MakingSense Apr 28, 2007 11:48 AM

                What are you going to use these egg whites for, Jim? That might help us to help you. Otherwise, we'll just keep flailing around.
                It might also help if you were to try one of the commercial varieties that some of the posters have suggested and been pleased with. In your original post, you said that you just assumed that they were "yucky" but maybe some of them might be acceptable. If they aren't acceptable as a class, then we can rule that out.
                I've used dehydrated egg white for royal frosting, and if that's all you need, they could be acceptable.
                How about some more information so we can help you out.

                8 Replies
                1. re: MakingSense
                  Jim Leff Apr 28, 2007 12:05 PM

                  Using for omelets and such, not baking. EggBeaters are absolutely yucky! Was hoping there might be a better-tasting (and better ingrediented) alternative out there.

                  My conclusion from this thread is to buy good organic eggs, separate my own whites, find someone to give the yolks too (e.g. neighbors' dogs), and consider one yolk in a three egg omelet.

                  I see the moderators are deleting the standard divisive (and off-topic) cholesterol flame bait. I was hoping to spark discussion re: my options rather than discussion of whether my decision makes medical sense.

                  1. re: Jim Leff
                    m
                    MakingSense Apr 28, 2007 12:55 PM

                    Agree totally on EggBeaters! Eggs are the perfect food if you were wise enough to select ancestors with the right genes on the cholesterol thing. Daddy never saw animal fat he didn't love and died with his cholesterol c.170. But if you didn't, you can't change that.
                    I think you have probably arrived at the best conclusion and will just have to practice until you get good at separating the eggs.

                    Wish you could team up with Adriennne or me (currently using her recipes for gelato and therefore swimming in egg whites.) Of course it won't be long before I'll be on to something else, the tide will turn and I'll have too many yolks. Can we ever be completely happy?

                    Now eat your oatmeal and we'll see if we can't come up with some other good ideas.

                    1. re: MakingSense
                      rworange Apr 28, 2007 06:47 PM

                      I don't know, trying at least one egg white product might be worthwhile if no one has any taste experiences. When I was eating egg whites, there were only the eggbeater type products available. Those are NOT pure eggs. They add oil and other stuff to them. That's why they taste awful.

                      The latest group like Organic Valley are just egg whites and nothing else, though pasturized. Organic Valley are my fallback regular eggs if I can't get to Berkeley Bowl or a farmer's market. They are not amazing eggs but they are good. I would imagine that the whites would be decent.

                      If Organic Valley doesn't sell in your area, then just check the ingrediant list. Make sure there's nothing but egg whites. I wouldn't get a frozen version of anything though. IMO, freezing changes the flavor of egg whites if you are putting them in something like an omelet where the egg whites are the main focus. There's also a a difference in texture and stuff.

                      1. re: rworange
                        MMRuth May 15, 2007 12:47 PM

                        I saw this Organic Valley product at Citarella in Manhattan on the UES over the weekend.

                    2. re: Jim Leff
                      Kitchen Queen Apr 28, 2007 08:15 PM

                      Jim,
                      You can purchase "Egg Whites Only" in a small carton and sold at Trader Joes. In the refrige section next to the egg alternative carton. It's smaller and blue and white, I think. Otherwise, crack open a few and freeze. Keep contained by cracking into ice cube trays! Defrost when needed. You're at 100% protein, nothing else. I make omelettes too. I saute finely chopped onion into a pan, then plop a tbls of pineapple salsa on top at the end.

                      1. re: Jim Leff
                        p
                        piccola Apr 29, 2007 08:12 AM

                        I find there's a huuuuge difference between brands of egg replacer, especially when it comes to texture. Some are rubbery or worse - pasty.

                        But I actually like Quick Eggs by Papetti Foods. They're tender but not mushy and the flavour's as close to real eggs as a substitute can be.

                        1. re: piccola
                          Jim Leff Apr 29, 2007 08:45 AM

                          Cool, thanks. That was what I was hoping for...a superior alternative to the gag-worthy obvious choice.

                          1. re: Jim Leff
                            p
                            piccola Apr 29, 2007 05:03 PM

                            Stay far, far away from Better Than Eggs. They aren't. They have the texture (and I imagine, the flavour) of decomposing newspapers.

                    3. heatherkay Apr 27, 2007 10:59 AM

                      I'm a little confused -- are you looking for an alternative to eggs altogether? Because if you don't want to buy commercial egg whites and you don't want to separate eggs, what are you left with?

                      2 Replies
                      1. re: heatherkay
                        Jim Leff Apr 28, 2007 09:50 AM

                        "if you don't want to buy commercial egg whites and you don't want to separate eggs, what are you left with?"

                        Appealing to the Chowhound community for other ideas! Thanks, everyone.

                        1. re: Jim Leff
                          Emme Apr 29, 2007 02:28 AM

                          Scramble tofu instead.

                      2. FoodFuser Apr 27, 2007 09:20 AM

                        Mark and MM and rw bring excellent points to the discussion.

                        I'd like to amplify those comments, and will base it on the assumption that a person is seeking to have a three-eggwhite-omelet as often and easily as they'd like, without waste and hassle. I enjoyed a period of egg-whites-only, and used the following system.

                        First, unless you want to pay ConAgra Foods to do the work for you and accept their inferior EggBeater product, you have to reconcile yourself to the fact that to make an eggwhite omelet, you have to break a few eggs, even if it is "time consuming and wasteful." The home cook has to "add the manufactured value" to those extremely efficient and tasty ovoid packages of perfect protein, delivered at an extremely low cost.

                        My system is based on minimal tools, minimal cleanup, and minimal hassle, with a good throughput for the "wasted" yolks.

                        Get an egg separator, a cheap but efficient tool, easily stored. You can of course use your undulating fingers to separate, or do the half-shell-shuffle back and forth to drip the desired white to the bowl below without puncturing the yolk. But, having the easily rinsed tool that gives repeatable results is my choice. Available here:
                        http://www.amazon.com/Fox-Run-Craftsmen-Egg-Separator/dp/B0000VLPTE
                        (rw's idea of a funnel seems like an interesting solution for "walk away while the funnel oes the work." Egg separator works for "get it done now."

                        Put two side-by-side jars on the work counter. (I'm a heavy user of one pint wide mouth Masons for all sorts of storage, from cabinet grains to refrigerated staples). Put the egg-separator tool over the jar to receive the egg whites. Crack egg, separate with a little rolling agitation of the plastic tool, then lift and flip the nestled yolk into the yolk jar.

                        Stopping at three eggs, for today's omelet only? Just use the separator to stir the whites and drop in the pan. Wanting to do a full run of one or two dozen eggs to freeze the whites (whites DO freeze well), then just take a ziploc-type thin gauge sandwich bag and put it into the clean white-receiving jar, with the top edge of bag peeled down over the sides of the jar, before placing the tool across the jar.

                        So you are now left with yolks. While they are a perfect package of nutrition for the developing organism, they are a real pain to dispose of. They coat the walls of pipes if sent down the sink; they find ways to sully your trash can; they are too concentrated to compost without problems. My solution: freeze the yolks, using the jar over and over until it is full, then give them to a neighbor who has 3 yapping Chihuahuas who wag their tails and identify me solely as the Egg Yolk Provider. Sadly, yolks do NOT freeze well to offer to human neighbors who use fresh yolks (they require salt or sugar stirred in, to raise solute concentration or they will become rubbery.) My sweet buddy Chihuahuas are however content with less discriminant texture thresholds. So, find a neighbor who is willing to accept your frozen yolks in return for dog-love. It is a great way to surmount the problem of "time consuming and wasteful"

                        If someone wants to freeze the yolks, try these links for info on freezing methods and which uses are suited for the frozen product:
                        http://www.georgiaeggs.org/pages/freezingeggs.html
                        http://www.eggs.ca/eggfacts/eggfreeze...

                        1. m
                          mark Apr 27, 2007 05:05 AM

                          short answer, no. my wife is a baker, and has tried most of the alternatives. while some perform fine in baking, none match the taste of fresh for stand alone use.

                          i understand the time aspect of separating your own, but suggest that with practice & technique, it's not really an issue. i break an egg into my hand, let the white stream through, and toss the yolk; i wash my hands after handling eggs anyway, so there's very little added time.

                          as to the waste, that depends upon how you look at it. strictly speaking, yes it's wasteful to pitch the yolks. but consider all the additional processing and transport costs something like eggbeaters accrue, then comapre those costs with what fresh eggs go through. if you look at the whole cost, then i think it's less wasteful to toss the yolk than pay all the hidden costs of the commercial product. plus, a dozen fresh eggs are cheaper than a container of eggbeaters (at least where i shop). and it tastes better.

                          also, yolks freeze well. you could accumulate them until you have enough for a yolk-heavy recipe (key lime pie, for example), then use 'em up. if you're avoiding yolks, your friends (assuming you cook/bake well enough) will be happy with your largesse.

                          only other suggestion i have, and i have not tried this, would be to combine a whole egg with one of the alternatives to extend it. you'll be eating a yolk that way, but only one, and if you're lucky, it'll make the commercial product palatable.

                          3 Replies
                          1. re: mark
                            MMRuth Apr 27, 2007 05:14 AM

                            I think egg whites also freeze well - you could do a large batch and then freeze however many you want in individual ziplock bags.

                            1. re: mark
                              rworange Apr 27, 2007 08:27 AM

                              Hope someone has a good suggestion. I didn't find a product in the market that I liked, but there seem to be new ones out there recently.

                              If the commercial egg whites don't work for you, it is easy to separate eggs by using a funnel.

                              For me, it works better than an egg separator and you can break a few eggs and walk away. Looked around on the web to see if anyone else does this and found this from Hormel (scroll down).
                              http://www.hormel.com/templates/knowl...

                              What I do different is put the funnel on the top of an old quart glass mayo jar. That way I don't need to hold the funnel. The mouth of the jar supports the funnel and the whites just drain into the jar. I do 2-3 eggs at a time. After that I've had yolks breaking.

                              Then I just put the lid on the jar and I have egg whites for a week ... I was on a diet thing for a while. Don't know if they keep longer than a week. Never kept them that long.

                              If you were a woman I'd say use the yolks for a facial mask or as a conditioner for hair .. but ...

                              They can always be zapped in the microwave and the cooked yolk fed to wild birds.

                              1. re: mark
                                Adrienne Apr 28, 2007 11:29 AM

                                I agree. And I think that not wanting to throw away the yolks to not be wasteful is great in theory, but that chances are the that there is more waste overall (energy, packaging, possibly even tossing yolks) if we buy egg white that is pre-processed.

                                It would be great if gelato places would sell their leftover whites -- my gelato always takes a bunch of yolks and I always enjoy an eggwhite omelette while the gelato churns. If my local gelataria would sell me their whites I'd be really happy. Maybe I'll ask... :)

                              2. amenidad Apr 26, 2007 10:11 PM

                                Eggology bottles organic egg whites. I used them once when making a massive quanity of meringue and was completely satisfied:
                                https://www.eggology.com/home.htm

                                1 Reply
                                1. re: amenidad
                                  k
                                  kesues Apr 27, 2007 01:23 PM

                                  I have used these as well to make omelets. I find that if you add fresh herbs (or even just as simple as adding herbs de provence) and veggies to the omelet - you don't miss the yolks as much.

                                2. n
                                  nc213 Apr 26, 2007 07:53 PM

                                  Not actually an alternative, but try using fewer as opposed to no yolks. Take your usual 3-egg omelette and make it with two yolks and three whites. when you get used to that, split the second yolk. Eventually, go to 1:3. you can do the same with over easy/ssu and with egg salad.

                                  Sort of like going from whole milk to 1%, eventually the full-fat seems too rich.

                                  2 Replies
                                  1. re: nc213
                                    Jim Leff Apr 26, 2007 09:59 PM

                                    Thanks, but I'm not looking for ways to reconcile to not eating yolks. That's not the issue.

                                    1. re: nc213
                                      rworange Apr 28, 2007 10:23 AM

                                      Maybe someone who tried these can say how they taste, but next to the organic cream cheese I was buying there was a pint sized container of Organic Valley egg whites.
                                      http://www.organicvalley.coop/product...

                                      They are pasturized ... but in their favor they are organic. It was $4.99

                                      Don't know if they sell on the East Coast. Late for an appointent, or I'd check.

                                      Moved this up as far as I could in the thread hoping people will comment on brands rather than advice on how to separate your own egg whites ... which is what you requested.

                                      I'm telling you, the week before this topic I saw about three new brands of egg whites. Just saw the linked whites today.

                                    Show Hidden Posts