HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >


your favorite cheese for grilled cheese sandwiches?

I've been experimenting... whats your favorite?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Anything but american/velveeta/other processed cheeses. My favorite is to use two or three different types, one of which is usually a good sharp cheddar. And ALWAYS butter (not margarine) the bread.

    1 Reply
    1. re: mojoeater

      Yep, I agree, many kinds. Last week, I made on good thick Challah. Prov., munster, sharp cheddar and smoky gouda. Added thin slices of tomato to the middle. I grill 1/2 first and put into the oven to broil the top - tomatoes and 1 slice of the cheese, then add to the other half that's in the pan. This assures the tomato is cooked and the middle of the sammy is melted. YUMMO! I add grainy mustard or a yeh bit of wasabi mayo - can't be beat! :)KQ

      1. re: Jimmy Buffet

        Right there with you. I will occasionally play with others, but I always come back to Kraft slices and Campbell's Tomato soup.

        1. re: ccbweb

          I, too, love Campbell's condensed tomato soup (always with milk and never water). But I just can't get over the non-cheese.

      2. Double Gloucester cheese...Incredible!

        1. Brie or Camembert between French bread. Smoked Gouda between whole wheat or multi-grain. Technically not grilled cheese: grated fresh pecorino on fried organic Russian rye bread.

            1. re: piccola

              Second fontina. Fruilano as well, on a bread with some character and a nice glass of wine. Great meal.

              1. re: pepper_mil

                I actually dig it on fruit and/or nut bread - the crusty European kind, not the soft Sun Maid kind.

            2. I am eating one right now with a big bowl of soup! I like havarti for its melting quality and usually combine it with a sharp cheddar or an aged gouda. I really like it on
              semi- freddi sourdough with good butter. cook slowly in a cast iron skillet.

              3 Replies
              1. re: jdm

                I second the Havarti... it's great with thick crusty bread with mayo & dijon, smoked ham, grilled and a homemade tomato basil soup.

                1. re: missmojito

                  thirding havarti -- with a crusty bread grilled in olive oil and a bit of pepper/kosher salt.

                  1. re: Jeters

                    Oh yeah - love the havarti - - sometimes a little cheddar thrown in as well, on good bread with a quick swipe of honeycup mustard. yum.

              2. Gruyere. (How do I make accents??) It's got a nice nutty undertone, and melts beauuuuuutifully.

                3 Replies
                1. re: chloe103

                  Provolone! Great melting cheese :)

                  1. re: chloe103

                    I second the Gruyere. I also combine it with a sharp cheddar or a pepper jack for a little zing.

                    1. re: chloe103

                      Gruyere for sure. Outside of processed cheeses, none melts better with such little separation of oils/solids.

                    2. I also do a mix - Always Mozzarella for it's beautiful melty texture -- it pairs well with cheddars - mild and sharp, as well as provolone. Surprisingly a mozz and smoked gouda mix is also fantastic.
                      Happy Grilling :)

                      1. If you are willing to branch out beyond the boring.... try an Asadero for a real grilled cheese. You will want to actuall grill or griddle a thick slice of the cheese itself until browned & the center is gooey, then stuff in what ever bread you prefer.

                        1. Havarti. With bacon. And tomato. On seeded rye or sourdough. Butter. Slowly cooked. 3 napkins.

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: Veggo

                            If I am having it with my "classic Cambells Tomatoe Soup" then I simply want American (Orange not white) and I want it on white bread with a tomato...
                            If there is not soup- I love Munster with tomato- it is much stringier than mozzarella cheese and has more flavor...
                            Another really fancy version is with Brie and Munster- best flavors from brie and strings from munster...

                          2. I like pepper jack on rye bread. But I've never met a cheese I didn't like, grilled or not grilled. Haha.

                            1. My two all time favorites:

                              -smoked mozzarella with sundried tomatoes

                              -gruyere with country style mustard and grilled or caramelized onions

                              1 Reply
                              1. Sharp cheddar, either by itself or with something else on buttered sourdough. I like pepper jack, münster, supermarket mozzarella and Havarti. I had some port du salut that was pretty cool, too.

                                Having said that, any grilled cheese on any bread is alright with me when the craving hits. If all I have is good-for-ya bread (like TJ's flourless sprouted wheat), Kraft Slices and margarine, so be it.

                                1. I love sharp, sharp cheddar and tomato but a new favorite of mine is basil pesto and mozzarella. Delicious!

                                  1. Double Gloucestor with Stilton on La Brea Bakery Olive Rosemary bread - divine!

                                    1. Plain old white american. Not Kraft, but the stuff sliced from the deli. Sometimes with a slice of provolone mixed in for extra zing and those cheesy threads.
                                      Butter is a must. Margarine doesn't seem to produce the same result for me.
                                      Soft, white bread.
                                      Thin slices of fresh tomato.

                                      1. Pepper jack (or better yet, habanero jack) on garlic sourdough.

                                        1. Some of my preferences are Vermont extra sharp cheddar on olive bread or sourdough, with optional fresh tomato, basil, sauteed mushrooms, mustard and/or or sauerkraut, depending upon the season. Open faced is great.

                                          1. Velveeta cheese and lots of it with sliced tomatoes grilled with LOTS of butter on white bread and French's mustard. Comfort food at it's best. Terrible for you. So what.

                                            1. Lots of fun replies. This is indeed a project of each of us finding our individual ecstasy in refining a foodstuff that was all too often fabricated for us in less than ideal fashion during our impressionable youth.

                                              Recently there were two adults and two kids in the kitchen and we debated the merits of american cheese versus sharp cheddar, bread type, toasting methods, etc.. We constructed this compromise:

                                              1) Sprouted wheat bread, for a tooth feel of soft wheat kernels against the gooeyness of the melted cheese.

                                              2) Dry toast the sandwich's internal faces in a med-low-heated cast iron pan.

                                              3) Spread a thin thin sheen of mayo on the dry-toasted inside faces.

                                              4) The choice of cheese was a classic compromise: grated white cheddar thinly laid on each interior face, then a slab of american cheese in the middle, to melt and mix between the shreds of the firmer cheddar matrix on each surface. The resulting color contrast between white cheddar shreds and yellow center were noted when we ate.

                                              5) Pepper was applied to the inner face of one half of each sandwich, so that each diner could compare the results of each half for future reference and preference.

                                              6) Grilled with about 1 tsp of butter, with flat metal lid laying on the sandwich, occasionally pressed down softly.

                                              7) Sandwiches were rested for two minute before service.

                                              8) Campbell's tomato soup was the kids' request; the adults added the compromise canned tomatoes and sauted onions, stick blended with a dash of drained yogurt.

                                              9) Sweet gherkins, sliced into strips and chunks and left whole, were presented and devoured as a piquant and crunchy contrast to the toothsome layers of bread and cheese.

                                              10) Table conversation veered at one point to the hair-netted lunch-ladies in school cafeterias who stolidly served up the sheet pans of baked cheese sandwiches. Segues to the concept of Purgatory and Final Justice were encouraged and explored.

                                              2 Replies
                                                1. re: FoodFuser

                                                  using garlic butter or rubbing the bread with garlic before grilling really does the trick

                                                2. Chudder and tomato. I use to have a source for chudder (fresh butter/white cheddar) and sliced fresh Jersey tomato was heaven until the source ran out...now I go for a sharp swiss and tomato.

                                                  1. Muenster with Challah or Egg Bread, lots of butter on all sides of the bread, and toasted in a waffle iron so the cheese oozes out and hardens....

                                                    1. I'm in the Gruyère club. Some paper thin slices of onion, thin slices of tomato (Kitchen Queen makes a mean grill cheese I can tell) a hit of balsamic. On a rustic Italian or French loaf. Grilled with butter (go mojoeater) Then grainy or deli mustard on the side to dip in. I'm salivating just thinking about it. Smoked gouda a close second.

                                                      1. Mmmmmm! A lot of these sound really good, I'll have to keep them in mind as we usually have soup and "grilled cheese"/pannini once a week. Tonight we had provolone with prosciutto on LaBrea's rosemary olive oil bread, that's a old standby for us and it is yummmmy!!!

                                                        1. Kraft Extra-Sharp Cheddar on whole-wheat bread with sunflower seeds on the crust. The bread has to be cut as thin as humanly possible. I'm sorry, but nothing else will do.

                                                          1. Every single one of these sounds absolutely delicious, and I've tried many of them based purely on the contents of my fridge (always *some* kind of cheese)/what kind of bread (always something good) I've had around.

                                                            1. Here's a previous discussion on the very same subject: http://www.chowhound.com/topics/31762...

                                                              9 Replies
                                                              1. re: Ora

                                                                For those who dis American cheese, try using REAL American cheese. Kraft makes it and Kroger has their brand also. It's hard to find...you need to read the labels. Most of what passes as American "cheese" is actually processed cheese food spread, or some such nomenclature. The real stuff is about 2x the cost of the imitation. If it comes in "singles" it's not what you want. I like American grilled with real butter on good bread; my husband adds some Jarlsburg and grilled onion and tomato to his.

                                                                1. re: sudiepav

                                                                  Isn't American cheese by definition... cheese scraps that have been reconstituted into a block (hence processed)?

                                                                    1. re: Eat_Nopal

                                                                      Sounds like a chicken/egg problem. Are you saying American cheese is scraps of other kinds of cheeses reformed into a block? Or is it scraps of American cheese reconstituted? If the latter, where did the first block of American cheese come from if it was made from scraps? If the former, how does it consistant taste the same, is it all made in one giant cheese sawmill that sees equal parts of it's constituant cheeses day in and day out?

                                                                      I'm being silly, but processed cheese is just a cheese that has emulsifiers and coloring added.

                                                                      1. re: Foureyes137

                                                                        The former... if I understand correct American is typically a blend of scraps from common U.S. cheeses like Jack, Cheddar & Mozarella. Why is it consistent? Why are big wineries Cabernet's consistent even though they buy from different growers all the time? I guess if you have enough variety of sources... the variation among tiny portions averages out to consistency for the whole.

                                                                        1. re: Eat_Nopal

                                                                          My most innovative grilled cheese recipe is as follows: Use one or two of these three cheeses.. Gouda, Gruyere or Cheddar. Degree of sharpness depends on your liking. I especially love using smoked Gouda for toasting in a sandwich, along with crispy bacon, deli-style mustard and tomato. Gruyere is exceptionally wonderful when paired with thinly sliced ham or mortadella. I sometimes like to add a few very thin slices of Granny Smith apple to a grilled ham and Gruyere. For these types of sandwich, any high-quality artisan bread works beautifully.

                                                                          1. re: CuzinVinny

                                                                            american or sharp cheddar and something called "english muffin toasting bread" does everyone have that or only the midwest..?
                                                                            I also recently read that using mayo instead of butter spread on the bread for grilling made it better. We tried it and it might be true.

                                                                          2. re: Eat_Nopal

                                                                            I think the differences from bottle to bottle of big botteler cabernet are perceptable. Kraft singles taste like Kraft singles taste like Kraft singles as far as I can tell. I smell a Frontline Investigation!

                                                                            1. re: Foureyes137

                                                                              Whoa... I never said Kraft singles were "real American" cheese. They are definitely industrialized clones. What I was referring to is if you got sliced American from a deli, made by a local dairy in some small mythical town 100 years ago... it would be made from the scraps of common cheeses.

                                                                  1. Good crusty white (sourdough) bread with cheddar/cheddarella ... and ricotta
                                                                    Put cheddar(ella) slices on buttered bread and put each face up in a pan so the cheese can get a little gooey. Put a few dollops of ricotta in the middle of the cheddar(ella) and create the sandwich, making sure to secure and close the edges of the sandwich and allow the cheddar to trap the ricotta in the middle. Press down a little and allow both sides to brown.
                                                                    Optional: Dip in cream of tomato soup.

                                                                    1. Harvarti.

                                                                      Or Saganaki, lightly pan fried, on a piece of toasted dark rye, with lemon juice.

                                                                      1 Reply
                                                                      1. re: purple goddess

                                                                        Sanganaki would certainly be interesting!

                                                                      2. Velveeta!,or American...add pepperjack to either one, always on white cooked in real butter and slathered in Miracle whip...sometimes add ham or bacon...is that my arteries i feel clogging?????,oh and with an ice cold Coke.

                                                                        1. I recently had an awesome goat cheese, feta and cream cheese with tomato at a local place.....wouldn't be my comfort grilled cheese (anything with a good sharp cheddar, white raw milk is awesome!) but it was really good.....and a really different take on it...

                                                                          1. Very basic using the KISS theory:

                                                                            LAND O' LAKES WHITE AMERICAN CHEESE from the deli.

                                                                            1. Good, sharp provolone (the kind that comes wrapped in a wax ball) makes the most excellent grilled cheese ever.

                                                                              1. ChowHappy----Thanks for starting this thread. I can't wait to start experimenting with some of the suggestions.

                                                                                1 Reply
                                                                                1. re: happyhomemaker

                                                                                  it has been really fun to try all of them but beware- your pant size may increase.