Is it possible to buy Cotija cheese anywhere around Toronto (or by mail order)? I bought some in Mexico, at a supermarket in the town of Chapala. It is a grated cheese tasting, in my opinion, something like a combination of Feta and Parmesan, and a welcome change, sprinkled on pasta, from the usual choice of Parmesan or Romano.
A little late from your posting date maybe!!, but I finally found some Cotija cheese at Highland Farms on Rutherford at Hwy 400! IF you contact the manufacturer they can maybe tell you where else in GTA it is available. Brand is Tifco , product of Canada, 16 Fima Cres.,ETOBICOKE, Ontario
M8W 3P9 Téléphone : (416) 253-7200
Nothing guaranteed, but I'd check with the latin places in Kensington like Perola's or Emporium Latino. You can also ask for Queso Anejado which just means aged cheese. There's a Mexican market on the sw corner of Keele and Lawrence called something like Market Tino. You could call them too.