Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Apr 17, 2007 07:58 PM

40th birthday dinner, Beverly area

I'll be in the Boston area with friends, the first weekend in May, and we're looking or a place for a 40th birthday dinner/party, for about 12 adults, 2 babies, and 2 medium sized kids.
We're coming from different parts of the country and the birthday girl doesn't know we're coming.

We are mostly family and a few friends. Four are women requiring special handling, who will not order straight off the menu, and are guaranteed to find something to complain about, no matter the quality of the location, service, or food.

Good wine is a requirement, because one is a winemaker with significant experience, reputation, and attitude.

The rest are people who like good food.

As the evening goes on, there is a good chance the family will devolve into discussions and arguments reaching the shouting stage.

So we need a place with a relatively large private area, great flexibility, a wide variety of choice and price, and child friendly.

Given multiple choices, no one will agree on where to go. The discussion will reach a standoff, at which point one of the sane people will say, "No one can decide, so this is where we're going." We need to have this place planned in advance.

Is there such a place ?

Thank you for any recommendations you can give.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. any type of food? italian, asian, american?? only Beverly, or around the area? is price a factor?

    2 Replies
    1. re: chompie

      Any type of food, but a wide variety of choice would be best, the area or even in Boston itself, and price is not a big factor.

      1. re: Usher73

        I was going to say Toscana in Peabody, but it's Italian so that's the whole variety. Nice room in back tho and very accomodating owners. But if you are open to Boston, this thread will probably now fly with tons of real chowish recs. Maybe repost with Boston in title and you will get swarmed with answers. I know there are some places with major wine cellars etc.

    2. What about that G2 place? Can't speak from experience but it seems like it's one of the nicer places in the Beverly Farms area and should be easy for the picky eaters to find something.

      1. There's a steakhouse - I think it might be Pellana's? - in Peabody/Danvers area, and a new place, Tryst, that a friend just went to last weekend and said she had a great dinner. Don't know about the wine list or size of the latter.

        2 Replies
        1. re: LindaWhit

          Tryst is WAY too small to accommodate your crowd, and most definitely not child friendly. There's only about 10 tables and a very large bar. Fantastic food and wine, though.

          1. re: Trixie Too

            Didn't know the size; just knew my friend and her husband and some friends really enjoyed dinner there last weekend.

        2. Depending on how casual ...and how good the food has to be...Bertucci's might be an option. The one in Peabody, on Rt 1, has a back room that would be perfect and they have just added a grill for steaks.etc. Your boisterous family couldn't possibly be out of place there. The wine list isn't great but there are a few acceptable wines at decent prices.

          Much more a last resort than a special birthday destination.

          1. --Capital Grille just opened up at a the Wayside Commons in Burlington--always great wine there and you may even possible get a semi private room there.

            --FINZ in salem, i think, is a pretty good. Its in Pickering Wharf in salem and i think it has a great atmospehere. Its a pretty open restaurant and have dined there a bunch of times--relaxing atmospehere, good for people of all ages, inlcuding children. The food is pretty conisistent. As a lobstor ravioli fanatic, i think their rendition is quite delish. The wine list is pretty good sized too. There is a little something for everyone on the menu---from raw bar to chicken. This may be a good choice for your type of group if you dont decide to take a ride into boston.

            Enjoy your stay in Bevtown.